Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: Jay Godfrey Dress

Fashion Faceoff: Jay Godfrey Dress

Eva Mendes wore a black one-strap Jay Godfrey frock with strappy sandals to the Spike TV Awards in December.

Heroes hottie Hayden Panettiere, donned the same $495 silk frock in eggplant for Entertainment Weekly‘s UpFront Party in New York City on Tuesday.

Who wore it best — EVA MENDES or HAYDEN PANETTIERE?

Like Just Jared on Facebook
eva longoria alice olivia dress 01
eva longoria alice olivia dress 02
eva longoria alice olivia dress 03
eva longoria alice olivia dress 04
eva longoria alice olivia dress 05
eva mendes jay godfrey dress 01
eva mendes jay godfrey dress 02
eva mendes jay godfrey dress 03
eva mendes jay godfrey dress 04
eva mendes jay godfrey dress 05
hayden panettiere alice olivia dress 01
hayden panettiere alice olivia dress 02
hayden panettiere alice olivia dress 03
hayden panettiere alice olivia dress 04
hayden panettiere alice olivia dress 05
hayden panettiere jay godfrey dress 01
hayden panettiere jay godfrey dress 02
hayden panettiere jay godfrey dress 03
hayden panettiere jay godfrey dress 04
hayden panettiere jay godfrey dress 05

Credit: People; Photos: Getty/Frazer Harrison/Evan Agostini
Posted to: Eva Mendes, Fashion Faceoff, Hayden Panettiere

JJ Links Around The Web

Larry Busacca/Getty

25 Responses to “Fashion Faceoff: Jay Godfrey Dress”

  1. 1
    [Fug Face [You]] Says:

    Hayden!!!

  2. 2
    Langtry Says:

    Eva. Hayden’s lovely, but the look is too old, too sophisticated for a teenager to carry off.

  3. 3
    Isabelle Says:

    obviously Eva Mendes is way way much better…
    the color, the length, the shoes, the tan, the rouge…
    but i’m not that crazy about the bag.

  4. 4
    mytwocents Says:

    Eva all the way, too hot…she carries this look perfectly. Hayden is still too young for this dress.

  5. 5
    Maureen Says:

    Eva hands down. Looks totally elegant on Eva and kind of awkward and ill-fitting on Hayden. Hayden always looks great but she’s so tiny the dress swallows her up. I think the dress itself no matter who is wearing it is better in black

  6. 6
    bella Says:

    eva duh.

  7. 7
    Nando Says:

    Eva.

  8. 8
    Kaylita Says:

    Hayden is too short to pull the dress off. Eva looks soo much better!

  9. 9
    Mariana Says:

    EVA!

  10. 10
    LUV EVA Says:

    Eva hands down!, she has worn lots of fabulous clothes,not the best pic of Eva but Eva is a fashion diva most times.Hayden seems to be wearing clothes that are to aged for her,she’d look better in hot clothes that fit her age.Shes got a great shape.Just need to find her nix.

  11. 11
    ZzaRaZza Says:

    Eva is classy in black, and the shoes are great. Not the best look on Hayden.

  12. 12
    Chris Says:

    Eva

  13. 13
    cook Says:

    Eva.

  14. 14
    Kibbell Says:

    Hayden should start wearing clothes to fit her age. She looks way too grown up.

  15. 15
    any Says:

    eva

  16. 16
    f Says:

    Eva

  17. 17
    Hana Says:

    Easily Eva Mendes

  18. 18
    Alisha Says:

    See Eva? She’s LAUGHING at the notion that anyone could pull off that dress better than she does.

  19. 19
    Anne Says:

    Uhhhh . . . EVA!!?!! Hayden’s cute as all get out (and getting prettier all the time), and unlike some, I’ve got no problem with her weight/body type. But the idea, for everybody (even Charlize!) is to wear stuff that flatters you … sadly, Hayden’s choice here makes her look like a little fireplug (why de-emphasize your cute shape?!)

  20. 20
    Julie Says:

    Eva did but that style of dress it just not flattering. It’s like maternity wear!

  21. 21
    EVA-DA-DIVA Says:

    EVA IS A DIVA THATS RIGHT,Eva wears some fierce clothes!!Go with your bad self EVA Dear.Hayden fire your stylist hon you could have smokin clothes on that cute petite bod with the right stylist,Go Hayden..fire that stylist little mama!

  22. 22
    bunny Says:

    i adore hayden but that eggplant dress does not suit her at all. it makes her arms look chunkier.

  23. 23
    Jen Says:

    Definitely Eva!

  24. 24
    jade Says:

    hayden definitely
    eva looks like a man

  25. 25
    chleseaJB4ever Says:

    HAYDEN P!

A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News | Advertise here