Top Stories

Sarah Michelle's Eyes Send Up Smoke

Sarah Michelle's Eyes Send Up Smoke

Sarah Michelle Gellar (in Donna Karan) plays up her eye shadow to the max, giving her best smoky eyes at the Vaseline “Skin is Amazing” exhibit at The Glass House in NYC’s Chelsea Art Tower on Tuesday.

Sarah Michelle, 30, is the latest nude spokesmodel for Vaseline. Amanda Bynes is a former spokesmodel for the petroleum jelly brand.

DO YOU THINK SMG overdid it with the eye shadow?

10+ pictures inside of Sarah Michelle Gellar‘s smoky eye shadow…

Just Jared on Facebook
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 01
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 02
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 03
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 04
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 05
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 06
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 07
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 08
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 09
sarah michelle gellar eyeshadow 10

Photos: Brad Barket/Getty Images for Vaseline
Posted to: Sarah Michelle Gellar

JJ Links Around The Web

  • George Lopez got into a fight with a Trump supporter at Hooters - TMZ
  • This singer is taking a break from social media - Just Jared Jr
  • Busy Philipps is spilling set secrets from Dawson's Creek - TooFab
  • This comedian is coming to Daniel Craig's aid - Lainey Gossip
  • Little Mix just released the track list for their upcoming album - Just Jared Jr
  • Taylor Swift isn't secretly engaged - Gossip Cop
  • God


  • Tina

    she is gorgeous.

  • Toni

    I think she looks beautiful.

  • God

    She has the look as to say (with concern)I hope the bionic woman will be back soon. :)

  • Lola

    She looks ridiculous. A bit too much like a corpse. Next time she should try putting a little bit of color on her lips.

  • b

    she pretty, but it looks like someone gave her two black eyes.

  • xxxxx

    she looks really pretty but i’m biased becuase every time i see i remember buffy so it’s impossible for me to think badly of her.

  • Anya

    sexy … i like it … =)

  • ewwww

    she’s not very attractive is she. haha

  • Freddie

    she’s always gorgeous and stylish. love her.

  • Pij

    Ugly and ridiculous make-up. Awful…

  • Arab.Aquarius

    Ah, I have to admit its a tad too dramatic. But I love her anyway

  • mia

    She looks like a corpse. This isn’t Buffy S6. Tone down the shadow and put some colored lipstick on.

  • Tracy

    She’s totally fugly.

  • Tanda

    She definitely did NOT overdo it. She looks great.

  • Jo

    She looks stylish, a bit of a color on her lips wouldn’t have been bad but she looks amazing anyways ! <3

  • abc

    I don´t like her, it´s like a boy in those pictures

  • OBfan

    … soo sweet!!!

  • Maria (Shorty)

    Loooove the eye makeup. She wears it well.

  • the shiznack

    bionic woman has been canned *God*

  • operaghost

    She needs to fire her makeup artist for making her look so AWFUL!!! On second thought, maybe just a stern word about experimentation. She usually looks so fresh and beautiful, but this is like a textbook example a mother would use when giving a teenage daughter lessons on how much is too much.

  • Justine

    Yes fire the make-up artist!!! It looks like she’s been dead for a few days!!!
    She has droopy eyes!

  • http://tyyyyyyyyyyyyyttttttttikdj not good.

    oy -not good not -good at all-, its as if a crackhead with crayola’s went mad on her face..eww.. that pancake ages her..she couldnt have look in a mirror be4 she ventured out..

  • elliott

    i think she looks awesome. Different. Yo always need to spice it up. i like it.

  • jessicaMISERALBAhasFLEES

    I don’t usually advocate plastic surgery unless it is necessary.. However, Sarah Michelle Gellar seriously needs a nose job.

    She would be pretty if her nose were smaller. It takes up too much of her face.

    A nose job and she would look great!

    Quite frankly I think Freddy Prinze, Jr. is gay!!

  • mANDY

    She looks terrible to be honest.
    I think she’s very beautiful but the whole make-up thing she has going on, just a NO!

  • Helena

    Sue the makeup stylist. IMMEDIATELY!

  • liz86000

    She looks beautiful!!!! Really nice. It’s cool to change sometimes, and this look is great on her.

  • Catherine

    Definitely looks like Night of the Living Dead there. Too much shadow on the inner corner of the eyes. Spreading it all the way to her nose like that gives her that dead “hollowed-out ” look.

  • wtf


  • required

    please people never forget: DO NOT PUT MAKEUP ON WHEN DRUNK.

  • nikki

    I love her but she looks like she’s trying way too hard!

  • jacinta

    at least it takes the focus away from her butt-ugly nose!

  • Rosanna

    In this pic, she looks like a raccoon!

  • wtf

    The makeup “artist” should burn her/his brushes. Horrible.

  • bataglio

    extended too far to the nose and too far down for her eye shape (droopy). if she does master the smoky eye, it doesn’t appear to be a bad look for her.

  • trish

    She looks great as usual.

  • samara

    where is her husband? what happened to him

  • savannah

    the power of advertising…..i certainly WON’T be buying vaseline now. vaseline sure got it wrong this time.

  • Nando

    Amanda’s so cute!!!!

  • lauralancome

    Too much make-up Sarah; it makes you looks ten years older. Vaseline is all about simplicity; you’re destroying your message with the heavy pancake foundation and black beyond smoke eyes.

  • lala_girl

    I love Amanda! she rocks!

  • Uh… wtf?

    She just crawled out of the grave. ONOEZ!!1

  • ?

    Two of my favourite actresses. Not a fan of Sarah’s make-up. Amanda looks gorgeous as always

  • Mary

    Sarah Gellar look UGLY always, because she have huge ugly nose, sad eyes, big ears, hole in neck and scaliosos!!! She have short body and short leggs and Hump in right part of shis back. Make up at this pics scary and she look like vampire!!!