Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: Tadashi Minidress

Fashion Faceoff: Tadashi Minidress

To the left, American Idol 5 runner-up Katharine McPhee rocked out a Tadashi beaded minidress int he June 2007 issue of Vegas magazine.

To the right, teen queen Hilary Duff wore the same minidress (available at Tadashi, The Forum Shops at Caesars) for her Star magazine photo shoot.

Who wore it best — KATHARINE MCPHEE or HILARY DUFF?

Just Jared on Facebook

JJ Links Around The Web

WENN
  • Chester Bennington may be buried next to longtime friend Chris Cornell - TMZ
  • Camila Cabello debuted a brand new song in concert - Just Jared Jr
  • Katie Holmes took Suri to see Dear Evan Hansen - TooFab
  • American Horror Story season 7 finally has a title - The Hollywood Reporter
  • Troian Bellisario is glad films are starting a conversation about eating disorders - Just Jared Jr
  • maz

    hilary duff

  • [Famous Fug Face]

    Katharine McPhee!!!!

    Where is Hilary’s Ug face disappearing to?

  • MJ

    Hilary

  • Jim

    This one’s a tie. :)

  • Mel

    McPhee, by a long shot. Hilary looks cute, but damn if Katharine doesn’t looks like a babe and a half.

  • Diana

    Hilary looks more classy, Katherine looks a bit trashy. Like neither, anyway….

  • T

    Hilary, I like the picture/color/lighting more.

  • Kelly D

    They both look nice in it, very cool dress.

  • Ashleigh

    Hilary’s coloring, hair and makeup go better and she looks classier in it but Katherine fills it out better and looks sexy. It seems much more suited for a woman older than Hilary but she looks good.

  • Sarah

    Katherine and it’s not even close.

  • kate.

    waoh. the look the same.

  • WHATTHE?

    wow, to me…they look like the same person w/ different lighting. I’m gonna pick KMcP here, simply because I can see the whole outfit….she’s only winning my vote by default, though…if i could see more than a sleeve in the HD pic, it might be another story….

  • Lolly Pop

    I can’t believe I’m going to write this but, Hilary Duff!

  • Cynthia

    Hilary

  • BO

    Ew, that Katherine thing is FAT!

  • freak

    K MCPHEE IS F – A – T

  • KarenA

    Hilary Duff.

  • Sarah

    15 and 16 – idiots.

  • veronica

    neither, this dress is HIDEOUS. rachel zoe would not approve. katherine is not fat, i think she’s been losing weight actually, but she looks good. she still looks somewhat curvy WHICH IS A WONDERFUL THING, but she is also slender.

  • Indie

    Hilary, even though I am not a fan of hers, whatsoever.

  • gee

    Hillary,and she looks really pretty.Katherine looks to much like a young Terri Hatcher on the pic.not a bad thing,but her bod looks nice.

  • erica

    hilary

  • Ali

    Katharine

  • Alicia

    maybe its been photoshopped to death, but the bridge of Duff’s nose has been shaved WAY down. or perhaps she really had a nose job…

  • [Famous Fug Face]

    [15] [16] are you trying to fool someone?

  • Christine

    i say Hilary as well

  • http://www.veece.com Fresh Raggedy Anne

    Hilary is perttier but you cant see the dress on her so how do you compare? Katherine’s boobs look nice so I’ll say Katherine…

    http://WWW.VEECE.COM

  • Nando

    The one who has more breasts!

  • [Famous Fug Face]

    Hilary is the ugliest celebrity – dead or alive.

  • frs730

    KAT

  • christie

    MCPHEEVER FOR SURE!!LOL

  • [Famous Fug Face]

    Yeah Hilary’s on crack, she has the official crack-head-sucked-in-cheeks.

  • vbn

    hilary

  • Michael C

    Hilary, duh.

  • JustCheckin

    Couldn’t compare unless both are doing the same pose. Here… K is very sexy…Hilary is more natural.

  • LostGirl

    Looks nothing like Katherine. Her face looks weird. Her body looks good but Hilary really shines in her pic. Just can’t see the rest of the dress, which sucks.

  • sexiboi

    katharine mcphever ofcourse!

  • 2985

    Hillary, her face looks better, the lighting’s better. McPhee’s face and pose try too hard, and even though she’s a pretty gal, her face looks quite masculine/almost tranny-like in that pic.

  • Jesse

    wow Kat wons she is so hotttt i wish she could be my girl hehehe

  • Melody

    Hilary Duff.

  • J3$$!C@

    Katharine > Hilary

  • Kylie

    HILARY DUFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • abby

    hilary she looks way better even though you cant see the whole dress the lighting is better and it makes the dress just shine.

  • Anna

    EWW Kat looks like a whore!!
    GO HILARY!!! Hil looks 100% better

  • sharkyy

    Kat Mcphee is the hottest woman ever.

  • M M

    I say Hilary. She looks a lot more classy.

  • Molly

    Hilary.

  • Jenna

    Hilary for sure.
    Sorry Kat fans.
    And whoever said Hil was on crack…you are frickin retarded! Hilary is prbably the only same teen star right now. She will never to go jail or rehab. Trust me, look at her career vs all those other girls. Hilary hasnt been stumbling out of clubs crazy drunk or anything. Her cheeks are pressed in cuz thats how she a) poses, and b) she lost weight and you would know that it makes your face different if you lost some of your fat ass.

  • Jenna

    *sane

  • Tiff

    Kath looks werid…so I say Hilary…plus hilary is amazingly beautiful!!