Top Stories

Fashion Faceoff: Jenny Packham Dress

Fashion Faceoff: Jenny Packham Dress

Leona Lewis performed her hit song “Better In Time” and then posed in the press room wearing a black sequined cocktail dress at the 2008 American Music Awards in Los Angeles on Sunday.

Earlier this month, Ashley Tisdale wore the same sparkly Packham dress during the premiere of High School Musical 3: Senior Year at the Village Jam Factory in Melbourne, Australia.

Who wore it best — LEONA LEWIS or ASHLEY TISDALE?

Just Jared on Facebook
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 01
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 02
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 03
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 04
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 05
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 06
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 07
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 08
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 09
leona lewis ashley tisdale jenny packham 10

Credit: RCFA; Photos: Frederick M. Brown/Vince Bucci/Lucas Dawson/Getty
Posted to: Ashley Tisdale, Fashion Faceoff, Leona Lewis

JJ Links Around The Web

  • Leah Jenner officially files for divorce from husband Brandon - TMZ
  • The stars of Riverdale are teasing season 3 - Just Jared Jr
  • Lisa Vanderpump is getting called out by one of her Real Housewives of Beverly Hills castmates - TooFab
  • The new trailer for the Transformers spin-off is out now - Lainey Gossip
  • Camila Cabello is hard at work on her second album - Just Jared Jr
  • This former Disney Channel star was reportedly considered for the American Idol reboot - Gossip Cop
  • Sam

    ashley looks so much better!!!!!

  • dee


  • me

    hate the dresss…ashley tho

  • eh

    that dress look ugly period!!!

  • Jacob E. sanchez

    Ashley wore it the best.

  • elizabeth

    love ash

  • elizabeth

    love ash

  • #1


  • Carly


  • Janelle

    Leona Lewis for sure, she has the body for it and she fills it out more unlike Ashley who’s a complete stick.

  • ass


  • pop86

    Ashley wins

  • amanda

    ashley for su-re!

  • sharri

    i abolutely love ashley but i think the dress looks better on Leona cuz she fills the dress out

  • Anne


  • massie

    leona lewis wore it wayyyyyy better!! it actually fits her unlike on ashley its like baggy and weirddd! and it looks cute with the tights

  • julie

    leona lewis! ashley does not have boobs, and it looks to baggy on her.

  • ….


  • doh

    leona obviosly….ashley have short legs

  • kate

    Taylor Swift wore this dress in gold to the VMA’s. I like it best on her!



  • michele

    ashley for the win!

  • Anonymous

    JJ, it should be “Who wore it BETTER,” not “Who wore it best”

    leona lewis. def.

  • zanessa fan

    of course Ashley
    she looks gorgeous!!!
    and she is the best!
    Ash rocks! lol
    vashley fan xd =]

  • Jennifer w


  • um

    Leona, she actually has a body too fill it out vs. ashley and her no boobs

  • Gossip-girl

    Are you kidding me? It’s obviously Leona! Her body fills it out, on Ashley the dress just looks weird. The lines on the dress just makes her body look like a square.

  • obviously


    Normal body, sweet, real vocal talent compared to a fake nose, no chest, squeaky failure of an attempt at a singer. No contest there.

  • obviously

    Although it should be noted that the dress on it’s own is pretty hideous anyway, despite whoever it’s on.

  • dina

    i love ashley but on a serious fashion view leonna.
    ashley doesnt have the right body for the dress.

  • Karen

    Ashley wins the day on this one.

  • Jean

    Leona for sure. One person sat there and made all those post. Look at the time on each post.
    That makes this voting rubbish.
    This is ridiculous. The dress don’t even fit Ashley. It’s hanging off her like it was brought for some one else.

  • Chris

    Has to be Leona. I love Ashley but the dress looks like a potato sack on her. Albeit a sequinned potato sack.

  • OkinawaStud

    Ashley’s look better on my bed room floor the next morning.

  • me

    Ashley. Without a doubt


    ash looks amazing and she is sooo beautiful!!!!
    wait ash always wears everything the best!!

  • RENO

    Ashley could kiss my ass

  • ina

    LEONA LEWIS!!!!!!!

  • kaat


  • girlleader1


  • V-Factory SoCal


  • OOO


  • fashion addict

    ASHLEY ASHLEY ASHLEY. Leona’s legs look really fat and she looks way to covered up. Love her music though

  • zanessafan4eva17

    leona for sure she feels it out more. on ashley it looked as though the dress swallowed her up so offense ash. but leona kilt it ( that’s slang for she rocked it the best)

  • AC

    Leona, girls need curves!!!!
    It just hangs on that skinny little toothpick

  • Lilianne

    the two are beatiful,but Leona fills it much better,
    But seriusly people,why are some of you saying if fake nose and real vocal talent and bla bla….This is who wears the dress better remember?no who is better of the two.
    Some people don’t have life and try to fill it trying to star fight,how pathetic

  • Bailey

    The dress looks a little to big for ashlee. she has no boobs no offence but leona has the right body shape and it fits her better so id say leona wears It better!

  • Stephie!


  • michelle

    Hate the dress but ASHLEY!

  • sara