Top Stories

Cynthia Nixon: Being Gay was a Choice for Me

Cynthia Nixon: Being Gay was a Choice for Me

Cynthia Nixon is speaking out about the controversy about her relationships with her college sweetheart, Danny Mozes, and her current partner, Christine Marinoni.

The 45-year-old actress, who currently stars in Wit on Broadway, was profiled in the New York Times.

“I gave a speech recently, an empowerment speech to a gay audience, and it included the line ‘I’ve been straight and I’ve been gay, and gay is better.’ And they tried to get me to change it, because they said it implies that homosexuality can be a choice. And for me, it is a choice. I understand that for many people it’s not, but for me it’s a choice, and you don’t get to define my gayness for me,” Cynthia said.

“A certain section of our community is very concerned that it not be seen as a choice, because if it’s a choice, then we could opt out. I say it doesn’t matter if we flew here or we swam here, it matters that we are here and we are one group and let us stop trying to make a litmus test for who is considered gay and who is not,” she added.

“I am very annoyed about this issue. Why can’t it be a choice? Why is that any less legitimate? It seems we’re just ceding this point to bigots who are demanding it, and I don’t think that they should define the terms of the debate,” Cynthia concluded.

Like Just Jared on Facebook

JJ Links Around The Web

  • Ryan Adams performed a ballad after his split from Mandy Moore- US Weekly
  • Richard Simmons got a visit from cops, who say he is fine- TMZ
  • Watch Blake Shelton perform “Boys ’Round Here” on SNL- Gossip Cop
  • See cute videos of R5 at Sundance Film Festival- Just Jared Jr
  • Gia Giudice made a tribute video for her mom Teresa- Radar
  • What should you know about Sundance Film Festival?- Huffington Post
  • Read a review of The Boy Next Door- Lainey Gossip
  • Who just got cast in Quentin Tarantino's Hateful Eight?- The Hollywood Reporter

65 Responses to “Cynthia Nixon: Being Gay was a Choice for Me”

  1. 1
    Liz Says:

    She’s completely right.

  2. 2
    Annie Says:

    Sooooo… she’s essentially bisexual. I *kinda* get what she’s saying – all homosexual people shouldn’t automatically be lumped into the same box. For some it may be a conscious “choice” while others know they were born that way and one isn’t less valid than the other. If I understood what she’s trying to say that is.

  3. 3
    David Says:

    That means you’re bisexual, Cynthia.

  4. 4
    BEAN Says:

    I think she is bisexual, but to be honest there is no reason for anyone to criticise her. Sexuality is a personal thing. If you’re telling others to mind their own business then mind your own.

  5. 5
    June Says:

    She’s right. It is a choice, you choose to be with men or women. No one is born gay or straight. Thank you Cynthia

  6. 6
    Andrea Says:

    ok miranda

  7. 7
    Drew Says:

    This is a statement I’ve been eagerly anticipating. I’m reminded of Colin Powell’s endorsement of Obama back in 2008, when he didn’t simply refute that Obama was Muslim, but reminded everyone it wouldn’t matter if he was. It was a missing piece of the conversation.

    Nixon, an always articulate advocate for LGBT rights, making this point publicly is significant. The conversation has become one of semantics when it should be about common sense, decency, and equality. Homosexuality is real and every bit as worthy as heterosexuality, no matter the hows or whys.

  8. 8
    Mimi Says:

    @David: Yeah, I agree and I’m not hatin’. I don’t care who she sleeps with, but I think she’s bisexual. I’m straight and couldn’t just decide to eat ***** tomorrow. It’s not in my nature or genes or whatever you want to call it.

  9. 9
    Jennica Panettiere Says:

    Well on the one hand I want to scream at her and say, “JUST TELL PEOPLE YOURE A BISEXUAL WHO PREFERS WOMEN”.

    But on the other hand, many women leave their husbands to be with other women and genuinely fall in love with them even though their WHOLE LIVES they considered themselves STRAIGHT. I have no idea how you can do that, but it’s possible I assume and it’s simply a case of ‘if only you walked a mile in my shoes’ so judge not les ye be judged.

  10. 10
    A Says:

    Good god, some people annoy the hell out of me. No Cynthia is NOT bisexual. Stop being condescending and listen to what she is saying! For *her* it WAS a choice. For *you* it might not have been a choice.
    You are complaining about the “oppressor” but at the same time oppressing one of your own!
    We are all different, why can’t we embrace that instead of punishing others for not being like us.

  11. 11
    Jennica Panettiere Says:

    @Jennica Panettiere: Regarding my first comment, I say that because there are people who dont believe in bisexuality and she could be an advocate for that. But she considers herself gay, so meh.

  12. 12
    Mimi Says:

    @A: OK, then by your definiition she’s just a ****?

  13. 13
    Mimi Says:

    @A: OK, so by your definition she’s just a s l u t who will sleep with anyone?

  14. 14
    cal Says:

    is being a clueless moron who doesn’t understand how sexuality works also a choice for her, or does that come naturally? only a bisexual person would be able to “choose” one or the other.

  15. 15
    A Says:

    @Mimi: No you fcking idiot, re read what I wrote! She is exactly what she say she is!

  16. 16
    A Says:

    @cal: Don’t complain about heterosexuals not respecting homosexuals the way you treat Cynthia and others like her! You are completely dismissing what she said and putting on label (bisexual) in the most snarky condescending b*tchy way. How would you like it if someone said “No, you are not gay/straight/bisexual, you are THIS because I say so! “She is a grown fcking woman stop labeling her! For her it was a choice. Accept that and move the fck on.

  17. 17
    A Says:

    Why do you get to define her sexuality for her? Who are you to say she is bisexual or it not being a choice for her? Are all gay people the same? Accept that for some gays it’s a choice and for others it’s not.

  18. 18
    dsfds Says:

    I agree with her. To some people it IS a choice. I was with a guy for 7 years, and I loved him, the sex wasn’t bad either. I always knew I liked women too though, but never got to try it until we broke up. Since then I’ve been with only women because I just like it so much better, not because I don’t find men attractive. I don’t consider myself bisexual, because I couldn’t imagine ever being with a man again, because I don’t WANT to be. It’s like you live your life thinking something is good, then you try something much better and don’t want to go back, even though you don’t find the old thing entirely disgusting… it’s just “ok”.

  19. 19
    Mimi Says:

    @A: If she considers it a choice than it’s really disgusting, even though I’m totally for gay rights. To think that she would “choose” to sleep with someone that ugly is disturbing. Couldn’t she find a beautiful l e s b i a n?

  20. 20
    nonya Says:

    not trying to criticize her but she just ruined a lot of what gays have been trying to get through stubborn people’s minds that gay is not a choice :(
    why would she say this?!

  21. 21
    Lila Says:

    So, technically it is a choice for everyone. The way I see it, is that you can chose who you are going to be in a relationship with. No one is forcing you be in a relationship with someone of the same sex. You are actively making the choice to be in a homosexual relationship. Additionally, to say “you can’t choose who you fall in love with” is probably true, but you can chose how you act upon that love. A teacher could fall in love with his underage student, but it is his responsibility not to act on that because it would be inappropriate. Furthermore, as you have said, if a person can’t chose to be gay, by the same token they would not be able to chose to straight either. A man could say “I’m gay because I am only attracted to men,” and then he could end up meeting a woman that he is attracted to because HE CANNOT CHOSE WHO HE IS ATTRACTED TO. I honestly think that being gay is just a social construct. People who say “being gay is not a choice” well then being straight is not a choice either. So you can say you’re gay, but how do you know you just have not met a member of the opposite sex to whom you are attracted? Yeah, that’s what I thought.

  22. 22
    Robert Says:


    She’s not essentially right. She’s making things worse. She is bisexual and what she is saying is that she is attracted to men and women and she is choosing to be with a woman.

  23. 23
    Mimi Says:

    @Lila: Wow, what great comments. I think people are born gay and personally I don’ t believe in bisexuality. I think bisexuals are either 1) really gay and don’t want to commit to that lifestyle or 2) promiscuous and will sleep with anybody. Either way I support gay rights. However, to say that one can choose to be attracted to the opposite sex of the same sex is ricidulous. I am straight and there is no choice about that in my mind.

  24. 24
    Carebear Says:

    I understand what she’s trying to say, but she could have worded it better. It would be like me saying I *choose* to be with men. Well, I choose it because I’m straight and not sexually attracted to women. I guess it could kind of be called a choice then?? However, I made this *choice* because I was born that way. Make any sense?

  25. 25
    Mac Says:

    for me she confuses “living gay” with “being gay”. you can’t choose if you ARE gay, but you can choose if you live according to your sexual preference or if you stay in the closet about it.

    coming out is a choice, but being gay is just like being male or female, black or white. who can chose to be white, except Michael Jackson anyway?!

  26. 26
    A Says:

    @Robert: You are an utter idiot. That’s not at all what she said and who the hell are you to say she is bisexual? She just said she’s not and yet you won’t listen to her and try to define her sexuality for her. The fcking audacity is mind blowing.
    Maybe you should spend some more time defining your own sexuality and stop seeking validation from others. All gay people are not alike.

  27. 27
    Mac Says:

    oh and I believe in pansexuality (meaning you love someone, but the sex doesn’t matter), and bisexuality. Why is it unbelieveable for some, that people don’t choose their partners according to their sex organs? doesn’t the person matter more?

  28. 28
    Nora Says:

    Who knows, perhaps she was with a man and did not choose to be with that man. Perhaps it was something that was forced on her.

    And so, her CHOICE was in future to be with a woman.

    All sexuality is a choice. Even heterosexuals can choose to be active or not.

  29. 29
    Ingrid Says:

    @Nora: You’re comments are nonsensical. You’re forgetting the essential part of all sexuality, the most important organ: the brain. That’s where sexuality and sexual preference really live and whether you are celibate or not doesn’t change that fact.

  30. 30
    Ingrid Says:

    @Mimi: Yeah, I agree. Why not choose to be in love with Angelina Jolie, who purports to be another bisexual.

  31. 31
    Cece Says:

    @Mimi: Please educate yourself. Saying bisexuality doesn’t exist is as offensive as saying homosexuality doesn’t exist… When you say you’re bisexual you’re either gay and a coward or a s***t? That’s a slap in the face of a lot of people.

    Why couldn’t it be a valid sexual orientation, to like both genders to some degree? Sexuality is not as simple as “you’re either straight or gay”. For some people it is, for other it’s not. You say you support gay rights and that’s great, but try to be tolerant towards everybody.

  32. 32
    dani Says:


    Actually you are wrong. Science has found that being gay is NOT a choice. It is genetic. Cynthia for whatever reasons swings both ways. I have a friend who prefers women, but considers herself to be basically straight. Why? Because she was molested by an uncle from age 6-12 and finds men bring back too many memories. Ones she has been unable to get over. People like you are either unwittingly cruel or cruel in the extreme to those that have no choice in their orientation or to those that make a choice based on past experiences.

  33. 33
    Mimi Says:

    @Cece: With all due respect, as I already wrote, I 100% support gay rights, which obviously includes bisexuality. However, I personally don’t believe in bisexuality and gave my explanation on that in an earlier post here.

  34. 34
    Cece Says:

    @Mimi: Uh, yes, I can read, you support everybody but you think some of them don’t have a “valid” or “real” sexual orientation. And I continue to say it’s offensive and completely illogical.

  35. 35
    Mimi Says:

    @Cece: I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree. However, again, I do support gay rights 100% and will continue to do so.

  36. 36
    MA Says:

    @Lila: All sexualities are social constructs since we develop our sexuality and sexual preferences affected by the world around us. The fact that we even have names for sexual identities is a social construct.

    According to the World Health Organization:
    Sexuality is a central aspect of being human throughout life and encompasses sex, gender identities and roles, sexual orientation, eroticism, pleasure, intimacy and reproduction. Sexuality is experienced and expressed in thoughts, fantasies, desires, beliefs, attitudes, values, behaviours, practices, roles and relationships. While sexuality can include all of these dimensions, not all of them are always experienced or expressed. Sexuality is influenced by the interaction of biological, psychological, social, economic, political, cultural, ethical, legal, historical, religious and spiritual factors.

  37. 37
    RayA Says:

    Jesus @ some of the posts here: I can not believe the narrow mindedness of some people here. She is talking common sense. She made a choice, she chose to be who she is which is incredibly brave to do rather than just saying “I can’t help it, etc”.

    Neither is wrong and neither is the only right answer. Some people feel they were born that way, some make an active choice. Why is that so hard to comprehend?

    Shouldn’t you all be supporting one another rather than having a pissing contest over who is more gay than the other? It’s disgusting to read. How do you propose to get respect when people like me read this and see you infighting with just as much narrow mindedness and hostility that you complain you get from society in general???

    And why is her saying she made a choice damaging to your cause? I really don’t get that? I honestly don’t.

  38. 38
    Meg Says:

    @RayA: It’s completely damaging to the homosexual cause!!!! She just set homosexual rights back decades and they are sure to be angry! Since the beginning, they have been fighting the ignorant belief that it’s a choice, when it’s not. Why would one choose to be discriminated against and looked down upon their whole life because of whom they love IF one could choose to love the opposite sex?????

  39. 39
    Sabrina Says:

    Homosexuality is NOT a choice. Why would someone choose to be gay and be treated like a second-class-citizen in this homophobe/heterosexist environment we sadly live in? For example in Iran you will get hanged if you are gay and nonetheless there are gay people. And what about all the suicides of homosexual teens who were bullied because of their sexual orientation? I’m pretty sure they would have chosen to be heterosexual, if they could have…
    But I have to agree with Cynthia when she says: “I say it doesn’t matter if we flew here or we swam here” and “Why is that any less legitimate? It seems we’re just ceding this point to bigots who are demanding it”.
    It simply SHOULD NOT MATTER if it’s a choice or not. Fact is: THERE ARE homosexual people and they deserve to have EVERY RIGHT heterosexuals have.

  40. 40
    Meg Says:

    @Sabrina: Well actually it does matter to all those religious people who send their children to therapists to “cure” them of homosexuality. Cynthia has really hurt gay rights with her comments. I assure you that she will soon feel the backlash, which she deserves. Maybe she should have just “chosen” to keep her bisexual mouth shut!!!!

  41. 41
    RayA Says:


    But what is wrong with it being a choice? What is wrong with choosing to be who you want to be?

    You seem to be looking at it the wrong way, because you shouldn’t be turning on the person who made that choice but questioning the people who see her making that choice as a bad thing.

    I don’t see it as a bad thing???? Good for her.

    I thought you were all trying fight for this: change societies perception that being gay is a bad thing. Yet, what I am reading here is perpetuating it.

    In my mind, what cynthia said was a positive to me because I thought “well bloody done for standing up and saying that”. More should be saying that and not afraid of what society will think about them for making that choice knowingly.

  42. 42
    Sheepypie Says:

    I don’t think it can be a choice, because I don’t think you can choose who you fall in love with. You either fall in love or you don’t. You can’t “decide” to. Even if a woman is bisexual, she can’t really just say, “I choose not to fall in love with a man.” She might hope to fall in love with a woman, or choose to live with a woman, but the heart wants what it wants, not the brain.

  43. 43
    Meg Says:

    @RayA: I don’t know what your sexual orientation is, but let’s just say you’re straight. Do you see yourself being able to choose to be gay? I am straight and I do not understand that concept or visa versa Trust me, gays will voice their negative opinions on her comments. I guarantee it.

  44. 44
    Barbra Says:

    @Sheepypie: Actually sexuality is in the brain, not the heart. Stupid comments.

  45. 45
    RayA Says:


    Meg, a very good question to ask! I won’t lie and fabricate my story to make me sound like a matyr for gay and lesbian rights because up to now I have only ever been in heterosexual relationships but I won’t rule out having a relationship with a woman either because I don’t know who I will meet in the future. I don’t see as wrong if I do.

    If I chose to be with women in the future, would that make me less “gay” in people’s eyes than someone who says they were just born that way?

  46. 46
    Meg Says:

    @RayA: OK, I’m confused because your name is Ray but you’re a woman, correct?

  47. 47
    Meg Says:

    RayA: To me it’s not a question of being more or less gay. The point is that it’s not a choice. It’s like saying I could choose to be 5 inches taller. It is what it is and I support it.

  48. 48
    RayA Says:


    Correct! It is what my friends and colleagues call me, as it is a shortened version of Rachel: Nice to meet you.

  49. 49
    Meg Says:

    @RayA: Nice to meet you too. So here are my thoughts if you chose to be with another woman in the future. I still believe it would not be a choice. Presumably you would want to be with a woman because your brain is telling you that you are sexually attracted to that person. Therefore, I go back to my original point, which is that homosexuality originates in the brain and therefore is not a choice, but probably genetic.

  50. 50
    RayA Says:


    It not being a choice is an opinion, not a fact. I fully believe that you should be allowed to admit that you chose rather that being white washed into believing that is inferior or wrong compared to someone who just already knew earlier on. Even then, people who knew from an earlier age had to make a choice to follow that rather than fight against it. So, either way, you all make a choice. I respect them either way.

    Plus, I don’t see bisexuality as being inferior or lesser form of sexuality.

  51. 51
    Meg Says:

    @RayA: Yes, any time one has feelings about anything they make a choice about what to do or not do about them. That’s a given, but the bottom line for me is what CAUSES those feelings and I believe it’s genetic.

  52. 52
    RayA Says:


    RE: The brain thing: I agree in a way but I know that I find certain physical features attractive on people- no matter if they are a man or woman- I appreciate physical beauty in both forms. I think most people do without realising it.

  53. 53
    Morgan Says:

    My belief is….if the world was totally free from hate and bigotry,
    1/3 would be straight, 1/3 would be gay and 1/3 would be bisexual.

  54. 54
    June Says:

    @dani: No it hasn’t. It’s a choice. Plain and simple, choosing doesn’t make it any less valid. Why are some of you gay people bashing her, and being derogatory? You should practice what you preach. 1 LOVE

  55. 55
    dani Says:


    She said it is a choice for HER and if you read the entire interview or statement, she acknowledges it is not a choice for others. Why should she lie to make a statement?

  56. 56
    dani Says:

    @June: @June:

    You obviously aren’t up on the latest studies. A 2011 comprehensive study found statistically significant differences in allele types between 361 identified homosexual subjects and 319 heterosexual control subjects. Many studies before this one also found genetic differences. For you to say it is a choice is ignorant. However, as I said in the above post, Cynthia Nixon said for her that this is a CHOICE she made. Which is fine. More power to her. I don’t care. ”

    You can sit there all you want and state that someone CHOOSES to be gay, but if you do some simple research you will find that for many it is NOT a choice, but rather a genetic anomoly. SO WHAT? A friend has a child with down syndrome. One chromosome or gene causes it. Was that a choice? Then how can you say that for some whether they are gay or straight is a choice when science has proven there is a genetic relationship for SOME.

  57. 57
    omd Says:

    @David: no, because no one, including you, knows if she will EVER go back to being with a man. so as it is, she is gay.

  58. 58
    omd Says:

    who cares about defining what she is? it’s her ******, why do you all care so much?

  59. 59
    omd Says:

    @dsfds: good comment. my bestfriend has always had boyfriends and now that she’s with a woman, she can’t see it any other way and she very much considers herself to be gay even though she still finds men attractive. but just because she’s attracted to men, doesn’t mean she wants to be with them that way again. i think for her, it IS a choice also. and at the end of the day, why does it matter how you get to the point of being attracted to the same sex? you just are and you’re entitled to do so!

  60. 60
    Meg Says:

    @RayA: Appreciating physical beauty does not necessarily translate into wanting to sleep with someone of the same sex. I appreciate beauty of all kinds, but your point doesn’t make any sense.

  61. 61
    Meg Says:

    @dani: I think she’s got mental issues and I always have. I don’t think that because she’s gay, she just seems off and has that crazy look in her eyes. If she’s being gay as a choice than that proves my point that she’s off. Why would you choose to be gay when it makes life so difficult? I can’t “choose” to be turned on by going down on another woman. Either my brain tells me I’m turned on or it doesn’t!!!!! HER COMMENTS MAKE ABSOLUTELY NO SENSE. I’M DONE COMMENTING ON HER STUPID STATEMENTS!!!!!! I feel sorry for the all the gays she just set back and whose lives she probably just mader harder.

  62. 62
    micky Says:

    I though the homo faggots say its in the dna LOL,being gay means you are mentally ill, and need help to be NORMAL, gays are as normal as pedophiles( most gays are pedophiles just look at all the gay catholic preists assaulting liitle boys)need proof of choice look at ellen degenerates ex GF ann heche married with children to a MAN. there will be no gays in heaven they will be in hell with all the democrats, murderers and LIARS

  63. 63
    Jen Says:

    oh god. here we go. My stomach is sinking just reading the comments of this awful story. The reason the gay population is so sensitive about this topic is because for most of known history they’ve been beaten, burned, experimented upon, tortured, and locked away in camps claiming to heal them of their immoral, evil ways. Cynthia definitely has the right to open her mouth and voice her opinion (and I’m sure I’m about to be blasted here for opening mine) but she’s being rather cavalier by doing so. If she’s telling the truth and really chose to be with a woman; it doesn’t actually mean she’s gay. It just means she’s using the progress people who’ve fought for gay rights have given her to do what she wants. This is ok… but to say its a choice for her and to claim to be “gay” is to slap those very people and their sacrifices in the face because her claim that it’s a decision is exactly what they’ve been fighting against for years. Saying it’s a decision is to open the door to all the behavior that hurts while claiming to help.

    If you can’t see that then look at it another way. It’s like all those other archaic ideas about certain populations of people others have used in history to steal land, enslave, imprison, experiment upon, torture, lock away to “train”, and murder. These things have happened. This is real history. And this behavior is what any civil or equal rights fight is about. And this is why it’s such a big deal when celebrities open their mouths and spout their opinions about things. It’s their right but it’s a little selfish. Especially since most people put celebs up on a pedestal. For some reason their opinions mean so much. We quote them. We put them in papers. And the next thing you know, people are thinking to themselves, “well if that gay celeb said this then it definitely must be so. I mean, she would know, right?” Just look at this page. It’s starting already.

  64. 64
    Lila Says:

    @Mimi: It’s not up to you to “believe in bisexuality” if there is someone who is attracted to both men and women who are you to say that you don’t “believe” them? It’s just honestly so cut and dry to me. A person cannot chose who they are attracted to. They can’t. Which means, that even though you may think that you a straight woman, one day you may meet a woman that you fall in love with, because as the gay people are saying, you don’t have a choice. By that same token, you make think that you are a gay man, but one day you may meet a woman that you fall in love with because, as the gay people are saying, YOU HAVE NO CHOICE IN THE MATTER. So, like I said, people just want to put labels on everything to make themselves feel better, and to make it sound like they deserve rights, but it’s like, I feel like marriage should be defined because otherwise people would just go left and right and forward and backwards on every whim of attraction they had. Instead, we have things that are defined within the laws of society to keep order and propriety. Like my example of the teacher dating his student. He may not be able to help being attracted to her [ because one cannot chose who to be attracted to] but he would should be prohibited from marrying her. How is this any different than prohibiting gay relationships? You’ll say because a gay relationship is between two consenting adults. But who decided what a “consenting adult” is? THE GOVERNMENT decided that’s who. So why is it any more discriminatory for the government to decide what is recognized as a legitimate relationship? I’ll tell you, it’s not. A pedophile could say “hey I want the same rights as everyone else has, you can’t tell me who I can and cannot love, I am in love with children, I can’t help it, I was born this way,” etc. etc. etc. But luckily, we have a system where we can decide that this form of love is improper. Now, I don’t care if you are for gay marriage or against it, but to say that the government has no right to define marriage as between a man and a woman is incorrect. Just my own opinion.

  65. 65
    Lila Says:

    Also, I’m sick of people saying that gays are treated like “second class citizens.” Illegal aliens, black people, the impoverished etc are treated like second class citizens, not gay people. To be honest, nobody really cares who you’re having sex with. That’s your own choice.

A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News | Advertise here