Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: Stella McCartney Dress

Fashion Faceoff: Stella McCartney Dress

To the left, Sienna Miller wears a Stella McCartney creation during a cocktail party in Santa Monica, Calif. back in January.

To the right, Liv Tyler wears a simliar Stella minidress at a Bergforf Goodman event in New York City on Thursday.

Who wears it best? SIENNA MILLER or LIV TYLER?

Just Jared on Facebook

JJ Links Around The Web

Getty
  • RHONY star Bethenny Frankel is suing her ex husband for full custody of their daughter - TMZ
  • Dove Cameron and Thomas Doherty celebrate their one year anniversary - Just Jared Jr
  • GLAAD slams Megyn Kelly failing the LGBTQ community - TooFab
  • Mario Batali has been accused of groping by two more former employees - The Hollywood Reporter
  • The cast of 13 Reasons Why celebrate Katherine Langford's Golden Globes nomination - Just Jared Jr
  • Sophie

    They are really different dresses Jared.

  • MMM

    Liv, she is gorgeous!

  • bdj

    Both dresses are cute. I like Stella McCartney designs. She is one of my favorite and unique designers.

  • Mary

    Liv def. wears it better. The other one on Sienna looks kind of heavy and shes just carrying the dress around. Not flattering

  • Kellie

    Liv Tyler is beautiful.
    You could dress her in a sack and she’d still look elegant!

  • ned

    love ‘em both!

  • Yily

    neither. both women are beautiful but those dresses are hideous.

  • [Fug Face........]

    Liv – beautiful – better dress.

    Haha @ sienna.

  • Who Cares

    I think they both look good…Stella does make beautiful clothes :)

  • Anthony

    Liv,she’s always classy and gorgeous.Sienna can ruin anything..

  • Elle

    Liv, Liv, Liv!

    That girl is a real beauty!

  • Raichill

    Liv looks better. Sienna’s legs look like my grandmother’s legs, all bony and knobbly.

  • angelah

    Liv

  • vbn

    Sienna you guys are crazy if you think that liv looks better!

  • Lucie

    Liv looks soooo cute and pretty! I love love her hair and makeup and shoes. Just everything is perfection.
    Sienna, on the other hand, looks like she’s wearing one of ‘em wooden beaded carseat covers. And her shoes are terrible

  • thiscoupleisboring

    i would bang siennas face off.

  • Snarky Sharky

    Liv looks so much better

  • amangel

    Liv, definitelly, design of her dress is better and she really knows how to wear things, not let things just hang on her.

  • Pole

    Liv for sure.

  • http://dkjfwekjnc4.com cat

    Sienna because of the skin color

  • Lila

    Liv. She’s always so peaches and cream.

    Why is Sienna so orange? Why is Sienna’s forehead so shiny? Why are Sienna’s legs so much darker than the rest of her (seriously, they’re Terror Alert orange-red!)? Why is Sienna famous?

  • http://ackles-guide.com Bibi

    Both. But, Sienna is fabulous.

  • Roxy

    I think I prefer it on Katie Cassidy! She’s gorgeous!

    http://www.kcassidy.net/gallery/albums/userpics/10001/hqpremiere02.jpg

  • http://justjared fighter

    SIENNA SIENNA SIENNA…..of course sienna miller…..

  • Melody

    Liv Tyler is much more elegant than Sienna will ever be, and she wears that dress perfectly contrary to the British wannabe-actress

  • the real tita

    Love Liv Tyler. I thought she was a model until I looked closer. And Sienna? didn’t even register until after reading the caption.

  • http://www.judao.com.br Valzinha

    Well…
    To be honest, I didnt like the dresses, they look like my kitchens curtains.
    Anyway, I prefer Liv. She is a mom and still looks stunning.
    and BTW, Katie Cassidy looks better in that dress, indeed.
    I just think Liv is skinny. She needs more flesh in her bones.

  • Ryan

    Liv. Her shoes are better, and she has the body confidence to pull off a hideous, shapeless, heavy shift dress. she doesn’t have to push herself to be “on” like sienna seems to. sienna just looks super awkward.

  • none

    I hate both dresses. If I had to pick, even though I love Liv, I would be pick Sienna, whom I loathe.

  • Tweek

    Liv…just because i hate sienna and every other girl who gets into the business by other people’s lives! Gwenyth paltrow…..sienna…..and anyone else who dated their way into hollywood. Don’t care if they were in love either, still isn’t fair to anyone else who doesn’t have that “a list” boyfriend to help their career.

  • http://www.livtyler-online.com Sandra

    Although I don’t really like the dresses themselves, I have to say Liv wears hers with more grace. I think she has the stature and elegance to pull off a dress like that. Sienna just looks flimsy to me.

  • cal

    liv all the way

  • zuz

    Liv because she is so classy

  • http://liv-tyler.mylog.pl/ Martina

    Liv is loooooooooooovelyyyyyyyyyy

  • Sandra

    KATIE CASSIDY got that dress befor they did.
    And she is more beautiful in that dress !

  • http://marke.blog.cz Markéta

    Liv

  • http://justjared.com pinklova

    liv is my fav she looks beatiful ♥♥♥