Top Stories

American Idol 5 Top 16

American Idol 5 Top 16

Weren’t last night’s American Idol 5 eliminations entirely expected?  The four contestants to get the boot were Heather Cox, 22, David Radford, 17, Jose "Sway" Penala, 28 and Brenna Gethers, 25.  And deservingly so, their performances put me straight to sleep last night.  ZZZ.  Who should be the next four to go?  Melissa McGhee, Kinnik Sky, Kevin Covais and Will Makar.  And it’s going to be a fight to the finish but here are my top 6 — Paris Bennett, Mandisa Hundley, Kellie Pickler, Lisa Tucker, Ace Young and Taylor Hicks.  Who are your top 6, America? More pictures in the gallery!

The four hopeful contestants to get the boot last night — Heather Cox,
 David Radford, Jose "Sway" Penala and
Brenna Gethers.
Like Just Jared on Facebook
american idol girls
american idol guys
american idol season 5 final 24
american idol top 16 new
american idol top 16
american idol top 24 01
american idol top 24 02
american idol top 24 03
american idol top 24 04
american idol top 24 05
american idol top 24 06
american idol top 24 07
american idol top 24 08
american idol top 24 09
american idol top 24 10
american idol top 24 11
american idol top 24 12
american idol top 24 13
american idol top 24 14
american idol top 24 15
american idol top 24 16
american idol top 24 17
american idol top 24 18
american idol top 24 19
american idol top 24 20
american idol top 24 21
american idol top 24 22
american idol top 24 23
american idol top 24 24
american idol z ace young
ayla brown
becky odonohue
bobby bennett
brenna gethers
bucky covington
chris daughtry
david radford
elliott yamin
gedeon mckinney
heather cox
jose penala
katharine mcphee
kellie pickler
kevin covais
kinnik sky
lisa tucker
mandisa hundley
melissa mcghee
paris bennett
patrick hall
stevie scott
taylor hicks
will makar

JJ Links Around The Web

  • Ryan Adams performed a ballad after his split from Mandy Moore- US Weekly
  • Richard Simmons got a visit from cops, who say he is fine- TMZ
  • Watch Blake Shelton perform “Boys ’Round Here” on SNL- Gossip Cop
  • See cute videos of R5 at Sundance Film Festival- Just Jared Jr
  • Gia Giudice made a tribute video for her mom Teresa- Radar
  • What should you know about Sundance Film Festival?- Huffington Post
  • Read a review of The Boy Next Door- Lainey Gossip
  • Who just got cast in Quentin Tarantino's Hateful Eight?- The Hollywood Reporter

14 Responses to “American Idol 5 Top 16”

  1. 1
    Barry Says:

    I think you got it all wrong, CHRIS DAUGHTRY is going to be the winner of the whole thing.. I was sad to see the crooner go last night

  2. 2
    Abbey Says:

    I like Taylor Hicks – he’s different, unique and you can tell he absolutely loves music

  3. 3
    Kim Says:

    My favorites are McPhee, Daughtry, Hicks, and Tucker. I hope one of those wins!It was good to see Sway go. And Heather! BRENNA! I’m so glad she’s gone! Now I can watch it without getting annoyed! Well… Ace is still there so I will still be annoyed but he’s not as loud as her!

  4. 4
    shannon Says:

    Was Paula drunk last night?

  5. 5
    Jamie Says:

    Yeah, Paula was totally drunked and drugged up. My favorites are Mandisa, Paris, Chris, Elliot and Katharine.

  6. 6
    Jamie Says:


  7. 7
    kirsten Says:

    you forgot about Chris in your top 6! but I totally agree on your pick for next weeks 4 to get kicked off

  8. 8
    j Says:

    i watch the show for chris daughtry. i hope he wins the whole thing. im so glad that brenna chick got voted off. she was insanely annoying.

  9. 9
    Zela Says:

    my pick for the final 6 are Taylor, Chris, Elliot, Ace, Mandisa and Lisa. And the winner will be a guy for sure….

  10. 10
    design_officer Says:

    can’t stand taylor. i think he’s totally fake and playing a part. my vote is for the amish dude.

  11. 11
    Kelly K Says:

    My favorites are Katharine Mcphee and Chris Daughtry. I think they will be in the top 3! I was right about Carrie Underwood last year from her first audition! It’s clear when someone’s got it, and they’ve got it. Chris Daughtry has never even had voice lessons! That’s impressive!

  12. 12
    Kelly K Says:

    Oh and YES btw..what’s up with Paula? She couldn’t even get her sentence out. She looked like an idiot being that drunk! Well, it could have been lots of things, but I’m assuming alcohol! She does strike me as a lush for some reason. She does cry a lot and she’s very emotional. All traits of a drunk!

  13. 13
    Melina Earnest Says:

    I like every on in the top 12 but Taylor and Katharine I didn’t want to see melissa go. Out of the top 16 I really liked will, he was awesome.

  14. 14
    Tanya Says:

    Chris Daughtry is BY FAR the most talented male on this years American Idol, he will be your winner, I have picked them every season since Kelly and don’t doubt it will be Chris HE’S GOT IT!!

A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News | Advertise here