Top Stories

Gerard Butler: Joxer Daly's Afternoon Outing!

Gerard Butler: Joxer Daly's Afternoon Outing!

Gerard Butler checks his phone real quick as he heads to his car after hanging out with some pals at Joxer Daly’s on Tuesday (November 20) in Culver City, Calif.

The 43-year-old Scottish actor showed off his super toned body in a tight black t-shirt!

PHOTOS: Check out the latest pics of Gerard Butler

It was recently announced that Gerard and Sarah Jessica Parker will be co-hosting this year’s Nobel Peace Prize Concert, to take place on December 11! Set to perform at the festivities are Jennifer Hudson and Seal.

Be sure to check out Gerard‘s next film, Playing for Keeps, in theaters on December 7.

Like Just Jared on Facebook
gerard butler joxer dalys afternoon outing 01
gerard butler joxer dalys afternoon outing 02
gerard butler joxer dalys afternoon outing 03
gerard butler joxer dalys afternoon outing 04
gerard butler joxer dalys afternoon outing 05

JJ Links Around The Web



# 1

Love him in the black tee. Looking good, Mr. B!

# 2
Gerry Butler's low standards @ 11/21/2012 at 12:31 pm

I read that he’s dating Madalina Ghenea. Why does this man have such low standards in women? Brandi Glanville a reality TV star. That really 23 year old girl Martina Rajic that he was shagging in Serbia while shooting a movie and exposes it all in bloody Playboy. Now this 24 year old from Romania who is only known for taking her clothes off for porn-looking lingerie shoots and has already been with Leo DiCaprio and Adrien Brody THIS YEAR? Who has had her lips surgically altered as well as other parts of her face from the looks of her, trying to look like Sophia Loren when she was already a very lovely girl, and at such young an age!
Does Gerard Butler have something against classy women? Women who aren’t willing to do everything and everyone to get famous? Does he just not like and respect women very much that he doesn’t care if girls are all about fame and exposing themselves so long as they are young and have low body fat?
Is it because he’s 43, and in his middle age feels the need to date girls under 25, and the only hot girls under 25 who will date him are the ones who want to get famous?
What does this guy have against smart, sophisticated, educated, respectable girls? Even if their young, can’t he find a young girl who hasn’t taken her clothes off for cameras and hasn’t degraded herself in a quest to be famous?
It all makes him seem pretty skeevy and low rent himself.

# 3

Classy women have something against him.

# 4

He dates only women he would have no desire to marry because he’s not the marrying kind. He’s all about the fun and freedom.

# 5

Hot body.

# 6

Rastêt vo mne tihaya uverennost’, chto on – bi.

# 7

@Gerry Butler’s low standards:
He has the Caveman mentality, he likes his woman dumb so they don’t know what hes upto.

# 8
Gerry ANTI AMERICAN? NOT!!! @ 11/21/2012 at 1:16 pm

I read in the last thread of someone posting that Gerry is anti American and doesnt like American women. I dont think thats true in the least! He knows America made him famous–and he LOVES being famous! I guess his acting skills are a matter of opinion but he wouldnt of had the same type of exposure in the UK that he has now in USA. and hes enjoying every bit of it. We can see that he speaks without thinking sometimes and my guess is that he problably broke up with some girl in the USA or he finds American women intolerant of his flirting and messing with other ladies outside of a relationship. Not that I think UK women are so easy about it either–I DOUBT THEY ARE! But he would rather date someone who wont address his wandering ways and certain women in other countries are most likely not going to open their mouths about it. Dont forget that he said that his wild wandering ways started when he was in Scotland–America is just a much bigger playground for him IMO. He speaks rashly sometimes. After all he said he wantedt o spend his birthday in India and that Scotland was his second choice. Wonder if his mom and the relatives read that one? And didnt he say something about his own hometown that got his fellow Scots upset?
As far as him going back to the UK to improve his career? HE AINT GOING NOWHERE. He said in the Mens Journal magazine that hes living a charmed life.He loves the papps the parties the real estate AND THE WOMEN…..on a very loose basis that is. I dont see him giving that up any way in any time soon!

# 9

Dude, don’t ever let the camera catch you from the side, looking down. Gross.

@DocP: If you are talking about MG, think again. She is no babe in the woods. You need to think again. She has been around the block a few times more than you can count and knows exactly what she is doing. Keeping this thread full of crap for one.
My my aren’t we the bitter one. Take your meds doc.

Dumb&Dumber @ 11/21/2012 at 1:31 pm

@oops: Yep, she’s been around the block, and she’s extremely manipulative imo, but she’s still dumb as a rock. I agree that some posters on here are falling for her gameplaying, but many also see it for what it is and won’t play the game. She’s an amateur at this, and blatantly obvious. I don’t care if they shag ’til doomsday, I just don’t want to hear about her anymore.

“My my aren’t we the bitter one. Take your meds doc.”
Apparently, what i said about DocP was right on the money. She is nothing but a jealous old hag who never misses an opportunity to bash MG as a result of her jealousy.
If I had to fill my prescriptions at a pharmacy where DocP is employed as a pharmacist, I’d walk away. How the hell can she focus on filling People’s prescription accurately and not make mistakes?
The woman is so unstable if all she cares about is hating on MG. Just goes to show that no matter the education, some women are as childish as a 3-year old throwing tamper tantrum, except it’s not cute when it’s coming from an old hag as opposed to a 2 year old.

Gotta say @ 11/21/2012 at 1:40 pm

So this thread is going to be the same as the last several.
No change at JJ.

Oh yes, and an old hag like you knows all about MG and GB, right?
it’s obvious your hate and jealousy are doing a number on you and you can’t see straight. f/k off.

@Gotta say:
Unfortunately, JJ hasn’t banned old hags like you who bash younger women, so apparently nothing changed with JJ.

@Gotta say: This thread will never change until JJ blocks a certain troll. The tone and attitude of it will become hostile and defensive every time no matter what anyone says unless they agree with the troll’s continued garbage. The only reason I’m on here today is because WO had a direct link with new pix. I removed JJ from my favs a month ago and haven’t missed it.

Juicy Lucy @ 11/21/2012 at 1:51 pm

By Gerry’s own admission, heis a bad boyfriend and lover but he is a great friend. As a friend, I think Gerry is very loyal but as a lover, he’s only interested in casual relationships with young women who are willing to feed his massive ego. MG is disingenuous to believe that she is his soul mate. The only soulmate Gerry will ever have is himself. Like the rest of his girlfiends, this one too will pass.

@oops: “If you are talking about MG, think again. She is no babe in the woods. You need to think again. ”
Talking about stupid perhaps you should read your own post. You sound like a poly parrot. the woman is dumb she’s selling herself out for money and fame. All the while she will miss out on true love. Not to mention some of the comments this woman makes shows her lack of intelligence. If what your trying to say is that MG is “clever” well that might be true but thats not intelligence. A smart woman doesn’t sell herself short to a man who flat out lies to her and treats her with disrespect. Just because he opens doors and buys her things doesn’t mean he respects her. I realise you have a different view on this but the fact that he wasn’t there with here for her big moment shows how disrespectful he is, the fact he was in India flirting (and who knows what else) with a “group” of woman shows he does not respect her. He thinks shes dumb enough to fall for his lies. Which I’m sure he was full of when they met up in Sotland. Tell me this, if he loves her so much, why is she out “ring” shopping without him?? Most guys go with their fiance or even better yet they surprise their love on a special occasion. This doesn’t smell of love, it stinks of an arrangement.

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/21/2012 at 2:01 pm

Happy Thanksgiving to all and wishing you a blessed day of thanks! Some of our families are scattered far and wide and we will miss them.
I don’t know if you want to do this or not, maybe just change the tone a little. Maybe because it is holiday time or maybe just wishing for a little more joy.
Anyway, wondering if you would want to list the movies that Gerry has done that you like and maybe why. #1 being your favourite etc. Mine happens to be #1 Dear Frankie, it was low budget and a charmer, touching and sincere. #2 The Cherry Orchard. Gerry played Yasha, such a stinker and freeloader. Just a thought, Ducky

@Juicy Lucy: I agree and I think it’s because Gerry holds friends to a higher esteem then gfs. The definition for a gf for him is simply someone to have a physical relationship with. I truly think Mr. Butler was hurt real bad one time by a gf and it left a bad taste in his mouth about loyalty and trust. With a gf comes a certain about of being accountable and meeting someone else’s needs where with a friend, you can be yourself without having to answer to anyone and you are accepted for who you are. Just an opinion. Someone like Gerry, to me, would be difficult to have as a bf and as a husband a nightmare! As a friend, I could see.

You really need to stop talking to yourself. people are gonna call the police on you and have you hauled off to the funny farm. We all know you posted as Oops!! get a life, oh tast right you don’t have one because you spend the majority of it in front of the computer attacking anyone that says anything remotely negative about your girlfriend. Perhaps she was shopping to buy you a ring for your devoted service. Afterall you gals are just such great BFF’s

Yes, Gerry is not anti-America, not by a longshot. Going back to the UK is like going down in style, wealth, and power. Who wants socialism? Socialist, Gerard Butler is not. Although, he is ignorant about politics in general, like calling the EU a good example of humanity uniting in peace. What? Europe is falling apart financially, and there is less freedom for people since the EU started to impose its totalitarian policies on citizens. What next, he’ll call the UN a good example for humanity? Yes, if you think terrorists and killers getting money form the US and EU, as well as having a world stage to spew their anti-democracies hate, is a good thing.
Regarding India, how do you guys know he didn’t try to take MG with him, and because she couldn’t get a visa he gave up India all together?
Two scenarios:

1) The whole thing never happened and is just a fabrication. After all, the Indian media loves to embellish stories about him. Also, he already declared almost 2 weeks before his birthday that his plans this year are to be home with his family for his birthday, otherwise, he would have planned a huge party like he usually does. So it’s obvious he had no plans besides spending time with MG with or without his family.

2) He wanted to do India last minute, which is no problem if it’s just him coming since he’s been there before so they have all his info and he is also a beloved star there because he supposedly proposed to their beloved LC, but MG never been there before and to organize a visa for her would have taken much longer so he had to forgo that whole idea.
Either way the whole thing sounds like such a lame reason to start a thread based on this story. It smells PR of some type, probably for the Indians who love to embellish stories about him.
I think he and MG are still goings strong, but I hate these separations which I have said are each a nail in the coffin of this relationship. They need to be together and the fact they aren’t, I wonder how strongly he really feels about her, and vice versa. About a month ago, I said if they are not going to spend most of their time together, this whole thing would fizzle. We might see them again a few more times, but it will end. Then they are spotted together in Scotland, which was nice. But now they are each living their separate lives again. It doesn’t bode well.

@Lord Love a Duck: Good idea, Ducky. My favorite would have to be Phantom of The Opera and for me the passion in the character. I also loved Dear Frankie , PS I love you is probably my second fav. I liked him in Lara Croft too and Timeline. But Phantom would be my fav…so far. I’m still holding out for Burns!

Surprised Gerard Butler isn’t getting more Oscar buzz for his portrayal of “80s George Michael” in PLAYING FOR KEEPS

I don’t post as anyone else. Get a grip on yourself old hag. I haven’t been here in days, and had to weed though garbage posts galore on the last 2 threads. I finally gave up after i got the gist of what’s news with Gerry, and i see you back to your old tricks of trashing her when you have nothing of value to say.
Then I read “oops ” and it triggered me off in the face of your sorry-for-an excuse post. I didn’t want to miss a chance to blast you for being the hag you are. There you have it!

Sunshine Daydream @ 11/21/2012 at 2:14 pm

@Ick: Lol, where’s his bum? Did he leave it at home? The last pic is much more flattering. He wears the black t-shirt well.

They’re advising against travel to India right now due to a high terrorism threat. That’s probably why he was turned down.

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/21/2012 at 2:20 pm

@#1Fan: Oh CRAP totally forgot about POTO. Yes, have to make that my #2. What a production that was.
I will alway lament Burns not being done. He would be the only one to do it well and true. I don’t want to think that he might be to old to do it now.

@DocP: Best not to converse with the resident troll. It’s like the old saying, the more you stir sht, the worse it stinks so we need to flush her down the crapper with our thumbs!

angelsrock @ 11/21/2012 at 2:23 pm


I was just going to post a similar statement. I have to agree after being a fan for a long time that Gerry is not in the market for a long term relationship let alone marriage. And you can bet that Maddie knew this from the get-go. He has made this very clear and that’s why we never hear of him breaking someone’s heart. He appears to be incapable of commitment and is aware enough to be very open about that. I hope one day, that special lady changes his mind.

@Lord Love a Duck: Well that last Halloween costume he was wearing might be the closest thing we get to seeing him even look like Burns! Burns wasn’t a healthy man and was always ailing, not to dis Gerry’s looks, but his age may not factor in because of how Burns probably looked anyway. Sally Field is 65 and she just played Mary Todd Lincoln who was 45. HW can works wonders and I think people looked older in bigone days.

Sunshine Daydream @ 11/21/2012 at 2:35 pm

@#1Fan: Not to mention Robert Burns died at age 37. That would have been the role for him right after 300 instead of doing those cr/ap rom-coms. He could have done so much with that one at that time. Sigh.


He is a frugal man since aren’t those the same trainers he has had since filming PFK in spring of 2011? Didn’t he collect those from that filming? Good on him for being so, ermm, resourceful. Right.

Well when I see random posts thumbed down it’s obvious the troll(s) are lurking about in force and no one will be able to make a positive comment ON ANYTHING! So Happy Thanksgiving to all who deserve it and I bid you adieu!

@#1Fan: I know ,sometimes however she needs to be put in her place. However like the cockroach that she is, she just keeps scumming. I won’t be addressing her posts except with thumbs down!!

So are we to believe that paps are sitting in the parking lot of Joxer D’s on a regular basis? Or did some little birdie put in a phone call? Interesting how we get an avalanche of daily JJ threads when attention is wanted for a movie coming up, and the rest of the time, crickets.

mg vs ll? @ 11/21/2012 at 3:01 pm

i think the pics from st tropez of mg and gb together were an obvious set up. you can tell because mg is clearly doing a bad acting job for the camera. the pic of them holding the umbrella kissing, with her practically grabbing him around the neck is ridiculous.

i’m 80% sure its a set up relationship but as gb is a womanizer i can’t believe he wouldn’t sleep with her anyway so…

it would have worked but mg lets the side down. she should take a leaf out of lara lieto’s book. no one knows ANYTHING about her, theres no info online other than her with Adrien and she has more press attention. she doesn’t talk to the press either. she seems like a genuinely nice girl and her and ab look in love together. she’s not my hero but you get my point

What annoys me the most about women is their whining about men’s nature and calling other prettier younger tighter women names. Woman use the fact that men are very visually focused, and they do have a physical ideal that most women cannot realistically achieve, as an excuse to not do the things that ARE under their control like lose weight and look good. No, honey, it’s not in the cards for you to be Alessandra Ambrosio or Madalina Ghenea. But you could lose 20 pounds and get a more flattering haircut and not be such a beetch all the time.

But that would be work, wouldn’t it? So instead let’s sit around and whine about how men are cads while we pound down a pint of Ben & Jerry’s. Uma Thurman’s dead eyes in the Playing for Keeps billboard perfectly capture the moment she found out she was in a Gerard Butler movie.

I Can Relate! @ 11/21/2012 at 3:36 pm

@LOL: I know what you are saying! I’ve encountered women such as this who look at me and make snide remarks and I can’t help it if their hubs or beaus are checking me out! That’s THEIR prob, right? If they kept themselves more fit he might not have such a roving eye! Now I realize being about five nine, all legs and 130 with most of it on top doesn’t hurt but jealousy is an ugly thing and I’m glad you see the side of us pretty women against these old hags who would do better if they’d work on themselves a bit more instead of slagging off us who can’t help it if we’re what every man wants! Thanks for your support!

@I Can Relate!:
It’s not just on JJ dumping on MG, i see it all the time even at the gym. If you have a rocking body you get the look of hate from other women. They stare at you and whisper as if you took their beauty away from them.
Women can do a lot to better themselves. if they spent all this time working out in the gym instead of trashing MG……..
Losing weight is key.


With the repeating of the words young and tide over and over again

I always have the feeling you are a man and you’re supporting this.

It sounds like the words of a pimp. It sounds disguting to me as everything and everyone has no feelings
We are all just flesh, old or young.

blah blah blah @ 11/21/2012 at 3:44 pm

@LOL: Don’t you get bored listening to yourself every day. Go milk the cows & churn the butter & bake the bread, the sister wives are on their way home from the farmer’s market with Daddy. They expect you to have dinner on the table & all the children washed and scrubbed. Better make sure you got the aprons and bonnets all starched. Hagling.

@blah blah blah:
fat are we?
No man paid any attention to us in years?

blah blah blah @ 11/21/2012 at 3:49 pm

@LOL: Oh so you like watching the women at the gym stare at the hot women, is that ’cause you are staring at the hot women too. Anything you need to fess up? Does Daddy only let you go to a female only gym. Maybe you need to concentrate on working out we hear you are dumpy for an arrogant hagling.

I Can Relate! @ 11/21/2012 at 3:56 pm

@LOL: Fortunately, I’ve never really had to go to the gym. Just good genetics I guess. My dad was very tall and athletic. I do admit I love to see a woman go off on her man when I walk by and I KNOW he’s checking me out! The other day, I got scared out of my wits when a firetruck passed me on the street and tooted their horn and siren! It caused me to step out of a stilleto! But I’ve even had women that were pretty mumble “b..itch” under their breath when I’m near. So what’s up with that?

shut up already with your man bashing.
men are men; they love beautiful women, it doesn’t make them rapist.
How many times were you imaginary “raped” ? Loser!

I Can Relate! @ 11/21/2012 at 4:02 pm

@LOL: I’m so glad there are women like you who understand the pain us pretty girls go through every day! I know we could be good friends because you would be my number one supporter and you would understand even if you weren’t as pretty as me! In fact, I have long dark hair and my lips aren’t enhanced, they’re natural and women think I’ve got boob implants because they’re jealous. My nose is a little big and I’ve been thinking about getting a nose job, what do you think??

@Gerry Butler’s low standards:
He’ll be into those once he’s turned off, or can successfully manage, the negative voice cycle that he isn’t worthy of anyone but low-life traps.
Until then, he might, sadly, keep up trending the same “type” that he can figure out in less than four minutes then lie to himself it’s “instant connection” when it’s “instant attraction” to a “type” he’s convinced himself he needs, which never existed in Scotland so that’s self told lie. Needing a “type” means he loves on condition which means start at the top and re-read.
who won’t give up b/c he’s been there once so can return again

A Freudian slip? (laughs) I meant tramps, like the peasant.

@blah blah blah:
No I am the beautiful woman, they stare at.
EVE you need to shut up. you’re anger only proves what an old hag you are.
just give it up. you’re se.xually. you have no viability. You know it and it’s killing you that your youth is in the past.
I am happy you have no youth or beauty left. you sure make lots of fun comments that show your anger about it.
Keep it up. You’re the poster child of what i am talking about.

I Can Relate! @ 11/21/2012 at 4:07 pm

@LOL: Don’t let the haters upset you. Men always appreciate beauty. At seventeen I was approached by a woman who gave me a card with the Playboy Bunny logo on it and asked me if I wanted to work in her “Bunny Club”. I told her I was too young and my Mom would have a fit. She said I could check coats and then when I turned eighteen, I could learn the “Bunny dip”. I asked her what I needed to do and she said all I’d be asked to do is face a wall and put my elbows on it and if my boobs touched first, I was in!


I believe in god I know it’s a sin but to say something like this to an abused person is…. I hope you find out the feeling one day. I wish you find out. what kind of person someone must be to say something like this.
You are evil

@I Can Relate!:
There is no such thing as not needing to go to the gym. if you want to be flexible and have long shapely limbs you have to. It’s not just being thin, it’s more about having a nice shape to you. I love Pilates and yoga. it sure makes my 5-7 frame hotter than if i weren’t doing it.
Just from this statement alone i don’t believe you are pretty or thin you’re probably one of these resentful old hags getting filled with anger and posting crap until you start to lash out when you can’t take it any longer. didn’t i say you old fat hags need something to do to better your situation. You’re proof. .

I Can Relate! @ 11/21/2012 at 4:14 pm

@LOL: Us pretty women need to stick together against these jealous haters! It’s not easy being beautiful and being hated! I’m what every man dreams of! I once had a guy walk up to me and ask if he could just walk around with me in a club so I looked like I was with him to show off to his friends!

I Can Relate! @ 11/21/2012 at 4:17 pm

@LOL: OMG! I don’t need to go to the gym because I play volleyball! I live near the beach and I skate and do some surfing too! I haven’t needed to go to the gym because I keep myself fit enough. I also enjoy riding my bike everywhere!

You sound bitter! Perhaps it is YOU who is not pretty and you are jealous of ME?? I feel sorry for you. You sound like just another jealous old hag to me!

Yes, you volley between monikers talking to yourself.

i call crap, carp.
if you were really raped and hated men because of the rape and not because they love beautiful women and you are not one, you wouldn’t be here lusting over Gerry and trashing his GF.
I might be young, but I wasn’t born yesterday, and i am not stupid either. you can pass that booll of yours on the stupid old hags here who would believe anything without proof, but not me. Scram!

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:23 pm

@I Can Relate!: She is NOT pretty. She’s a chubby, horned rimmed spectacled, pudgy faced, butt fugly little betch. We’ve all seen her facebook, which she has since taken down. Her husband leaves her alone and night and hangs out with his ex so you can understand why she’s so mean and bitter. Ignore everything she says. She’s a nobody.

I Can Relate! =EVE @ 11/21/2012 at 4:24 pm

Can you tell it’s the old hag at work again?
she changes monikers like it’s going out of business, but she fails to see some of us can see past her.
ignore the jealous beoutch. At what point did Gerard Butler decide that romcoms were the only type of movies he could make?

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:27 pm

@I Can Relate! =EVE: You talking to yourself again, LOL? They have drugs for that you know.

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:29 pm

In LOL’s world, everyone is EVE but her! Poor delusional and very paranoid twit!

@I Can Relate! =EVE:
@I Can Relate!:
“OMG! I don’t need to go to the gym because I play volleyball! I live near the beach and I skate and do some surfing too! ”
Which still means you exercise. what’s the difference if it’s in the gym or you live near the beach can you utilize that instead?
EVE you have lots of cognitive dissonance you think you’re clever but all your arguments are teenager like. didn’t all that life experience pay up at some point? Cause you sound like a re/ard

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:32 pm

@LOL: You can always tell when you are getting upset! You start telling posters to scram or leave the board, as if they will do what you say! LMFAO! You have no powers here! You just run your mouth because that’s all you have!

Philosopher King @ 11/21/2012 at 4:32 pm

“The beauty of a woman is not in a facial mole,
but true beauty in a Woman is reflected in her soul.
It is the caring that she lovingly gives,
the passion that she knows.”
― Audrey Hepburn

Audrey Hepburn was the epitome of beauty and class. Beauty without class is not so pretty.

LOL’s inner ugliness shines daily. Yet she accuses people here of outer ugliness daily. To make her feel better about herself. We must take pity on her inner pain.

As outer beauty fades, those who neglect their souls at the alter of beauty and the shallow, find the inner ugliness grows more bitter.

Here is the test – at your funeral think about what you hope people will say about your life in eulogy. Something we perhaps should all reflect on.

@I Can Relate! =EVE:
Trollenator=EVE too.
she is always claiming she saw me once on FB. she knows it’s not true, but she keeps repeating the same lies hoping to make them stick. That’s what I call her a desperate old hag whose fighting hope against hope trying to stay buoyant when she is sinking in the abyss of old age and senility. Poor thing. NOT! I hope she gets uglier and more senile. She sure sounds more ugly and more senile than when i trashed her last.

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:35 pm

@LOL: What’s a “re/ard”??

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:37 pm



What’s this? Pretty childish behavior on your part! Poor, LOL! She’s loosing it!

Someone on here, LOL, talks about sex too much which means she 1) isn’t getting any; and 2) knows nothing about it at all. Her canned statements are all text book nonsense about a gender she knows nothing about, men. This person is linear, cold and simply thinks sex equals love when it does not. Not at all. If you ask a man about his best times with his woman, it won’t be about sex at all.

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:40 pm

Now she’s talking to herself again! OMG, someone’s off her meds! LOL is an old hag in training! LMFAO!

Add a t where the / is and you’ll know Einstein.
Improvisation is key old hag.
forgot my comment was directed to “I can relate!”, EVE?
I see EVE changed into more monikers and her hate is exploding. LOLZZZZZZZZZZZLOLZZZZZZZ

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:44 pm

I actually feel sorry for LOL! She’s shallow and empty inside and believes that the seat of beauty lies in superficial appearances. She’ll have it rough as she ages and looses her looks. Oh wait, she has nothing to worry about in that regard! Her inner beauty will come shining through! LOLOLOLOL!

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:45 pm

And very juvenile. I bet her hubs just has her around for a quick piece and the rest of the time he stays as far away as he can! Poor guy!

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:46 pm

I fogot to add he probably needs to put a bag over her head first! LOLOLOLZZZZZZZZZZZ

I know that I am telling the truth. I never had a man can’t stand someone touching me. Believe what you believe. Sometimes you have hobbies to light up your life. i went through things you can’t imagine. I love movies and books so I can escape. I am always on the side of the weak.
I won’t say anything more. When you believe someone lies when she is telling she was abused as a child than believe it. I know god knows the truth. I like Gerry as an actor and have never trashed him or her.

I loved this forum because I loved to read about Gerry and about movies and other things
It has changed

Trollenator @ 11/21/2012 at 4:48 pm

I’ve had enough fun beating up on LOL for one day. Got better things to do. Ciao!

Angry EVE is all the entertainment we need on JJ these days. she beats everything else hands down.
I might post one or two of my anti-feminist rants and how it’s related to the bashing of GB dating MG to get her blood pumping again. She is starting to lose it now, posting stupid comments because she has nothing to say. I need to get her back to the fold, the poor senile such as she is.

I am always on the side of the weak.”
That’s where your problem is. You are using emotions, not intellect. The weak is not always right. Sometimes the weak finds tactics to hurt others, as they hide behind their weakness so that people feel sorry for them and they continue to operate with no one ever holding them accountable.
When you remove the emotional aspects, then you can see reality for what it is. Here is an example you can all relate to. How many women can’t leave a man they should leave because they judge with their emotions and not their intellect? Most women are like that.
Case closed. The weak is not always right. Each situation should be evaluated on its own merit.

I am always on the side of the weak.”
That’s where your problem is. You are using emotions, not intellect. The weak is not always right. Sometimes the weak finds tactics to hurt others, as they hide behind their weakness so that people feel sorry for them and they continue to operate with no one ever holding them accountable.
When you remove the emotional aspects, then you can see reality for what it is. Here is an example you can all relate to. How many women can’t leave a man they should leave because they judge with their emotions and not their intellect? Most women are like that.
Case closed. The weak is not always right. Each situation should be evaluated on its own merit.

Child abuse is no laughing matter and anyone who can admit it should praised and respected but you’re trying to have a grown-up conversation with a woman hater who knows nothing about little, least above all the victimization associated with child abuse. She’s a one-track mind and can’t veer from it.
Obtuse is being polite. Furthermore apart from her volleying between monikers to talk to herself, somethings she’s famous for, to keep her topic as centerpiece, you’ll have no peace trying to negotiate or get through to her.
And if the board has changed, and it has, it is solely because of that relentless individual who promotes anything (in her supposed age-bracket) as the end all for men forgetting she will age and all this will come back to bite her in the butt, and it couldn’t come soon enough.
Back the village peasant. Abuse isn’t love.

Another thing when I show and start to get warmed up this person suddenly must go, and always “to the gym” or some such nonsense, [read: more like back to her cell or iron lung] Sorry, that’s not funny but it is because it seems she’s these spurts of high volume activity inventing her ‘very active’ life yet here she is for days, nights, months on end then immediately is being summoned out on the town (eye roll) because she’s being clocked as fraud and fake for knowing nothing about love, relationships or commitment or what attraction really is.

Textbook example of just why she knows nothing, absolutely, nothing about men: “When you remove the emotional aspects, then you can see reality for what it is.” Why? Men don’t do anything they don’t feel like doing. Men are all feelings. Men are very emotional super-duper sensitive. See what I mean? Nothing, not one thing she says is true about men, the kind that live outside her mind in the real world. The men she’s referring to? I don’t know any like that, none.
Oh, maybe pimps and those in the “male entertainment” business or porn but not real living, breathing men with hearts who are very full of emotions and men like Gerry and want emotional, intellectual not just physical attraction? As it takes all three for anything to last or move past 1st Stage Love… infatuation.
This person is SO off target about him, in the long-run, but it suits her to debase him to some reptile like herself.

Old hag GFW is now opining, LOL!
GFW, how old are you your old haggeryness? somewhere 50 +, right. isn’t it time you give up lusting and dooling in favor of some other garbage you like to do? Oh, I forgot, you have no other garbage you like to do. Gerry is your whole life..
Behold, soon he’ll get married and have little ones and what will you have? just your insults of his hot younger tighter woman. Be gone witch.

You know nothing about men. All you know is what you made up about them in your fantasies. Didn’t getting a divorce and him throwing you out on your ear enough to see the light? Some old hags never change their old-hag ways.
How does it feel to know Gerry is in the arms of another woman that you can never be, cause you sagging ol’ pooz is not wanted in his bed?


Playing For Keeps

Going unopposed certainly has its perks. With Playing For Keeps being the only wide release this week, it will certainly help the opening figures, which star Gerard Butler could definitely use since Chasing Mavericks wiped out with a meager $5.6 million. This romantic family comedy, which also features Jessica Biel, Dennis Quaid, Scarlett Johansson, and Catherine Zeta-Jones, certainly isn’t Butler’s forte (The Ugly Truth and The Bounty Hunter weren’t exactly hits), and will certainly have an uphill struggle with strong November holdovers like Rise of the Guardians, Life of Pi, and Killing Them Softly, but it is still too early to count it out just yet.

rahel, i offer you a hug @ 11/21/2012 at 5:27 pm

all is not lost, keep your faith, God loves you. Ignore evil and do what is good. There is still good people here and elsewhere. :)

Need to comment on his look here. I like it. It is way above his “red neck” period this past summer. He’s ‘back’ so to speak and that reflects in his dressing better. Everything matters.
In other words, he’s back on the market. He’s got it all pulled together even for California “LA” dress code, and for a reason.
Don’t care if the village peasant shows up for a scheduled “shoot” with him or not, something has changed with Gerry. He’s had an epigraphy. His wanting to go to India was key.
You do not need to be a rocket scientist to tell his demeanor has improved. His focus and clarity as well. He always looks like the real him alone. I love this.
Spring and summer took its toll in many directions. Chasing Mavericks took its toll and was a flare. It is time to turn serious or back out. I don’t see him doing the latter, but the former. That career of his is his baby.

always think with your heart @ 11/21/2012 at 5:33 pm

don’t fall victim to the bright , shiney things of this world, they will pass away, who is first now will later be last.

those that take up their lives for the weak will be the most blessed in His kingdom.

God Bless you Rahel

Hasn’t your (fake) phone run inviting you out Ms. LOL? You know to party with the droids in your small hick town where you believe you rule? No? Not yet? No worries, they will. Your (fake) call will summon you to go “party” with them and your other heartless self-hating droids. As, you know, like attracts like.
What I find most annoying about you is your lack of connectedness to Gerry’s career. It is like you don’t give a flippin’ cell phone about it? And frankly, this is why (not the primary reason as you know nothing about men, real ones, at all) why your bllshit about what men want doesn’t jell. It shows by your lack of knowledge when men really want, the triangle. Like in Lincoln! That triangle. All must be equal! (wink)


But why is she doing that I don’t understand.
I was a little bit shocked of her words but now
I have calmed down but to be honest I didn’t want
to post again the next time
maybe when the energy here has changed.
I just wanted to let you know that I read your post
and thank you for your words. I wish everyone a good night.

@rahel, i offer you a hug

Thank you

I know there are. May god bless you all

I know light will always enlighten the dark

Show is up for GFW... Cheers! @ 11/21/2012 at 5:40 pm

@GFW: A new Gerard Butler romcom and it’s… bad??!! When birds fly, I say!

I'veSavedMyReplyRahel @ 11/21/2012 at 5:46 pm

I don’t get it…

I didn’t know anything about this … sorry if somebody already posted it.

The girl has a speaking part in PFK and her father was the technical soccer advisor for the production.

Can someone please explain to me why Gerard gets so many comments in the section of posts related to him? Hes not particularly interesting or talented.

Let it slide @ 11/21/2012 at 6:54 pm

@Uh huh:
Each to their own, you might not like him but others does. It Just happen.

The photos of MG at the Damiani jewelry store were taken in Milan (not Beverly Hills). There are more photos at this Italian link. MG also seems to have given an interview to one of the paps, because there is a microphone attached to her jacket in a few of the photos. This was definitely a pre-planned event.

@Gerry Butler’s low standards: Men who are low-rent and without manners who probably don’t shower regularly don’t “get” decent women. What do you expect of him? He’s not a respectable and decent man. He has no manners and he’s crude and classless. He dumps women left and right.

His fan clubs have supported this useless POS for way too long and it’s demeaning to think “he’s such a great guy with a beautiful soul”. No, he’s not. He’s a hedonistic bore who can’t act his way out of a paper bag.

I can’t find a word that describes the male sl.ut he is but that’s pretty close. Sl.utler. He’s only in it for the sl.uts and the rutting around. I feel sorry for Maddie if she thinks she’s getting something good out of this deal. He’s nothing to brag about.

@bex: Someone forgot to tell Scarlett Johannsen she was in PFK if she had been that WOULD have been interesting as she seems to have a pattern of glomming onto her male co-stars. Uma will be devastated.

And The Ugly Truth made over $200 million dollars world wide. How is that not successful as compared to like many of say Clooney’s recent films. Except for the Bond people, everyone would be ecstatic with $200 million world wide. Bond going to hit a billion? That would be sweet. They won’t let Craig quit.

@bex: Someone forgot to tell Scarlett Johannsen she was in PFK if she had been that WOULD have been interesting as she seems to have a pattern of glomming onto her male co-stars. Uma will be devastated.

And The Ugly Truth made over $200 million dollars world wide. How is that not successful as compared to like many of say Clooney’s recent films. Except for the Bond people, everyone would be ecstatic with $200 million world wide. Bond going to hit a billion? That would be sweet. They won’t let Craig quit.

I’ve been watching Gone With the Wind most of the afternoon and evening. I could see Gerry as Rhett. Clark Gable was great in the role, but he got it because of his sexy image and looks and not his great acting chops.

@LOL: Eve’s “surfing” involves riding a bar of soap in the tub. Who is she kidding? She’s jealous and hateful because Madalina has Gerry (for now).

Like you, LOL, I don’t think their relationship is all smooth sailing. It’s definitely weird what with the ring shopping. Not sure what to make of it. I’ll thank God every day for my hubby and kids and hope that Maddie and Gerry find happiness.

re gerry and rhett @ 11/21/2012 at 8:18 pm

@windy: Agree with what you wrote. Some roles like Rhett just take a charismatic leading man, not necessarily Laurence Olivier.On that note…Tom Hardy was a much better Heathcliff than Olivier.Of course, Hardy has it all. Looks and acting ability. But, I’d still see Butler as “Butler”, Rhett that is, over Hardy.

@re gerry and rhett: Well, it’s a moot point because there should NEVER be a remake of GWTW. But if I ever read it again, I’ll picture Rhett as looking just like GJB.

Just saw gerard butler on 3rd street in santa monica

Hope Maddie and he can get some time together. I know Thanksdgiving is not something celebrated in Scotland but still hope he has a nice day with friends.

angelsrock @ 11/21/2012 at 9:26 pm


Oh, poor baby! She looks like the little soccer player in the trailer that says her sister died.
Bless her heart!

Home made biscuits @ 11/21/2012 at 9:27 pm

In regards to the pic and article of him and that little girl, why aren’t the press in the US picking it up? It’s very emotional and important information for everyone. Plus it would be great to help the parents raise money and would show a side of G that is worth the public knowing. So sad and disappointing all the way.

“I’ll thank God every day for my hubby and kids ”
There you go, that’s what’s important in the end. Nothing beats that.
Have a wonderful Thanksgiving, to you and yours.
Who knows what’s really going on with GB and her. The ring shopping was a strange exercise. But i have seen pics of her shopping before in Italy for Jewelry. it could be one of those things she likes buying for herself. I think it sends a bad message to the man in your life if you buy Jewelry for yourself, unless it’s something small and inexpressive like costume Jewelry. if she is buying diamond for herself, it radiates too much independence. I think she should wait for him to buy expensive pieces for her.
If it’s an engagement ring she is looking for because he asked her to marry him (which i don’t think is the case yet), then i hate that too. It should be his decision to buy what he thinks is right for her, with her taste in mind of course. It takes all the romance out of it when the woman makes the choice and the man doesn’t surprise her with it.

He celebrated Thanksgiving before. He usually gets invited by his friends to their Thanksgiving dinner.
If MG is in the states with him, it will be twice as nice. But i think she’s still in Europe. Hell, but who knows, maybe she caught a flight today and came to the states already. Maybe they will spend more time together while he promotes and starts shooting again. It’s the only way this relationship will have a fighting chance.

“And The Ugly Truth made over $200 million dollars world wide. How is that not successful as compared to like many of say Clooney’s recent films. Except for the Bond people, everyone would be ecstatic with $200 million world wide. Bond going to hit a billion? That would be sweet. They won’t let Craig quit.”
TUT did very well, just like LAC. so he had some winners besides 300. He’ll find another good project soon enough. Maybe PFK will do good. that’s what i am projecting.
Skyfall was excellent. We saw it 2 times. it has made almost 2/3 of a billion dollars. Unbelievable. Can’t get enough of Bond.

It’s my understanding that MG is due back in London for filming. She gave an interview at the Rome film fest stating that she was going back to London. “Dom Hemingway” is still shooting. It hasn’t wrapped yet.

Ring Shopping @ 11/21/2012 at 10:11 pm

Again with the moronic comments. Madi was not ring shopping. She was returning borrowed jewelry from her red carpet and award ceremony. The store was using it as publicity which is why she was being filmed.

Can'tGetEnough @ 11/21/2012 at 10:18 pm

Good Evening JJer’s! Here’s a photo of GB. He seems to be in Santa Monica. Didn’t he spend last Thanksgiving there as well?? Anyone remember?
Hope you all have a very Happy Thanksgiving!
I love my job and i love LA #inlove #GerardButler #love #handsome #santamonica @ Bar Chloe

@Ring Shopping:
Exactly! I made another post fter i read facebook’a post.
Damiani lent her Jewelry for the awards show (as many jewelers do) and she was returning it to them. I guess the crazies theory of her pretending to buy an engagement ring and be photographed doing it, in order to drive the fan girls crazy is not the case.

I meant Exactly! I made another post fter i read facebook’a post but it didn’t show on the board. (getting sidetracked with BF around who wants me to quit posting on JJ and pay attention to him.
so she is going back to London? You see, that’s not going to bode well for them in the long run, but i guess a girl’s got to do what a girl’s got to do.
I missed some of the info. because i couldn’t read all the news on the last 2 threads, as they were full of horrible ant-Semitic posts. I just gave up and skipped to this thread.
Do you know what’s GB’s next move, did he say anything?

SouthernBelle @ 11/21/2012 at 10:34 pm


Here’s another article – same content as fb.


@Gerard the flirt:
I totally believe he had chemistry with Jessica Biel and they might have gotten involved with each other if she wasn’t still in love with JT and was more into casual sex. And the way he describes her is right in the money for being a pieces.
“”Then the more you get talking, and suddenly she makes a joke and you go, ‘You’re funny!’ Then you get this whole other side of her,” said Butler, who now counts Biel as a really good friend. “[W]ith me you get it all immediately. But with her it’s like this you know you peel back layers and you just see more and more depth and humor. ”
Pisces girls hate meaningless or cheap sex, yet they are very sexual. The best match for a Scorpio man is a Pisces, bar none. The way he explains about the pealing of the layers is very accurate since Pisces women are very mysterious and feminine and you have to give them time before they will trust you enough for sex, but once they do the sex is mind blowing, just like the Scorpio like it. Men in general are very fascinated by Pisces, but especially the Scorpio. The way he talks about her and her personality, it sounds like he would have wanted something to happen between them and he cared enough to study her to catch something of her core personality. I’m starting to give it 80% chance of truth about him being sorry she got away.
Cancer girls are also a good match for Scorpios.

dargabriel @ 11/21/2012 at 10:54 pm

Greetings JJ and Happy Holidays. Looking good butler, don’t be afraid to let your gaurd down, you don’t need to go to gyms, a body looks best toned only, more of a natural state, less stress on the temple. Hi my friend Rahel, I love you, remember what we’re taught about others who don’t understand the inner workings, negativity loves to rapture, this is truth. You are a lovely person, have a beautiful holiday. I hope life is rolling for gerard, he’s itchen for something,lol. Hopefully for butler he finds his true light and then the magic happens for many. Love and peace to all. Sincerely, dargabriel

Thanks for the link.
The Jewelry is nothing special. Very simple and nothing extravagant or eye popping. Definitely nothing a gold digger would wear.

But i have to add she wasn’t glamorous at all. her dress was nothing special either, and her hair and makeup were simple, kind like MG wears it all the time. It’s definitely not like you show up to an awards show in the USA. She is more simple than most think of her here. Maybe it’s why he likes her. she isn’t too extravagant.

SouthernBelle @ 11/21/2012 at 11:09 pm


My birthday is the same as GB’s – Nov. 13, and my best relationships have been with Taurus and Leo men. Didn’t know about Pisces.

Happy Thanksgiving @ 11/21/2012 at 11:15 pm

Just wondering about him working out. We haven’t heard anything lately about it. Isn’t Nicki Holender in LA and is he still G’s trainer?

He said someday he loves her? Why all of a sudden decided that he’s in love with her? He did not even call her by name! He says “my gf” It’s all so fake!

Hello everyone. To all the americans that post here have a happy and healthy thanksgiving. Be greatful for family and friends. To everyone else have a wonderful day.

“My birthday is the same as GB’s – Nov. 13, and my best relationships have been with Taurus and Leo men. Didn’t know about Pisces.”
Cool. My BF is a Scorpio too. He just had his birthday last weekend. They are very spiritual even if not religious, that’s why water signs are best suited for them, except Scorpio. Not that another Scorpio is bad, just that it creates a lot of emotions, sparks, and both are suborn, so it depends on other things whether or not it can work.
Scorpio men do well with Pisces, but for the ladies it’s a little different though. I am not sure you would have done well with a Pisces because they tend to be submissive. Even the men can play both sides, be dominate at times and submissive at others, unless he has some Aries influences. Then the sex could be explosive.
Both Taurus and Leo, are actually perfect matches for the Scorpio lady. I can’t think of better matches, especially Taurus who is on the same axis but the exact opposite – so you complement each other. Both Taurus and Scorpios are very much into intimacy and being with the ONE.
With a Leo, he is such a strong dominate personality that he commends such respect form his woman, and who better to appreciate him than a Scorpio lady who know all about power and strength? That respect and appreciation can make a great intimate connection between a man and a woman.
And both Taurus’ and Leos love luxuries and the finer things in life, just like the Scorpio so again these are good matches. The only downside is that all three are stubborn signs so there is always a test of wills. Some can handle these situations better than others. It depends on a lot of things.
It’s interesting you are a Scorpio. Almost everyone drawn to Gerry is either a Scorpio herself, a water sign, has Scorpio influences, is involved with a Scorpio or was involved with a Scorpio at some time.


She just look like a freaking moron. She’s always staring right at the camera like she HAS to make sure there’s a camera on her. it’s just lame. She’s not natural at all. How conceited do you have to act all “winsome” and then blatantly stare at the camera with this goofy please with herself expression like a kid that just did a cartwheel? I mean it’s beyond the pale. Putting cheap pix online everywhere that were taken by phone in a mirror. it’s the antics of a 15 YO girl. Which is understandable. The young ones are just discovering their appeal. This is NOT the same as someone that got kicked out of school *12 years ago* for doing that. The whole thing is way past acceptable behavior. I never liked the “little girl” act, it’s asinine. Only asian girls can get away with that type of little girl nonsense at 28 or 30 because they are so delicate and feminine. Their whole culture is childlike charm, It doesn’t work on a 6 foot tall giraffe with a mouth as big as bass. Esp one that is not at all feminine even though she thinks she is.

What are you so freaking angry about? is she your family? is she your sister, daughter, friend, what?

do you know her well enough to make decisions about her personality and worth?
You make all your decisions based on some photos or some stories you read in the media without knowing her yourself. How would you like it if your neighbor told me awful things about you and i believed him/her without making that determination for myself by getting to know you personally? that’s essentially what you are doing. You have no real knowledge of her personally, yet you are judging her.
Anyway, what business is it of yours who he dates? If he likes her, is attracted to her, she is his type, he wants her, what is it to you?
I’m sorry but your comment is so viscerally hateful, it only means that you are simply very jealous of her and are upset, irritated, resentful, and frustrated he has a GF. There is no other reason for you to be so obsessed with hatting her, and that goes for everyone else here who sits on JJ 24/7 and spews MG hate, not just you.

SouthernBelle @ 11/22/2012 at 1:40 am


Thank you – appreciate your response. Glad I got a chance to read it before we’re both thumbed into oblivion. Happy Thanksgiving.

LOL= Gone Already? Nailed. @ 11/22/2012 at 2:03 am


(laughs) Never know when I’ll go into moderation. But seriously… is she still here? That makes hours on end. Doesn’t she ever get tired of, well, just typing? (more laughs)
Good to see Gerry someplace he knows he’s welcomed and out of the City of the Fallen Angel for Thanksgiving!

Santa Monica @ 11/22/2012 at 2:19 am

Santa Monica is in the LA area unless you know he’s off somewhere else.

Trying again… saved message…
She is insensitive, naive, ignorant, heartless and dumb… or scared. And most like a victim (of some kind) herself. Hurt people hurt people.
She’s a bore, a fraud and heartless and knows nothing about life, or living beyond the text box or her hickville circle of fake friends. Her laptop is her friend! Don’t let her get to you. She’s “hidden” for a reason.
I respect you and your challenges. Have you read Maureen Channing? She is an ex victim turned therapist. She has a book that might be helpful but it sounds like recovery is not a fleeting thing for you. You are there.
Acceptance is king, or in this case queen. In accepting your situation and being able to name it, label it, you take control of it not the reverse.
And besides, until you’re broken, you don’t know what you’re made of. (wink) Challenge on! Meet those negative voices with a question, “Where’s the evidence?” If you can’t find any, and chances are you won’t, then tell it, like in Cloud Atlas, to take hike.

Santa Monica @ 11/22/2012 at 2:23 am

What’s with the moderation lately? It’s been happening to everyone except the political trolls.

Hypocrete Much? @ 11/22/2012 at 2:51 am

For one who is capable of spending hours on JJ, you’re one to talk about LOL who is more rational and more intelligent than your mumblings, and definitely spends a lot less time than you on JJ.
You need to seek help form a shrink yourself, so it’s laughable you are offering advise to another. When was the last time you engaged in something constructive and beneficial to your life that didn’t involve posting stuff about Gerry? It must be years now. So sad.


Not at all, but that’s a typical response for the mindless, such as your boring one note self. I don’t covet stupidity, I merely don’t like it. I don’t like the protracted infancy of the western world these days where a 27 YO is a “girl”, and everyone acts like a entitled baby. I hate game playing and find it tiresome.

You are addicted to drama, I loathe BS. Let’s just cut the ****. When you’re 30ish and 45ish, these stupid little games aren’t charming anymore. I see more adult behavior from Matt Latner and his fiancee that are actually young then these two dolts. They actually Twitter to each other and if others can’t handle it it’s too bad, but they are sincere and that makes it endearing.

As for GB, I have been a fan of his for maybe a month or two, long after he started dating this woman. And I could care less, I just can’t stand HW BS. I know actors ad they don’t act stupid, they don’t buy their own hype and are cool as hell. They are well rounded and not addicted to attention.

As for asian females, they are treated as children and have to act hyper girly which I find sad and not alluring. I knew a 40 YO woman from Vietnam that was literally spanked like a child for some perceived wrong doing by her husband. I respect a strong woman.

And this forum is frankly more interesting than Gerry is. He’s attractive and cute in personality, but he’s not so amazing that he should generate this much angst and shite. i find it amusing for my after work unwinding. And am so thankful i never wanted to be famous.

We invite you to join us for an Exclusive Screening for the upcoming movie Playing For Keeps. The cast and filmmakers are supporting Soccer For Hope as we raise funds for cancer research at Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
. My friends Abella has a speaking part in the movie and Oliver was the Technical Soccer Advisor for the production. Come show your support!

It takes a pretty sick person to thumb down a post about a PFK charity screening for children like Abella. What is wrong with some people?


“Men don’t do anything they don’t feel like doing.”

Are you serious? If you really believe that then you don’t know men at all! How many men do you think want to cut the grass or go shopping or fix the disposal or that dripping faucet or take out the garbage or go see that silly rom-com his girlfriend/wife wants to see or go to the in-laws for dinner. Men do stuff they don’t want to do all the time and especially if they want sex. Don’t say ridiculous things!

@GEEZ!: Right! She claims to “know stuff” but she doesn’t know men. Probably never leaves her basement dungeon, either. She sounds like a reclusive bore.

If my husband had his way, he’d do nothing but sleep, eat pizza and pasta and drink beer every weekend. Oh, and play golf. But he has responsibilities to our children and myself, too. We share the workload and it’s so much easier. He grumbles about it but it’s all in fun.

@LOL: It was some tabloids that were reporting it that she was engagement ring shopping.

Not North American but Romanian tabloids the odd Italian but even the Italian press is not that interested in GB and MG. The Romanians want to see one of their own married to the guy. But I tend to believe a certain someone or her agent feed the Romanian tabloids from time to time. Like Team Gerry does here for example.

Another day should bring another photo op since we are pre movie release. Gerry buys Diet Coke at the local gas station. Gerry walks along the Santa Monica pier. Gerry walks Lolita in his Los Feliz neighborhood. Gerry and Alan lunch in Beverly Hills.

PS I think that if you use a link that has her name in it and particularly Romanian links that seems to trigger moderation.

Transcribing my interview with Gerard Butler. Wow, this guy is humbling. #ImThankfulFor some of the great perspective he’s provided.

“You can have 1 foot in tomorrow, 1 foot in yesterday & you are pissing on today. Stay Here! Be focused on the moment!” Gerard Butler to me

He’s so right! That’s my lug! That’s what he learned from this summer. He was so way ahead of himself. Seems to have gotten his head on straight after all!


Transcribing my interview with Gerard Butler. Wow, this guy is humbling. #ImThankfulFor some of the great perspective he’s provided.
“You can have 1 foot in tomorrow, 1 foot in yesterday & you are pissing on today. Stay Here! Be focused on the moment!” Gerard Butler to me

It’s amazing how gullible some people are. As long as someone is quite pretty, famous and rich some will believe any bullsh*t that comes out of their mouth. No wonder  some many rich people have so much contempt for the poor

This is a cover art of my sinful fan fic series (written in Japanese) . The man next to McAvoy is Gerard Butler;-)

The village peasant isn’t “getting” anything. My guess is she’s been paid off and is now, for the most part, a thing (literally) of his past. Fa. ce it, if they were a real couple, they’d be together and he’s support her career in want of to make her “famous” which is what she went after him for anyways. No, we have a man who has seen the light, smelled the coffee and who do what he does not want to do. Like I said, men are feeling creatures and work off feelings. He needed to feel like going to her (cough) award thing. Did he? No. Actions with men speak louder than words!
~K wishing everyone, even the reptile LOL, a happy Thanksgiving and to remind yourselves of all you have to be thankful and grateful for!!

The clam is sounding more and more like someone from IMDb. And one who is “friends” with a few (and their are only a few) regulars there too.
who thinks you described Ms.LOL not me who wants to say that husband of yours does what he does b/c he loves you and wants to make you happy, which means a happy wife equals a happy husband… in other words he does it because he truly does feel like it

They are SO together, we’re worried for your health when you find out. (We know stuff)

Yes, yes he IS HOT!

Yeah, right, so that’s we don’t see stuff, right?
All I know is you are here morning, noon, afternoon, night, all night all day, every day for some reason and that’s to taunt like Clam and Ms. Reptile (LOL).
Have a nice day.

Curious the use of “we”. You and your alternate ego or in cahoots with others at fan=sites? ooOPs. So you’re The Guardian here? (wink) Yeah, right. Maybe you’re disabled, and if so that’s sad, but to be here like you are is a huge curiosity.
Anyways, makes no difference as good for right now is just that, good for right now. Sex on demand. Company on demand. Not love. No way he can trust her, or her him, and both know it. If they are together, it makes no difference in the big scheme of things because it is mutual use, and that is never love. His heart belongs to another, and always will.
He’s too emotionally shut down (now) to do anything but fornicate with the person, if her, or anyone to meet masculine needs. He’s too many issues to be in a committed relationship, and knows it. She’s no capabilities of handling the real him… just the court jester he plays when around her if even .15% of what you say is true. He is never his real self with her and can never be. Not putting him down, not my point, but he’s had some serious self heart-to-hearts this fall.
The fallout from this has been huge, and costly. And, let’s face it, he’s been apart (if even together which I highly doubt) way too much for this to be serious.
This person can elude with more fake clues all she wants to keep her name out there and being talked about here (as her relationship exists only in her mind) but he was NOT there for her when he could be and that says more than anything. She comes on demand like a call-girl.
The little dumb girl is a waste of time and he knows it. If he is serious about connecting emotionally, he’s got to rid himself of his anger (toward her specifically for all the damage to his career and his closest heart-partner… that is not her and never ever will be) and toward himself for allowing it. Will say no more. BUT today is a good day to atone.
~K, making this her last post for the day wishing everyone the best day of they year so far!!

food 4 thought @ 11/22/2012 at 10:04 am

Well this is a dose of ick. Djimon Hounsou and Kimora Lee Simmons are separating. The GB connection is this – apparently Djimon has been carrying on with the nasty Kola Boof. So let’s review – GB costarred with Djimon in “Tomb Raider”, and b0inked Boof at some point. Now Djimon has been b0inking Boof as well. I would just laugh at the lunacy of it all, but there are kids involved, so it’s not at all funny.

food 4 thought @ 11/22/2012 at 10:07 am

Happy Thanksgiving to all the crazy JJrs, and the sane ones as well! If you celebrate this holiday – enjoy yourselves. And enjoy the day even if it’s not your holiday. I’m grateful for the many laughs I have had in these threads.

dargabriel @ 11/22/2012 at 12:19 pm

I wish everyone a very nice day. Why does people have to be so mean? God isn’t this world full of enough madness? Spending thanksgiving by myself, emotionally cleansing, broken hearted, because of madness, I don’t belong in the madness, although I love everyone. Please someone answer this for me? My wish, will butler ever let go of his heart partner? It’s not really fair to the other half, love is free, free the heart, forget and let go. I really feel this other half wants to forget and wipe the memory from the face of humanity. If someone answers, wonderful and I thank you from this heart. Go,go,go, lassie. Love,dargabriel

dargabriel @ 11/22/2012 at 12:38 pm

Really thumbs down, what a dis graccceee, god be with you

angelsrock @ 11/22/2012 at 12:43 pm


I’m so sorry that you are alone right now. Take care of yourself. God bless you.

dargabriel @ 11/22/2012 at 12:53 pm

@angelsrock: thank you, its all fine, I chose it, needed space and time. I guess I’m alone, but definitely not lonely. Made peace with a mom who wasn’t nice to me, I always am the bigger person, even after, gabriel has screwed me over, through people, a life lesson. God bless you too. Love, dar

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/22/2012 at 1:07 pm

@Wtf: And it seems that you have comtempt for the rich. Why is that?
Yesterday is ashes.
Tomorrow is green wood.
Only today does the fire burn brightly.
- Eskimo Saying

“Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tomorrow. Albert Einstein.
Matt 6:34″So don’t worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will bring its own worries. Today’s trouble is enough for today.

Isn’t it all the same said in a different way? I thought it was lovely to know that he has such insight . You don’t have to be pretty or rich or famous to have a belief in the importance of living in the moment.
I enjoy hearing of Gerry sitting with people he has never met and before and conversing with them. He doesn’t seem to be the reg. HW type as is read in many tweets and the also the cast and crew of the movies he is in. Seems pretty down to earth to me and glad the interviewer was able to draw him out. Good man.
Happy Thanksgiving JJ’rs. Ducky

ron howard and gerard butler were at my work yesterdaaay. <3

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/22/2012 at 1:21 pm

Hi Dar, Glad you are spending the day as you choose. Don’t have an answer for you, wish I did. So, he travels the same road we all do. Mistakes will be made, sorrow and broken hearts are impossible to avoid, but then joy also come unexpectedly. It’s called life.
Good that you made peace with mom. More for yourself and the peace that you get for the effort. You will be blessed for it. You did good. Love, Ducky

Happy Thanksgiving @ 11/22/2012 at 2:06 pm

May all my JJ friends have a very happy and blessed day.
Remember —–we can either dwell on our woes or our blessings. Be thankful for all our blessings today.

Trying to figure it out @ 11/22/2012 at 2:39 pm


Trying to figure it out @ 11/22/2012 at 2:41 pm

Enjoy your day with your woodland friends.

Take care.
Gerard Butler, how many ways do I hate thee.
Let me count the ways:
I hate thee with the… No, it’s too many. I don’t have that much time.

I just wanna rip his shirt off. Sexy sexy hot dude, Mr Butler!

dargabriel @ 11/22/2012 at 3:27 pm

@Lord Love a Duck: I love you ducky, I wish you a very yummy day. Thank you for your answer, I kind of know, yet, it drives me crazy to know the real true answer, freaking maddening for his other half, its true what they say about scorpios, once they realize something belongs to them, they hang on tight, a true , aye,aye,aye, lol. Watching lassie bright sunshiney day, incredible there are bugs flying in fall a mile high, will be warm, then snow will fall very soon. Today I reflect on past and present, all of you and what you’ve brought to me. My children for bringing me so much joy,love and headache, also my dear mom, I forgive her, protect her, I forgive hurt feelings, sometimes when the closest people call you sunshine and then turn around and call you horrible names and says they never want to see you again, no less leave it on your message, I don’t understand doing a great deed for someone, then they lied to you, then leave you with a burden, mom did this to me over my Verizon bill. Anyways, I’ve learned not to let negativity rapture meself. I hope butler has much peace and warmth today and always. The universe has all kinds of tricks up its sleeve, I only wish my Gabriel could treat others with empathy. Have a blessed day. Love, dargabriel

No news is good news with Butler

Happy thanksgiving everyone – all my friends and all my hags, the free standing ones and the members of the Axis of Haggery (@Clamsie, thanks for the suggestion). Please, just for one day, abandon your MG trashing, bashing, slashing, noshing, and gnashing and think about the positives in your life this year and give thanks. And, of course, don’t forget to think about Gerry and all he has to be thankful for this year, most of all MG, the ONE who is keeping him out of bars and clubs – chasing and pursuing, flirting and prowling, pillaging and plundering, partying and shagging, Thank you MG for all you have done to keep law and order in place for our caveman with a law degree (as one poster calls him). Let’s give thanks.

dargabriel @ 11/22/2012 at 3:37 pm

@Trying to figure it out: Thank you enjoy your day. Happy turkey day to you. Love,dargabriel

Mehhh. Carb stupor. Do aspirins help with artery clogging?

@LOL: why don’t you leave here and start the MG fan club somewhere? You obviously are more a fan of her than him. I think you should but on her pages not his. Join her FB and drool over her there. Happy T Day.

@blatantgirlcrush @ 11/22/2012 at 4:07 pm

@LOL: why don’t you leave here and start the MG fan club somewhere? You obviously are more a fan of her than him. I think you should but on her pages not his. Join her FB and drool over her there. You sound rather bicurious.

Happy T Day.

@blatantgirlcrush @ 11/22/2012 at 4:09 pm


FIFY blue… :-) :-)

Your memory is purposely selective considering the Halloween parties, number collecting, along with the strip club he was seen exiting (caught on film) recently. Suit yourself.
Any changes made were suggested long before the empty thumb drive showed up, trust me. he got an ear-full on Howard Stern that sent him running from NYC! Feel being used as a sex slave tucked away for months out of sight so someone doesn’t dog about isn’t exactly flattering.
His choice to pull it together before his career goes belly up thanks to his low-end call-girl who runs to him on demand like a lap dog ruins it completely with her selfish self-focused rush for what she’s not getting, fame… or his heart.
No one here gives crap about her at all. In fact the opposite. All USA press is distancing themselves from the one with a worse reputation than him, her.
who is glad he’s with a group of genuine friends doing something very traditional

Uneffinbelievable @ 11/22/2012 at 5:50 pm

Why am I not surprised that the troll is so sick it can’t even stop poking, prodding, and pulling the wings off flies on Thanksgiving. Guess we have confirmation it has no life, as if we didn’t know.

A fan for all seasons @ 11/22/2012 at 6:23 pm

If you’re taking the troll’s jokes too seriously and angrily, maybe it means you’re too invested in the hatred of Gerry’s GF. Could it be your inane jealousy of Madalina?

Hope each and every one is having fantastic day!

Happy Thanksgiving To All and God Bless!

Gerry is scheduled to be on Ellen, Tuesday, November 4.

angelsrock @ 11/22/2012 at 9:00 pm


That would be Dec. 4. Hard to believe we are almost through November, isn’t it? Also scheduled for Leno on the 3rd and GMA on the 5th!
I will look forward to that week. the DVR will be busy. As all of those programs are on while I’m at work or while I’m sound asleep. Can’t do the late night talk shows anymore. Lights out for me by 11.

Diana Guminski @ 11/22/2012 at 10:28 pm

Looks like the PR team is using JJ as its bi.ii.itch. JJ is the film, ads everywhere. It must be really bad. This is as bad as pretending to be in Maui for Thanksigiving.


Gosh I guess you guys had not to much to be thankful for today because it’s better to be hateful.

Getting a little worried about you lately with the Madi-hating. Even if this young woman had some questionable behaviour in her youth, who hasn’t? Does that mean that these people don’t deserve the chance to love, grow and be happy?

It’s amazing how you read a story and only yank out the details that suit your delusion. You’re just being played.

IfAnyonePlayedItIsThatPerson~K @ 11/23/2012 at 3:39 am

No one cares about this person trust me. This person is an on-demand lay summoned like a call girl when needed who puts up with it (and all his other more important women in his life who’ll still be around long after she’s gone) and that’s just sad because if anyone is getting played, it’s her and she’s just too dumb to see it. LOL

You totally did not get what you were being told, but you’ll figure it out on your own. MG isn’t going anywhere.

ChelSHIIT HOndler @ 11/23/2012 at 4:42 am

Happy Thanksgiving everyone.


@ #196

Unfortunately for Gerard Butler, his family, any friend who genuinely ever gave a t/oss about him, and also for what remains of his fanbase –
it’s been made abundantly clear for months by you (nameless poster) and by her own schoolyard mentality and behaviour, that she’s not going anywhere.
It’s a shame Gerard Butler turned out to be an idiot of the highest level professionally and clearly personally too.

Kali Orexi @ 11/23/2012 at 5:38 am

I just read this article:

New Delhi, Nov 23 (IANS) Hollywood actor Gerard Butler reveals that he once planned to skip his flight just to meet his good friend and Bollywood actress Priyanka Chopra, while she was in the US.

In a candid interview, Butler opened up about his affection for Priyanka, said a statement.

He said: “Last year, Priyanka was here (US) and I was going out of town to a wedding. I stay in Malibu and she was coming to party at Malibu and I couldn’t meet.”

“I was even thinking of missing the plane and going and saying hello because I hadn’t seen her in a long time. But we are in touch all the time,” he added.

The 43−year−old Butler quips, “I am still single because I am waiting for Priyanka Chopra.”

Meanwhile, the actor is looking forward to the release of his new film “Playing For Keeps”, which hits the screens Dec 7.

He says he is SINGLE!

looking for gerry @ 11/23/2012 at 6:22 am

wierd no gerry’s pics or twitter since wed.

hey even this thread’s was dead yesterday, everyone in the US wasThanksgiving it.

@Kali Orexi: Gerry seems to be pining away for a number of women that GOT AWAY other than the one’s he been schtupping on and off for the past few months. Guess beauty doesn’t you everything after all.

She is career cancer for him.

She does not make him his best self.

@Kali Orexi:
Wow, they (the press,and the industry or the business) hate this good for only fornicating on demand that much?! Ouch.

Love isn’t spite.

He is not proud of her. It’s pretty necessary.

@Kali Orexi: oh that’s interesting. did he recently say that or are they rehashing an old interview?

Kali Orexi @ 11/23/2012 at 8:25 am

@missjude: The interview was printed in the papers today, doubt it’s an old interview as he is talking about looking forward to the release of PFK.

She can never be trusted, ever. That’s kind of important.

It shows the press hates this python. It’s proof positive. Like I said career cancer.

She will never know him. He will never know her. It’s superficial and shallow without depth nor emotional connection.

Demanding a type is a condition. Conditions are not love.

Love is not control.

Love is more than a wet dyck. Love is more than called to service said dyck.

@Kali Orexi: oh wow, that confirms it then, he’s single. he must have dumped mg, probably why she looked miserable at the RFF.

He can’t believe one word out of her fish lips, ever. Not even the fake “Oh-oh-oh!” and he will come to hate her for all of it.

that was quick as he mentioned a girlfriend when he was talking about his birthday in an interview. Celebs move fast!

Something seriously got your panties twisted; no matter what abuse you heap on Miss Ghenea, she’s still with Gerard.

Kali Orexi @ 11/23/2012 at 8:44 am

@missjude: I guess we will have to wait till he does the tv interviews to hear if he’s still seeing her or not

It doesn’t matter if he’s still ba/nging her or not. The point is, if he’s willing to say something like that about another woman, then he’s not madly in love. It’s a slam and disrespectful. How would you feel if your boyfriend was talking publicly about another woman that way? He wouldn’t be talking about PC at all if he was serious about someone. There was no reason to, because she has nothing to do with his movie release, unlike the pr crap about JB.

It does not matter. There; not there.
Someone summoned on demand after spending weeks partying is not serious. She’s being used.
She is career cancer (his). She has no career.

I can’t believe that article! It speaks volumes. To do that means a lot by the press. Huge message. It means they do not like her at all and won’t play her games. God, to be hated so? No wonder he hides her. Ouch.

@missjude @ 11/23/2012 at 9:10 am

This article should be filed under the same category as Jessica Biel being the one who got away.

The only huge message from this article is that it was originated in the Bollywood tabs which were capitalizing on Gerry trying to get to India. You are, again trying to qualify your statements. What would your lug think about how you malign the woman he cares so deeply for?

He won’t mention her on national television because she’s bad news for his career.

They are making a point, or trying to. His heart belongs to another.

@@missjude: well we’ll see. not sure what interview the comment came from, it doesn’t say the source. time will tell

Physical attraction isn’t connection and never will be. He can never ever ever trust her. Did I say ever? Yeah, ever.

Come on, not even you can be so naive to believe that Gerry’s girlfriend has any bearing whatsoever on his career. Hollywood doesn’t care who he’s in a relationship with. They only care if his films make money. If their relationship was splattered from here to kingdom come, THEN maybe you could say his fans stayed away in droves because he’s seeing someone exclusively. You better relax and be prepared because the word is coming.

The jealous person is up to old tricks some place else but they won’t play. They will not be controlled or manipulated.

You’re seriously making this stuff up as you go along right? It’s part of the grand plot of your neverending story. Most tend to support the people they care about, not rip their decisions.

I agree and it goes with what I’ve been saying, he’s disrespectful to her. You aren’t disrespectful to people you are in love with. I betting this isn’t the end of Maddie but its coming soon. You can’t spend this much time away from someone and not drift apart. As far as Piggy Chops , he only wants her because he knows he can never have her. Mostly due to religious and cultural barriers.


Hmmm, this actually isn’t true. Hollywood does care about this kind of crap; it’s called image and branding. And the only reason the relationship isn’t “splattered from here to kingdom come” is because nobody cares about this guy. This is why everything he’s put out in the last two years has bombed… really bombed.

Usually your posts are correct, regardless of how unpopular they are, but this one was a little ignorant.

And for goodness sake, stop baiting the GFW. Every one knows she has issues; show a little pity.

@DocP: It appears he may be doing the passive/aggressive routine, which he’s used so many times before. It wouldn’t surprise me in the least if he’s trying to put distance between them now, and using the press to do it. I agree it’s a little odd that for someone “madly in love” they have spent more time apart than together since September. If it’s not completely done yet, it most likely soon will be.

@missjude: The Indian press are just trying to link him to PC. Don’t believe them. I’m not saying that he is with mg I’m just saying you can’t beleive 90% of the things you read.

@@@GFW: Thanks for saying that. Let GFW believe anything she wishes. This baiting and stalking of her is just sick and says a lot about this poster.

As a rule, relationships usually aren’t reported and hashed over unless it’s a power couple or tabloid fodder. It’s really not surprising this relationship isn’t a big deal. I agree with your comment about branding, however sometimes H’wood loves a good underdog story or bad boy makes good. Not saying this applies to GB per se.

And yes, noted.

It’s an old story and taken from an interview given to Indian media during MGP promotion. It doesn’t matter that PFK is mentioned as it’s just the Indian media way of recirculating old news and trying to make it seem current.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 10:22 am

“Hollywood doesn’t care who he’s in a relationship with. They only care if his films make money”
Oh yes they do but more so the fans. Why do you think they’ve drummed up the Biel/Butler rumors?

I see, thanks girls. just lazy journalism

The Special One @ 11/23/2012 at 10:30 am

Latest news from India: serious source, saying he is “single” and that he is “waiting for Priyanka”. I think he messed up the relationship with her but still “single”, so Madalina is nothing but a high paid hooker. Right?

Even when he is in a relationship he is not respectful IMO. Remember when he gave that interview while he was with either Jasmine or Bianca (I can never remember which one) and said he had several “someones special in his life… sorry darling.”
I agree that he uses the press to do his “dirty work.” I totally believe he just leaves or cuts off contact rather than be a man and say the words “I don’t want you or this any longer.”

Do you remember the Seinfeld episode about “the bad breaker upper”? Every time I see that episode I think of Gerry .

I apologizing for being so rude Kathy.

@Manny: I think that interview was way after either of those women had come and gone. .As I recall, no one knew of whom he spoke. Just “poor girl.” At the time, I wondered if it was really anyone or if it was just one of his stories for his idea of humor.

Thanks for being the bigger person. :)
@GFW – I hope you use your lunch break to go outside and breathe some fresh air. Spewing hate all day at Macaroni is not healthy IMO. I hope you have something in your life outside of Butlerland. BTW Macaroni has more claim to your “big lug” than you do… she has at least “known” him in the biblical sense…

Yes. Although I truly believe Butler is the non-breaker-upper. Just leave seems to be his MO…

@not sure:
He was with one of them at the time. I remember because there was a HUGE fight here about him dissing her and peeps definitely took sides on it.
BTW JJers I have figured out that JJ is getting greedy. It seems if you reply to more than one poster in your post you will be sent to moderation. The more hits the better for his pocketbook…

@Manny: Manny, I would think as a nurse you would have more compassion.

Maybe this is his way of keeping his options “open”- in case in wants them back (I’m joking of course:)

Interesting @ 11/23/2012 at 11:40 am

Manny sounds exactly like that Evila person at imdb.

Good Lord give it a rest. I have NEVER posted on IMDb and I haven’t read over there in years…

@Manny: Does anyone remember what he was promoting during that interview? That should give us the gf timeline

Wow, so many questions… Is there any merit in “news” reported by tabs? What’s believeable, what’s not? Do peeps want GB to have a GF? Whether MG or PC or and I’m sure the list goes on and on, lol. What’s real, what’s faux? What’s true, what’s for show? Well I do know one thing for a fact. PFK opens on Dec. 7 and I can’t wait to see it. GB in a towel, GB in the rain, GB in a red hot Ferrari. Yes, yes, yes! And the icing is that the story seems to be a really good one.

So glib… if you are injured you would be lucky to have a nurse like me…

I have freaking 10 posts in moderation. What gives JJ…
Is it compassionate to empower delusional people in their illness? GFW is troubled and needs to have a life outside of Butler. In fact she deserves that. If I had a clue where she lived I would be posting counseling resources here for her. Just reading the last page of her posts you can see she is so overwhelmed with her hatred of Macaroni that she is not even making sense. I may not be her fan but I can spot someone on the edge of another meltdown. Get a clue.
Sorry if you are not a fan of tough love, but in the long run who is doing her more good… you or me…
Think about it…

Previous was addressed to Pree…. OMG JJ…

Totally Useless Information @ 11/23/2012 at 12:41 pm

The only reason GB has the hots for Piggy Chops is she will not sleep with him. That makes her someone to conquer, but I think she’s one smart cookie and will never allow him to get that close. Little Maddie won’t last because while she’s probably a sweet young woman, she’s easy.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 12:44 pm

“If I had a clue where she lived I would be posting counseling resources here for her.”
Alexandria, VA and LOL lives in Webster, Mass. She could use some anger management!

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 12:46 pm

@Totally Useless Information: PC will never marry outside her culture/faith/religion. That’s why G wants her. He always wants what he can’t have.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 12:51 pm

@Manny: However, you can lead the horse to water but you can’t make him drink. The sickest minds don’t know they are and will never seek out help. They both need interventions. Let’s schedule one here!

@Manny: I am an advocate of tough love. IMO you were being needlessly cruel about it by rubbing her face in the physical nature of the “relationship”, which was unnecessary. There are kinder ways of delivering the same message. It won’t help to put her on the defensive.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 1:00 pm

A person says everything you need to know about them if you listen. Gerry reveals a lot about himself in interviews. Watch his body language, his posture and how he squirms in his chair with certain questions and interviewers. He speaks the truth first then says he’s kidding immediately afterwards. If it’s the first thing that pops in to his brain and his “filter” doesn’t catch it, and we all know the Butler filtering system, he’ll back it up by making it a joke. And when he says he’s kidding, he looks down. Liar, liar, pants on fire!

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 1:03 pm

@Pree: You are correct, really. When dealing with someone who may be mentally ill, tough love doesn’t work because the person will just feel threatened as how they feel and what they believe is real to them and they don’t see themselves as having a problem. They could “snap” and do something drastic if the reality they believe in feels threatened.

Another Opinion @ 11/23/2012 at 1:12 pm

This is no news. The Indian press is rehashing the PC story from last year; they’ve just added a reference to PFK to make it look like a new interview. I like it how people are still discussing whether Butler is faithful to MG or not. There is no evidence that Butler has been in an honest and monogamous relationship with a woman in the last couple of years. Just the opposite – his so called relationship with BC started as a PR stunt, just like MG, and according to a number of reports he cheated on her with a number of girls during TIFF (2006). When he said that he was dating 4 special people none of which was special enough, he was “dating” Jasmine Burgess (there are photos of them on New Year 2008). A couple of months later, he was still dating JB, a dancer and GR, all at the same time. At the time of the Kristi Korzec stunt he was still with JB and this allegedly put an end to their “relationship”. During the shooting of LAC he was supposedly still with Gina and the dancer, which didn’t prevent him from sleeping around with several people in Philadelphia and from flirting with PC in India. This was followed by the interview in which he admitted to having threesomes and by the admission of Alicia-Marie herself that they were sleeping together. What followed was a fest of shallowness – Beatriz, Martina and Laurie in 2011. It’s well established that he was seeing a married porn star with a kid last year, which ultimately led to her divorce. In the fall of last year he had a fling/one night stand with Brandi and was asking locals in Santa Cruz to sleep with him. Everyone also knows that this was followed by a two-week rehab, partying and a new PR saga involving MG. Butler has had the same lifestyle for at least a couple of years and there is no evidence what so ever that he has changed it. Of course he can say in interviews that what he wants in life now is spirituality and self- acceptance, but talking the talk is one thing and walking the walk another.

OMG! How naive can some people be? It’s either naiveté or old haggery speaking, hoping to make MG insignificant so it can feel good about itself.
First, The Indian press loves to link him to PC and also loves to mention to their readers how much he loves India. It’s flattery for the Indian people. They write a ton of articles about him a year, and they all say the same thing about him – namely, how much he loves India(that he’s visited) and how much he loves PC (that he proposed to her but she had a BF). All of it is bu.llcr@p. He and PC are friends, maybe they slept together at some point but no one knows for sure. She invited him to India and he went. There she had a huge party in his honor, and her BF was also invited. GB got on one knee and proposed but it was a joke. End of story. From that day forward the Indian media has rehashed the story repeatedly.
Because he knows how much the Indian press loves to rehash the same story repeatedly, when he gets interviews by the Indian Media he usually tells them things they want to hear. Basically, he’s a good sport about it and plays along. He doesn’t complain, ‘oh why did you say this or that, it’s not true’. Old hags best chill out. The only thing of value or true that came out of his mouth was that he is still single which is true, technically. He’s not married and he plays that to the max since he loves to be free for the girls to dream about him.

Second, he always says “I am still single because I am waiting for Priyanka Chopra.” In every interview for the Indian press. He knows what they want to hear. Pay attention to the language used in the article:
“In a candid interview, Butler opened up about his affection for Priyanka, said a statement.”
WHAT???? They call this opening up and a candid interview? That’s all they have to talk to him about? It’s pitiful how much the Indian press makes fun of themselves and India itself. It sounds like Indians have low self-esteem so they need to read stories about how westerners love their country and love their women. Please. It’s a dumb article and I am not even sure it’s recent because if it were, they would have discussed his upcoming movie PFK, not added a line in the end, Meanwhile, the actor is looking forward to the release of his new film “Playing For Keeps”, which hits the screens Dec 7.” It’s obvious they wanted to write an article about PFK, but they don’t have much material about it, so they sprinkled PC, which is something they love to do anyway, and then on the bottom added, PFK is coming out. BIG DEAL!

For GFW or her friends that are reading here and are really concerned about her…
She deserves to have a life. Gerard Butler as the center of your universe is sad.

@Who’s Naive Here?:
Thanks for the info. I posted a link.

In other words, I wouldn’t believe a damn thing coming from Indian press. They love to make their readers feel that Gerry is one of the family because he loves India so much and he even wanted to marry an Indian woman (PC), blah, blah, blah…..
That story about him wanting to go to India for his birthday is also manufactured. He said weeks before he was going to spend it with his family. Maybe he met someone in Dubai from India who invited him and he said he would love to come but that at this rate he couldn’t get a visa for him and his GF and the that conversation was leaked to the Indian press. Or, the Indian press made it up, pure and simple. But either way, that India-for-his-birthday story is definitely highly embellished. No way would he be able to get himself and MG a visa that last minute, and he knows it.
People need to forgo looking for far-fetched excuses why he isn’t with MG or doesn’t really care for her, etc…. If that’s the case you’d know soon enough. You don’t need to make up conspiracy theories or far- fetched explanations. And anyone who engages with GFW in this behavior is as disturbed as she is. So far, its 2 members of the Old Hags trifecta – GFW and DocP, all we need it Old Hag Supreme EVE and the place would look like a senior citizens luncheon.

This is the original old interview from where the Indian press is taking the info …

That’s your opinion. Stating bluntly is the kindest way and doesn’t leave it open to interpretation. And reminding her that he is not hers and she is not a part of his intimate life is direct whether you think it is kind or not. Sheeeesh…

God Bless yoou all! @ 11/23/2012 at 2:40 pm

“May you experience the love of Christ, though it is too great to understand fully. Then you will be made complete with all the fullness of life and power that comes from God.” – Ephesians 3:19

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 3:39 pm

@Manny: If she ever actually got to meet him in person, she might be cured! LMFAO!

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 3:50 pm

@Mmmmmmm: It’s odd that this story would be recycled now when he has a supposed “girlfriend”. Why do you suppose that is? He has friends in India. Maybe he told them to pull it out and dust it off? Who knows? For someone who is “with her”, (MG) he’s not with her very much now is he? Afterall, he did say he wanted to go to India instead of Scotland for his BD. That would certainly make a girl feel like she was an after thought after spending time with him there, wouldn’t it? Maybe he was going to take MG and make PC jealous? Who knows what goes on in the mind of The Butler!

Just reading all this garbage about Piggy Chops whay is someone called Piggy Chops. Seems like once or twice a year a story out of Bollywood comes up have him and her. I did about a year or two hear him say in an interview with a Bollywood press person that she was in LA but he was going out of the country and yes he did say he was thinking about not catching his flight but guess what he didn’t, he flew off to the wedding. I think Piggy uses him for PR too. I liked an interview I just heard from Toronto where he said his girl friend. Cut him a break the guy is in love you may not but he loves her. Not everyone is going to love evyerone else. But was pull down people, it’s not getting you anywhere except maybe high blood pressure and an early grave.

@Cara: I wouldn’t hold my breath if I were you.

Drama Queen @ 11/23/2012 at 4:10 pm

Do you seriously think anyone gets there blood pressure up just because of GB?? Okay well that was loaded question let me phrase it differently. i seriously doubt MOST get their pan’ties in a wad over whether GB has a gf or if he is still pining over piggy chops. Its a gossip site, its for fun not stress.

Poor Gerry @ 11/23/2012 at 4:19 pm

It´s obvious that he suffers from attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, ADHD.
I noticed that he can´t sit still during a lot of interviews. I think he is easily bored, unsteady. All this roaming around, taking pics with fans for his daily ritual, this is so weired and it´s going on for years now. Maybe he needs a stop in a bonzery, visit Tibet and the Dalai Lama, to find enlightening for his soul, not chasing Bollywood beauties or going on a shag tour through India.

Who's Naive Here?=EVE @ 11/23/2012 at 4:39 pm

Who’s Naive Here?
Not us. We know who you are. Try again beotch witch.

@Who’s Naive Here?=EVE: Your continuous attempts to out this “Eve” person are becoming tedious and boring. No one cares if it’s her or not.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 5:15 pm

@Who’s Naive Here?=EVE: What’s this “we” business, sugar? You’re the only one who seems to get your dander up when someone around here makes better sense then you do AND does it without calling people names. You might fare better if you tried a more positive approach to your theories and opinions instead of calling anyone who doesn’t agree with you an old hag betch.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 5:17 pm

After earlier talk about obsession with celebrities and mental health, found this interesting tidbit.

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 5:36 pm

@So what?: She cares and that’s all that matters. Talk about someone OBSESSED!

Who's Naive Here? @ 11/23/2012 at 5:39 pm

By the way would someone tell me who or what is EVE? I’ve never seen her posts today??

Toxic waste @ 11/23/2012 at 5:43 pm

Oh man, this place can be very toxic! I think most of you need mental therapy!

@Who’s Naive Here?: As soon as you pose that question someone will acuse you of being “Eve” It happened to me, too. I don’t remember ever seeing a post by someone named Eve, although I haven’t been on ths site for long. I think “Eve” is like Bigfoot or the ChupaCabra-a lot of folklore, but I’m not so sure that it really exists.

Diana Guminski @ 11/23/2012 at 6:15 pm

@Manny: GFW is Moira Framadodo without the money to stalk GB.

dargabriel @ 11/23/2012 at 6:28 pm

@Toxic waste: including yourself, perhaps? Do not judge if you don’t expect to be judged. Have a wonderful day. Peace, dargabriel, P.S. Just saying and defending great people on jj.

He has what, 10 days, before he has to appear for anything, if I’m not mistaken, so maybe he’s gone away to get his candle waxed again. I’ll be mildly curious to see where he turns up.

@Oh well: Southern hemisphere, I would bet.

Totally Useless Information @ 11/23/2012 at 7:10 pm

We all know he lies, we all know he can’t be faithful (no one is ever special enough including little Maddie), we all know he’s got the hots for Piggy, we all know GFW is totally obsessed, we all know Eve trolls, we all know people think he ADHD, we all know everything ad nauseam, on and on it goes, where it’ll stop, no one knows. So now we have another know it all that repeats what many have been saying for months like it’s big news. It is rather amusing.

wiphoenix @ 11/23/2012 at 7:20 pm

There’s no earthly way of knowing / Which direction we are going / There’s no knowing where we’re rowing / Or which way the river’s flowing / Is it raining? / Is it snowing? / Is a hurricane a-blowing? / Not a speck of light is showing / So the danger must be growing / Are the fires of hell a-glowing? / Is the grisly reaper mowing? / Yes, the danger must be growing / ‘Cause the rowers keep on rowing / And they’re certainly not showing / Any signs that they are slowing!

troll talk is boring. why give them any attention? the definition of a troll means that they are mentally unstable so it is actually cruel to interact and humour them because it’s just encouraging their behaviour.

lets keep to gossip.

I love Willie Wonka!!!

@Who’s Naive Here?:

Sorry, but you are so wrong! You are obviouly one of the people who simply doesn’t get Gerry’s sense of humor. His first response is not the “truth” at all. He just likes to say something off the wall because he’s trying to be funny and then he qualifies what he said by saying he’s “just kidding”. I know that because I do the same thing. Someone calls me on the phone and asks “What are you doing?” I might answer by saying “Smoking a joint.” Since I don’t use drugs, I think it’s funny but someone who doesn’t know me might not get it. I often give ‘smart ass’ answers and then realize some may think I’m serious and i say the same thng “just kidding”.

The fact that someone reacts differently to any given situation doesn’t make them wrong necessarily, it just makes them different. As far as body language goes, maybe you need to srudy up on it a little more unless you are a professional profiler. Many may not agree with you on that.

Untamable Shrew @ 11/23/2012 at 8:38 pm

Mr.Butler reminds me of my brother.Except my brother was married 2x.He has a live-in girlfriend now.Anyhoo,my brother can’t retain a relationship with a woman very long.He always has another on the back burner too.I could never get close with his girlfriends or sister-n-laws lol,because they never lasted.He’s a flirt,broke up a few marriages too.The girlfriend he has now wants to marry my brother.I know he won’t He’s wasting her time.He doesn’t want to be lonely.Pure selfishness.Nothing different for Mr.Butler except tons of thee best looking women out there for his picking.He doesn’t know what love is or has any desire to know.It requires sacrifice and putting others first.Love is for grown men not little boys.

angelsrock @ 11/23/2012 at 9:00 pm


After seeing most of Gerry’s interviews over the last 6 years, I agree with you 100%. He is trying to be funny. That is the bottom line. He is also trying to please everyone. When will he ever learn??? His quips are usually not very funny and sometime downright embarrassing, and he must learn that you can’t please everyone. As a celeb, lots of people are going to despise you. This is hard for someone like Gerry. Every now and again he gives an interview that is genuine and relaxed. But for the most part he does act like he has ADHD and has a hard time just answering the questions honestly and in a reserved manner. I also think he responds just to the interviewer. If the interviewer is a goof, that’s how Gerry responds. And vice versa. Bottom line, he says what he THINKS people want to hear. But listen closely because every now and then he reveals who he really is.

Untamable Shrew @ 11/23/2012 at 10:47 pm

Another thing,I read that Mr.Butler said “American men appear weak “.I don’t know if that’s true or not.I hope not.But if it is,time to pack your bags and go.He plays pretend.It takes a real man day in day out to work, raise a family,making marriage work.Maybe he should go back home and his mom could bring him down to earth.If he wants to be remember as a pig in heat-so be it.But he better be very careful what he says about Americans,it will backfire big time.

@angelsrock: Yes, Gerard seems to be inflicted with perpetual foot-in-mouth-disorder. Lol. He really is a big knucklehead and has managed to make that something lovable, and that is why so many here still hold out hope for a moment of epiphany from him regarding his career. We fans have heard it all before and the sad part is that after all is said and done, his box office scores aren’t that great lately. SO MUCH can be ignored when the box office is raging with sales. Still hanging iin there with you, Gerard.

I think that if you are going to make accusations such as that, you should at least post the link where you read it. Personally I have never read anything close to that.

Gerard Butler is average when he goes home to Scotland

He explains, “In America I’m seen as a very strong, masculine guy.

“But in Scotland I’m just like a lot of other guys. Back home in Glasgow, you probably grow up faster.

“You have to deal with more sh**, more realism. In LA, it’s a superficial, perfect world. In Glasgow, you’re expected to be a man.”

As you will see, that was posted in 2008.

Yes Lyla he has come up with some doosies but you did say
“and has managed to make that something lovable”, That was great and oh so true.

I’m glad some think that if you say its a joke after you say something it doesn’t give people a glimpse of who you are. It is as telling as anything you say.

@Hello: Since when does LA equal the rest of America.

@PsychoB: Because as I posted…in 2008 LA was his world.

dargabriel @ 11/23/2012 at 11:55 pm

Good evening JJ and friends. Prediction, butler stars in batman, big hit, sexy, superhero, yet dark. This is a deep vision. Also, hurry up butler get that place in san francisco and scotland as well, farm it up boyo, who knows, maybe I’m wrong.. Have a warm night. Love,dargabriel

@Hello: it’s his world we are just leaving in it. As It is for every actor

7' Tall Evergreen Tree @ 11/24/2012 at 12:06 am


Dar, I don;t know why you want him going to San Francisco—–Hasn’t LA been weird enough for him?

7' Tall Evergreen Tree @ 11/24/2012 at 12:13 am

Well he hasn’t been seen since the 21st. So I wonder where he went? He’s not due to appear until the 29th on Chelsea. He is so good at times, dropping out of sight for awhile.


After recent comment on Priyanka Chopra I think Gerard Butler gonna break up with his gf

Diana Guminski @ 11/24/2012 at 1:21 am

Gerry loves this woman. My kid loves this woman. Please stop hating her.

wiphoenix @ 11/24/2012 at 1:33 am

@Diana Guminski:

What woman. Can’t leave the tired subject alone can you? Let this thread be about Ger.

I would like to see him ina nerdy role, where he’s not always the object of desire. Like Liam Neeson in taken. Something where the story is tyenstar.

wiphoenix @ 11/24/2012 at 1:34 am

@wiphoenix: the star, typo.

What type of role would you gals like GB be in?

Mina Hanson

So my uncle was in line behind gerard butler in Europe!
9:37 PM – 23 Nov 12

7' Tall Evergreen Tree @ 11/24/2012 at 2:01 am

I would like to see Gerry do a very intense and dramatic movie with Densel Washington.

@wiphoenix: A period piece or Burns or Burns My gran & Grandad met Gerard butler at LA airport during the week and pink last year in New York always at the right place at the right time

I love it @ 11/24/2012 at 3:44 am

He just refuted the story about his starting a band and getting lessons from Johnny Depp. He says he never even met Johnny Depp
It goes to show that we can’t believe anything reported about him in the media. If the story sounds too fantastic, it probably is. This leads to believe that the married woman story last year is false, the Jessica Biel being the one that got away story is false, all the PC stories are false, the recent India story is false, the starting a band story is false, the sex in the port a potty is surly false – It’s all false and shouldn’t be believed.
what we do know:

He slept with Brandi – she admitted it

he started smoking again – we saw pics

He went to rehab – he admitted it

he is dating MG – he admitted it.
The rest is all hearsay, until we see proof or he or someone close to him admits it.

@I love it: Or, you choose to believe only what you want to believe no matter what is posted anywhere. I happen to think a lot written about him is true except the stories coming out of India. The Indian press loves recycling and embellishing stories to create gossip where none exists, especially when it comes to B-listers like Piggy Chops.

Over the past couple years or so, I’ve come to believe he’s not a nice guy at all. I think he’s an egomaniac with money. I never thought he was a good actor. His fangirls keep him on a pedestal, picking and choosing what to believe about him and still blindly following him for reasons unknown.

What about that story where he tossed a fan’s cellphone because she wanted a pic of him at a club? True or not? I think it could be true because we know he has a temper and sometimes he doesn’t want to be bothered. He seems to have put a velvet rope between himself and his fans. He’s almost inaccessible compared to the earlier days when he would spend several minutes with a fan or fans who met him on the street. Now he’s too good to hang out with the lowly non-Hollywood types.

Gotta say @ 11/24/2012 at 5:03 am

There are too many who are too eager to believe the worst, even when there is nothing to substantiate any of it.

incognito @ 11/24/2012 at 7:38 am

I think he does not want to be in a relationship! He was getting tired of it. I think that soon it will start to hate her! She has become an obstacle in his career! Apparently it’s the end!

@incognito @ 11/24/2012 at 8:16 am

Right, which is why he confirmed that he is in a relationship with Madalina. He sounds more like he’s ready to settle down and have kids.

@@incognito: Uh huh. And he still won’t say her name. And he’s still giving a long list of all the reasons he has trouble with relationships. You are in deep denial.

If it was a real relationship he would be saying her name openly and with love.Doesn’t feel comfortable talking about it ,doesn’t want to be in a relationship that what it tells me……

Hi lladies hope you all have a good weekend. Btw, @ incognito you have toremember baby steps for gerry.He did admit to having a gf and that is a step in the right direction. He ddoesn’t have to say her name. He knows that we know her name. Yet he is still wants to remain private about her. The way it should be. Don’t you think?.

You are hilarious. Being “giddy” when talking about it indicates joy, not the other way around. He corrected when asked about him being single and confirmed the relationship. He talked about having kids soon. This is the real deal regardless of how you try to spin it otherwise. Congratulations Gerry and Madaline!

@@Ggfblx: Although I agree he confirmed the relationship I don’t think a marriage with her or anyone else is gonna happen so quickly. He is getting older and this girl is just starting out. A lot to give up and I don’t think she would do it. I could be wrong. He’s just a man dating, nothing more. He’s probably realized the mistakes he;s made in hiding girls and I’m sure he doesn’t want to say anything about her that could come back to bite him. In the end, I think she’ll dump him just my thoughts.

Egomaniac @ 11/24/2012 at 9:08 am

Well, this article confirms for me that his ego is completely out of control. Some other things that pop out is that once again, he won’t say her name. He only seems to speak of it at all in some far away place’s rag, like the Uzbekistan Times, but never in the US or major European press, where he avoids it altogether. He is spending a lot of time here explaining why he has trouble with relationships, and that speaks volumes, because he’s setting up an excuse to get out, like usual. He is not the type to settle down, and he just said so, so even if he caved and got married, it won’t last. He’ll end up resenting her, and I’d bet he’s already feeling the strain of flying all over to keep it going. When someone makes a declarative statement about themselves, believe them.

I do think he is more into her than him, she likes the fame side of things but who can blame her shes trying to emerge into the limelight and work on acting career whereas his is slowly dimming, I think he knows his shelf life in HW is limited and give it maybe 2yrs or so he may be out of work if another 300 type doesnt happen he is still riding on that fame.

She looks the type like she wants to be whined and dined, luxury lifestyle etc even GB is a star he mostly doesnt seem like the classy man who wants the finer things in life. If they do marry or have kids by the time hes hit 50, she’l be in her 30′s and shel be maturer on a different level she will look for other things and with this relationship i do think she will do the dumping eventually.

Its shame really i always thought he was a bit intelligent but hes dumb as two planks of wood he should’ve taken settling down serious in his mid 30′s . He’s always on the run, and talks about travelling i hope he does realise when you have kids its all about stability and routine which i dont think he has a clue

incognito @ 11/24/2012 at 9:11 am

@@Ggfblx: Congratulate until there is nothing! For me, it just does not want to talk seriously about the relationship. Only an idi/ot would marry after 6 months of relationship. For him it’s just “It’s very nice,” and ….. “I never gave a proper relationship the time …” It’s his word!

He is a strange man, tells you to google the name of his gf. So he is aware of what is being said about him and her.
Google his name, not to many places talking about him and how his career is on the up swing with so many options on new projects for him.
It really seems like no one is interested in what he is doing anymore. His movies are panned before they even come out. The only sightings he gets are when he sets them up walking around.
He has been around 10 plus years and by now his acting should have improved to the point that he would be sought after for so many impressive roles and that has not happened. If anything it has gone backwards. I don’t know what he needs to do to change this but he better do something soon. He really can’t afford to many more box office flops.


I agree and a lot of times he says these things to please the audience he says hes not a flirt but truth is he loves women some men do they prob want as much as affection from different women thats why he prob struggles in relationships.He also mentions the glory of a star status and how a one time star told him how you miss it and i think that would blow his ego if a time came and people didnt recognise him or give him attention so i think he thrives on being known.

The other thing is that yes he does know all of us know who she is etc but by mentioning her would have been a bit respectful as she has left no stone unturned in mentioning him. Privacy can be measured in a lot of things but acknowledging someone is another

I read somewhere angelina watched freind ewan mcgregars new film and said she didnt recognise him in that film as he was so convincing in his character that you forget that star that he is. These are the type of actors who take their craft very seriously and make substance films that people will remember you for.

GB will be remembered for all the wrong reasons, womaniser, home wrecker dating superficial models and the 300 guy nothing worthy or respectable there

@lolita: Thats why it bothers me what he said in one of the interviews,that he had all the success. I hope he doesnt really mean that he doesnt really care about his career anymore.

Egomaniac @ 11/24/2012 at 9:30 am

@Mojo: The only people who know he’s seeing someone are the posters on this site and the one or two remaining fan sites. No one’s reporting on him or his personal life anymore. The DM printed the St. Tropez pics, but the comments were very unflattering, and hundreds of posters there basically said “uh oh, mid-life crisis.” He really has no self-awareness at all. Have you ever noticed that even the flattering tweets about him are girls who are equating him with his movie characters of years ago, especially PSILY, which really reels in the chicks. I’m a woman, but the one thing I hate about women is when they think an actor is actually the character they play in the movie. I think he is probably quite the opposite, and is proving that by his recent behavior.

He says in that interview he’s not a player LMAO who’s his kidding everyone in HW & out knows hes bedded more women than most of us can possibly imagine. Also hes oblivious if a womans hitting on him yeh whatever….. he loves it and he doesnt flirt but notices a pretty girl interviewing him my god, If thats not a man out of control dont know what is and hes acting no different to the way he was before expect mentioning gf for a change My thoughts and blessings are with Madalina goodluck your in for a tough job

@AA: I think he cares about his career I just don’t think the powers that be care. They bypass him for so many others. Look who is popular now and in the press for their ACTING not tabloid bs.
I think Gerry was told to clean up his act and picking some one with the reputation she has was his way of being defiant because he was being told what to do. I could be completely wrong but he did the same thing with JA and used LC because he was tired of the faux crap with TBH.
He also could really care about MG and he wants to see where it goes.
Who knows, only he does.
I am only interested in his acting career not his personal life. It’s to bad that it over shadows his career.

This man is full of sh!t its okay for you to roam around kissing for the paps and shoving it in everyone’s faces but not okay to mention her name lol….am i missing something here please someone enlighten me

@Eli: Typical lawyer. Everything they say is bs. I wouldn’t worry too much about Macaroni. I think they are very much alike. Both difficult. Both have massive egos. This is why it won’t work. Neither one will sacrifice for the other, guaranteed. They will use each other until one or the other either meets someone else or it gets to be too much of a hassle.

Hi i know all you guys are well wishers of GB and prob want the best for him but it annoys me when you believe all bullsh!t that comes out of these stars mouths, thats how they are they sell themselves and fools like us feel like they are something fantastic when theyre not, An everyday person who struggles to pay bills and supports his family is a fantastic person, a woman who doesnt flaunt her modesty and uses assets to become successfully is a fantastic person and a person who benefits others in some way is a fantastic person in my eyes. They are not ordinary people but extraordinary in my eyes better than any celebs

Red arrow me all you want

@Rimi: Good point. I don’t think I’ve seen any pics of him or his semi-annual piece standing in any lines on Thanksgiving, serving food to the needy. Or any other time for that matter. These two probably spend all day trying on outfits and posing in front of a mirror. I’m sure their conversations are mindblowing.

@Bulloney: Read a transcript of the recent Men’s Journal article. He mentions “her” name (he referred to her as “Maddie”) and he also called her his “girlfriend”.
Reading through page upon page of speculation about his love life and MG. OMG! Why do some of you care so FREAKIN’ much? GB is an actor, yet, most on here would rather discuss his love life (a bit, I can certainly understand, but to the point of obsession?) than his work projects. And newsflash: MG had nothing to do with CM flopping at the box office. Only a very small group of overly-invested fans know anything much about her. The VAST majority of his fan-base doesn’t give a s/hit who he’s dating, as it should be. Someone the other day called MG “career suicide”. Drama, much? Sure, industry insiders/investors might care if his name was linked to someone scandalous like Lindsay Lohan (with her long arrest record). But a European model? Naw. So, if Adrian or Leo or (insert name) had a movie flop…it would be their girlfriend’s fault? Come on…
And sadly, IMO, Gerry’s movies are bombing because he’s making bad script choices; it’s really that simple. Keeping my fingers crossed for PFK. He needs a hit…and I’d really like to see that happen for him.

7' Tall Evergreen Tree @ 11/24/2012 at 10:26 am

Oh Please—-he wouldn’t say her name and told them to look it up—-How dumb—–He could have said her name and said something like she is a wonderful woman.
Or what is even worse if he said that to try and end the conversation about her and hoping it would move along to a different subject.
Either way I wouldn’t appreciate it.

@7′ Tall Evergreen Tree: Okay, I never saw an interview where he told reporters to “look it up”. But he can be moody. He had no problem discussing her in Men’s Journal. But don’t we all, at this point, know that he doesn’t always treat women the best? HELLO! And I agree with you; I wouldn’t appreciate it either.
He could also be sick of reporters that don’t do their homework. Any reporter about to interview him should, at the very least, do a quick Google. His gf’s name could be easily found.


You know you cannot believe a thing he says when he says he doesn’t get that girls hit o him, that he’s so innocent and clueless, that he’s not a womanizer? Oh please…..


Yeah, remember, she’s a ‘supermodel’ that no one has ever of or seen.

7' Tall Evergreen Tree @ 11/24/2012 at 10:43 am

Another thing—no one would really know anything about their relationship if it wasn’t for her talking about it to tabs in Europe. So he knows she talks about him. So then that’s OK?

7' Tall Evergreen Tree @ 11/24/2012 at 10:47 am

Well evidently he is in Europe somewhere. I would assume they have met up again ——

Pitt, Clooney, Depp, Hanks, Cruise, Decaprio all have had flops but they also have had many hits with much critical acclaim. Gerry has not had that type of career. He needs a hit. PFK’s is going up against Twilight, 007 movie, and Pitt has a gangster movie coming out on Nov. 30th. There are also whatever else is coming out on Dec. 7th. Even if PFK’s was being advertised as a good movie to see, it still is going to come up against the ones that have already proved themselves as a hit. I wonder if it will make the top 5 movies for the week.
Bad timing, bad scripts haven’t helped him. The question is has he been offered anything else like the guys mentioned above have and if so why has he not chosen those roles over the ones he has picked. I have followed him for a while and it just doesn’t seem like he is offered those kind of roles. The above mentioned men will always get the roles that Gerry should have the chance to make but he is never offered. I hope PFK’s is a hit for him and that OHF is a bigger one. He needs this.

He’s never been in the habit of naming any of his girlfriends. This is no different.

As for everyone knowing who she is and that they are an item, I beg to differ. It’s only on certain sites and in the Romanian and Italian media who have been slavishly following her facebook entries that this has caused even a ripple.

Only on sites such as JJ and WO has this grown to epic proportions. Yet.

@Toronto: If anyone in the press looked up her name, they’d think she was still dating Leo, because that’s what comes up the most. In terms of the personal lives of celebrities, that’s what makes the money for the rags and the ET’s and Extra’s of the world. Look at the top of this page. Pics of private lives of celebs. To think people should only pay attention to the work is naive. That’s never been the case.

@wiphoenix: Yes, I’ve noticed that, these days, the term “Super-Model” is used very casually. When I was growing up, it was Cindy, Linda, Christy, Naomi, Elle and Claudia. That was pretty well it. (Heidi Klum came slightly later). These days….it’s anyone with a commercial!


LMAO so true hes acting like a school boy that hes so unaware of it all new to this environment i found it funny actually lol.
Also about mentioning the name pleaseee in mens journal he mentioned her in hurry when they saw her from far… and this interviewer asked him and he wouldnt say lol…so he couldve saved the man the bother on googling it as he found the answer eventually anyway so dont see the logic

Also if it was real gentleman he wouldve said shes called so and so and is a great girl proudly and wouldve introduced her name basic manners anyone!!! he was clearly feeling awkward and uncomfortable wonder why?? if i was in a supposed serious relationship with any guy i wouldve expected him to mention me especially if he had a reputation more so the point as it could be anyones guess

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 10:57 am

@7′ Tall Evergreen Tree: you obviously do not know san fran, nothing compared to fake hollywood, also LA is the scum of cali, the freakin sky is purple from all the pollution and snobs, yuck. San fran also happens to be where my family’s from, have some class. California is the best state, the golden state, also the richest state and most beautiful. Many peep can’t afford to live there, haha maybe gerrrrraaard cant afford it either, lol. If you’ve never been to san fran, maybe you shouldnt say a word. Most diverse welcoming city I’ve ever been too. Please don’t put my homeplace down. Oh one more thing golden gate bridge is voted #1 beautiful bridges in the world, so there. I now live in northeast cali and just as beautiful, cascade mountains. p.S., I do find other places nice too, but I’m protective of my place. Take care, Love,dar

I just dont get it the journo asked him a specific question on who she is and he wouldnt answer???? Im lost whats so hard or difficult or ground breaking by mentioning her shows how pathetic he is. He says hes private but mentions his mum and other family like anything he grows weird by the day

How insulting. Tell people to look up his GF’s name. Like don’t you know how important I am. Sounds like he’s bored. He needs to go back to work.

My educated guess is that when you are juggling a few women, you never name one as being your girlfriend. Google it, that’s funny.

Travelagent @ 11/24/2012 at 11:04 am

@7′ Tall Evergreen Tree: Makes sense that he’d go back over there now that he has a big chunk of time to kill. I bet he does it again after the promo tour for PFK, because he has nothing going on for months after that.

@7′ Tall Evergreen Tree: Why do you think he’s in Europe again? Did I miss something?

Travelagent @ 11/24/2012 at 11:14 am

@Sue: That’s funny. That was my take as well. That’s a tactic a man would use if he’s juggling more than one woman. My antenna went up when I saw that.

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 11:17 am

So everyone thinks gerard has bedded all these women, butler plays games, lots of them, however, he never slept with most of these, he does have religious values and beliefs, funnily this is all a game, there is no gf, hes playing with the media and gossip columns. He does have many girl friends, not one intimate one, also he is a **** they do indeed have a hen house, butler is half woman, so of course he’s surrounded by many, who gives a shiiieet. Just watch. My gosh people believe everything they read and hear, kinda makes me wonder how this world has been programmed, maybe some tweaking needs to be done with the masters strings, make this show more positive. Take care? Dargabriel

miami mama @ 11/24/2012 at 11:18 am

you Maddie fans are slipping, she posted she’s been sick in bed for the past few days at home, guessing that’s Milan

actually he is not too bright telling a journalist to google it up because there is a lot of stuff about her on google true or not that would not be good coming out before his movie in the US A tabloid editor could have a field day. Lucky for him no one seems interested.

His old MO was not to name current girlfriends -interesting he is reverting back to that after the MJ article He acts like having a girlfriend for a few months is a monumental feat when we know from his own mouth he has had much longer relationships that no one knew about it.

In terms of supermodels the most of the supermodels today are still the old guard as most of them are still working and the new guard is the higher profile VS models Heidi & on top of that heap and runway stars like Coca Rocha and even then you have to be a fashionista or interested in fashion to register names like Coca Rocha etc.

Designers decided they wanted their clothes to be the stars and spend less on the models. Designers like the fashion world prefer non-model , celebrities as their muse, and on the covers of the fashion and other magazines and even in photospreads because they sell more magazines.Gwen Stefani is more a supermodel than MG will ever be,

I hope Olivier Martinez did not damage Gabriel Aubry’s face in that scuffle, Halle sure inspires passion.

miami mama @ 11/24/2012 at 11:21 am

Heidi & Giselle, sorry Mrs, Brady

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 11:23 am

Sorry I stand corrected, is it fair to say, most of you? thinks butler has bedded all these friends of his, sorry if I offended anyone. But no one puts down my home place. He is sneaky, I will give him that. Batman baby. Love,dargabriel

angelsrock @ 11/24/2012 at 11:24 am


What direction would that interview have gone if he’d mentioned her name? A quick detour from the subject at hand, PFK.


I just wanted to say I agree with you regarding your post #344

Well, life is not fair …
“Gerard Butler” = 17.100.000 results in google.
“Christiaan Barnard” = 381.000 results in google.
Analogously, the name of GB new girlfriend gives 1.400.000 results in google.

Let’s say that nowadays the person who performed the world’s first successful human-to-human heart transplant is not as interesting for the public has a lingerie model.

Does it mean that they are fantastic people just because more people pay attention to them??? Of course not! Nowadays people pay more attention to what celebrities have to say that what competent people have to say.

Ordinary people who work everyday to build a better world are extraordinary people … parents who take care of their children, teachers, doctors, nurses, scientists, etc. All of them have more relevant things to say than these movies starts … sadly no many people would pay attention to them.

Celebrities in general have the possibility to reach people; at least they could help these ordinary/extraordinary people to spread good messages to the audience, but sadly that is something we don’t see very often.

Gosh imagine being in relationship with him im beginning to think all the women did the running and never looked back and MG is the only one that tolerates his bullsh!t ..How rude to tell you to look it up, apart from a minority i dont think much ppl care about how he dates ive noticed on sites foreign no ones really said anything praise worthy of MG or him.

When celebs sign up to be a star they know that its part of the package your private life will always be flagged and under scrutiny, same with politicians its the image you build. jennifer aniston got more popular after brad and used to her best advantage, hugh jackman, matt damon married ordinary women who weren’t models or beauty pageant holders they were family men who directors, producers and investors took seriously.

Not some notorious womaniser who has serious relationships with only so called models, boinks married or reality tv nobodies & parties and hops on planes like theyre going out of fashion i certainly for one would bank my money on him. My mum always said a mans character and integrity can be measured with the type of woman he dates or marries his defientley says a lot

food 4 thought @ 11/24/2012 at 11:35 am

@Mojo: I agree. He has that romanticized view of parenthood, where he would have a little friend to do fun stuff with, and go to cool places. Oh please. Parenthood is great fun at times, but it’s also about walking the floor at night with a crying baby, making the school run twice a day, homework, playdates, ear infections. Temples in India? Parenthood is about staying in one place and making a life that is alien to him at this point. He can’t even stay more than a couple of days with his family. He would be bored to sobs after a week of taking care of a child. He always trots out his I’d love to be a dad litany when he’s promoting a flick like this.
And pathetic that he cannot say his girlfriend’s name out loud. She is a quasi-public figure, not Jane Doe from Smallville.

angelsrock @ 11/24/2012 at 11:36 am


He is not in their league; I’ll grant you that. And he probably never will be. But I enjoy the movies he does make. He seems OK with it. And never in a million years dreamed he would be where he is today. I really do think he sees a bit of himself in a lot of these characters he’s played lately. Of the actors you’ve mentioned, I can’t stand Cruise or Depp lately. I don’t think Pit is a better actor than Gerry at all. Tom Hanks was always one of my favorites. That string of movies: Philadelphia, Forrest Gump, and Apollo 13 was simply amazing!!

Why is it we can’t support him for what he is doing? In all of our jobs, we may strive to climb higher on the ladder and for many reasons we don’t make it to the top. That doesn’t make us bad at what we do.

I, too, hope that these next 2 movies do well; he deserves it.

If we take more negative out of our thinking, it leaves room for more of the positive.

Can’t believe some are rationalizing Butler not mentioning her name, give me a break!! It would be normal to mention her name at this point. He said they have been going out for several months. She is his girlfriend, why not say, “Her name is Madalina?” Big deal?! He is GOING to be asked questions about who he is dating & on top of that this new film is about relationships with women(mostly). He can’t escape that plot/theme. Doesn’t he have a publicist? Didn’t they discuss how he would answer questions? I mean since he can’t seem to just tell things like they are, then coach his a/s/s. Just look at the discussion here over this one point & it will fester…yikes.

more games @ 11/24/2012 at 11:40 am

@miami mama: Where’s home? Could be anywhere. It’s most likely a hotel in London. I doubt she has any apartment or house, since she was living with him in the US for months. This could also be more of her game-playing. She may have been in bed for days, but not sick. Note the link to the romantic movie? This girl plays games…remember that. It could be more attention-seeking.

angelsrock @ 11/24/2012 at 11:41 am

@3 months:

I’m sure they discussed how to answer the girlfriend question and this was their decision. The reason is not privvy to us here. And I can tell you if I thought that a boyfriend of mine would be picked to the bone daily on gossip sites and the media, I would want to keep it as secret as possible. You want to see mean people, visit a gossip site. Some are like wolves who just have the need to attack, no matter what.

So often people here ask who is Eve? I wish some long-time poster would clear the air. My memory isn’t that good for all things on JJ,but I seen ti recall several years ago in the midst of the Kyrie nonsense there was an Eve who also either claimed to be his GF or other posters thought she was intimately connected with him. It went downhill rapidly. Someone with a memory, please clear this up for all of us and let it be gone.finally.

@angelsrock: Angel, he took the time to say they were dating a few months which he acknowledged but to tell someone to google her knowing what they can find out about her was not respectful. You know they want to dig up as much junk on him as they can to sell their stories. He is just plain weird when it comes to woman. He managed to change the subject back to where he wanted it to go by saying he didn’t want to talk about it.
You know i like Gerry and have been a fan of his for a long time but sometimes I think he is off his rocker with some of the things he does and says.
He says he is a pr nightmare, well he proves that all the time.
I understand it must be a royal pain in the patoot to always deny most of the crap that is written and said about you. A job I wouldn’t want to deal with on a daily basis.

@angelsrock: yikes again if this is how Butler & his people decided to answer the girlfriend question! He already mentioned her & her profession. He opened the door then. Did he regret doing that? Who can say but you can’t put the toothpaste back into the tube. It is done so deal with it. Backpedaling only invites more speculation. Questions will only get more frequent & more detailed.

@lolita: If indeed he does read stuff written on the internet, then he knows for a fact what terrible things people are saying about MG. Maybe he’s just trying to deflect an ymore horrible posts about her. If he even just likes her rather than is in love with her, he would want to spare her any more of that kind of thing.

angelsrock @ 11/24/2012 at 11:56 am


Well, we all know he can be weird and unpredictable. That’s why I don’t understand why people still don’t get it. Saying to look it up on the internet was uncalled for. Not the first time he’s surprised us with an answer and certainly won’t be the last time. I personally think this relationship is on its last legs. Time will tell. As you know, if he would have mentioned her name and said a little bit about her, many here would have offed him for that, saying he’s just promoting her and she’s just in it for that. And that he told the interviews to ask that question. You know, really, he can’t win.

I’ve always liked Gerry for his quirkiness and fun. I am the first to say he would not make a good boyfriend/husband, and he knows that, too. That doesn’t make him a monster. I think he’s right up front with the ladies he’s taking home. And I also think it’s a lot less ladies than the media and we perceive. He is a true enigma.

@angelsrock: Angel, most of the actors I mentioned I am not a big fan of. I do like Hanks also. I have watched most of Gerry’s movies and enjoyed them except for TBH. I didn’t get to see CM because it was pulled before I could get to the theater. I hope PFK’s does much better and I know OHF will. I never expected his career to be where it is now either. I only hope he can get new roles that puts him back on the map to get the offers we both know he can do.

food 4 thought @ 11/24/2012 at 12:00 pm

@re eve: “Eve” was a fight-picking poster who lived here for a while – basically causing trouble and posting thousands of long-winded grammatically-challenged and poorly spelled missives that always ended in the word LOL. Eventually it got bored and left. IMO the current trouble-maker is not the same individual, despite the word LOL. All mean-spirited or obnoxious posters get tagged at some point with the “insert name here = Eve”.

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 12:02 pm

@imho: trust me he laughs and calls people ignorant through his thoughts, sorry but this is true. Love,dar

Him actually using her name again would be like waving a red flag in the faces of the haters. Perhaps he wants to let sleeping dogs lie.

angelsrock @ 11/24/2012 at 12:04 pm

@3 months:

Your are absolutely right. But remember, too, that 98% of the people that know who Gerry is, have no idea about his girlfriend and could give a flying leap. We here are in the very small minority. Many of those that saw that interview have no idea about his past references and history with Maddie.

Some people are going to rag on Butler’s behavior no matter what he does but really is that an argument for not mentioning her name?? that people on a gossip site might snark on him for that and shred him to pieces for it? and shred her too?? That has pretty much been happening here already in case y’all haven’t noticed…just saying.

@imho: then he shouldn’t have led them to where they will find it. That wasn’t protecting her it was outing her.
But I could care less it’s his life not mine and I don’t have to deal with the bs.
Just give us good movies. Show the world that MGP, Coriolanus and CM were not flukes but stepping stones to greater roles for him.

Read the article and all I can say is BULLSPIT! Next he’ll be selling swamp land. We have heard this over and over again. Go back and read his interviews for Nim’s. Same sh!t different movie.
And I can’t believe he could say he doesn’t know chicks are coming on to him. Just watch him walk a red carpet. His eyes are constantly scanning and when he finds something his predatory look hits his face. What about his herds? How many clubs have his buddies done the parade of shame for him with willing women posing for his attention. God give me strength.
Sorry girlies. This guy lies every time he opens his pie hole. Macaroni is just the latest idiot who thinks she can change him. Good luck with that. Many many have tread this tightrope and many many will in the future. Macaroni is a fool but she is getting what she deserves IMO. He doesn’t know how to be faithful. If she can live with sharing with others than more power to her. I just cringe thinking of all the partners they have had and the health issues involved. Ugh…
PFK hasn’t had a decent review yet. Why when I glance into Dargabriel’s crystal ball do I see Lifetime movies in his future???

@re eve:
Quit saying the name you may Beetlejuice us all…

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 12:15 pm

Well, lets hope butler is answering to the higher source like his other half is, so not cool, get your shat together butler, is that why your hiding, because your eye is swollen, hide behind your shades, quit projecting madness butler, not good for your life,career, and anything else in your realm, you say endure, well backatcha babes. Stop your madness, things will be better if you do or fight to the death, your choice. Butler it would be in your best interest to unconditionally love others with the heart. peeps just had to say. Love,dargabriel, sending light to this universal thread.

@Manny: Manny, how is your dad doing? Hope he is well.

Actually... @ 11/24/2012 at 12:16 pm

@food 4 thought: After watching the pattern for a few months, I would bet that LOL is the one who posts (insert name)=Eve. The troll has issues with Eve for some reason and was always attacking her and still does. A batch of those =Eve posts always pop up when the troll is hanging around.

justsayin'too @ 11/24/2012 at 12:21 pm

Just popped in and read the article. Whatever his relationship is I don’t know but it is obvious he is spinning his words for his upcoming movie. He wants to be a dad, right!? He doesn’t have a clue what being a dad is all about. He thinks it is all fun and games by his comments. It’s hard to be a great dad and you have to be willing to sacrifice your needs for your child and also stay in one place for more than a day. The more I know about him the less I want to know. His BS get old, every time a movie comes out his words are so contrived to fit the theme of the movie. Enough already GB and get real.

I agree he wasn’t protecting her at all. Wait until somene Googles her name and the escort sites pop up. I don’t think he cares at all. Maybe he likes the idea of people thinking she is a highend escort. If the p*rn star rumors were true then it may be his proclivity. Who knows. I wish he would get back to making a decent movie. This personal crap makes me nauseated. How f*cked can a person be who was beaten with the lucky stick???


I see your point but i dont necessary agree with it i dont think the interview wouldve gone another direction the journo is paid to promote questions related to PFK so it wouldnt have been a therapy session to discuss his private life so randomly he mentioned his gf but then said look it up. I dont think he gives a flying toss what fans thinks of her shes been dealing this like/dislike from romanian ppl to dating leo. anyway whatever rocks your boat but i personally think its more repectful when someone actually acknowledges you, nothing new just saying gf everyone knows hes was always surrounded by a particular gf, but again i do think he has slept around there are just too many accounts, stories, blogs and rumours theres no smoke without fire thats all i can say

having a child isnt having a little buddy on going on adventures its about giving them the best upbringing and stable childhood includes basically major responsibility does he even have a home that he properly stays in??

I think that answer was his ego talking … he really meant: “What? You don’t really know who she? Please google it and look at her pictures!!! Her name is not relevant at all here … what you have to do is look at her!!!! Look at that b***, etc. etc …. And please don’t forget to mention in the article that I am dating a hot lingerie model!!!!! What’s the point of having such a gf if people are not aware of her physical attributes!” ;-)

That is the probably the reason why he didn’t mention her … if the person doing the interview really didn’t know anything about her then her name wouldn’t have rung any bell.

I’m struggling. He is in good spirits but all my training and I can’t do anything for him. Hubby is keeping my spirits up but I’m heartbroken that he is slowly disappearing. Honestly Lolly I have never felt so helpless.
Back to Gerry… He needs to use his time off enrolling in acting classes IMO. He showed moments of brilliance in The Jury IMO but I think it was because it hit too close to home and was easy to draw from. He needs tutoring to learn how to not overact and bring his raw talent to the top.
I don’t hold up hopes he would do that because I feel he is too arrogant. It’s a pity really…


Oh Manny missed you lol….

i agree he selling the same bottle but new packaging lol…i dont think he has a clue on what a good parent entails hes a great example the poor bugger would want to read on their parents his apart from 300 all his liaisons with women and hers the same and getting expelled from school for advocating underwear fantastic role models i say gosh what a messed up environment, for some reason i cant picture him in a supermarket loading the car with grocery

Just a little reminder of what Gerard Butler was doing on Monday night, well Tuesday morning at 2am…

I can’t even wrap my head around him and kids. Will Amy get a raise for all the diaper changing and babysitting of the “kids he wants?”

“Doing on Monday…” was that Freudian on your part??? Hehe

@Rimi: I think he had a good role model in parenting in Margaret. She raised and educated three kids on her ownwith only hte help of her mother. All the time getting her own higher education and working to support the family.

@Manny: Manny, sorry to hear about your Dad not doing well, keep good thoughts and prayers for him.
As you say back to Gerry.

In the interview did you all notice how he still talks about his accident making CM. I know he has to move on but I think CM hurt him in more ways than one without it being more of a hit for him. He must have nightmares reliving that moment. I don’t know how he bounces back and deals with some of the stuff he deals with in regards to his movies. I don’t believe every role he takes on is just for the money. I think he connects somehow like Angel said with the person he is portraying.
Maybe it’s good he has the attention span of a gnat to keep going onto the next project without letting it all get to him.

warm & fuzzy @ 11/24/2012 at 1:17 pm

He’s holding those girls in quite a bit closer than in his usual twitpics. Heh heh. Does everyone in L.A. look like a model? Seems so.

Curious if any of the Christian groups will be boycotting this latest film of Gerard Butlers. A much wiser move for Mr. Butler would of been to denied his aparent relationship with a women who is featured on Russian Porn sites.

Another Opinion @ 11/24/2012 at 1:22 pm

HAHA! For me his answer to the journalist to google MG’s name meant: Holly crap! Didn’t I ***** myself enough in Shreveport, in the South of France and in Glasgow for everyone to know that I am capable of dating someone! Didn’t I call the paps and hang around with students to make sure that they take photos and tweet that they have seen me with my girlfriend?! And please, I want you to feel sorry for me and forget about my rehab and playboy past, because as I told the press multiple times now, I had a near-death experience almost a year ago. I need your sympathy to sell this movie!

Totally Useless Information @ 11/24/2012 at 1:38 pm

GB just gave the I want a wife and kids interview. We’ve heard it many times. Remember what Playing For Keeps is all about and you’ll hear that theme related to GB’s personal life in his interviews. The reason he wouldn’t give little Maddie’s name is it would have interfered with the fantasy he is spinning about his life and movie and that is more important than she is. So now he’s not aware of women hitting on him. Isn’t that exactly what goes on with George in the movie. GB is so transparent in his interviews that I usually end up shaking my head and not even finishing them. I’ve seen those exact interviews before and nothing is new.

@food 4 thought:
“Eve” was a fight-picking poster who lived here for a while – basically causing trouble and posting thousands of long-winded grammatically-challenged and poorly spelled missives that always ended in the word LOL. Eventually it got bored and left. ”
No, it didn’t. The old hag is still here and kicking.
Trouble is its middle name.

“Angel, he took the time to say they were dating a few months which he acknowledged but to tell someone to google her knowing what they can find out about her was not respectful. ”
And what they can find out about him or any other star is not respectful either. Butler is so passed what Google says about him or anyone associated or linked to him. Only a bunch of hysterical fans still think it makes a dent in him what gossip rags say about him. He had 16 years to get used to it. Any girl who’s going to be with him better get used to it too.
I don’t think Maddie gives a flying F about any of her decisions, she did what she had to do. if he can’t understand it, then he has no business being with a model or an actress because they all did what she did to get ahead. And, if having previous BFs is a problem for him, let him bed 14 year olds because there isn’t a woman on the planet that didn’t have BFs before she met the “ONE”.
What type of nonsense is this talk? “If you Google her you will find not so nice things about her”, really? Do you think he cares? He knows it comes with the territory. If anything, it seems he doesn’t care she was LD’s short-term GF at some point. But you sure seem to care more than he cares??? Wake up, the fact he told them to Google her means he doesn’t care and he is happy with who she is. You need to do the same and stop making up explanations and analyzing this stuff to no end.

@simmy: As I said I don’t care who he is with or about his personal life. Regardless of who he is dating he shows little respect by keeping her as his official picture taker while he gets all the nods on his walk abouts. You seem to be analyzing things yourself or you wouldn’t have taken the time to respond to my comments. I haven’t said anything compared to what others have said about him and her. I just wish his personal life didn’t effect his career as much as it has. If he is happy in this relationship more power to him. It is his life and he can lead it the way he chooses.
If he doesn’t care what is written about him which effects his career then maybe he doesn’t really care where it is going.

Maybe some here think I am being harsh about him but i want him to succeed and be the actor I know he can be. He has proven he can excel in roles where he is directed properly. We shouldn’t judge his performances by his personal life but it does cross over into it. Is it fair maybe not but he is the only one who can change that. We are only his observers of his movies and his life, outsiders looking in.

Let Down Fan @ 11/24/2012 at 2:33 pm

If Gerard Butler and Madalina Ghenea are in a real relationship, I don’t think it’s what Gerry thinks it is. He says in the interview that he’s not comfortable mentioning her name or discussing her, but Madalina is out there answering questions about him from everyone who asks – where he is, why he’s not next to her on the red carpet, whether he visited her on set, etc. etc. etc.
The whole reason Gerry’s fans found out about the two of them being together months ago was because of the information that she was posting on her Facebook page, informing everyone that she was everywhere Gerry was reported to be, posting photos of herself in the same places that fan photos with Gerry were taken, posting the photos from their trip to Scotland, giving an interview saying she was in Manchester for the match that Gerry played in, all AFTER she was asked about whether she was dating Gerry in an interview in Cannes and new that the tabloids were watching them to see if they were together.
If he’s not comfortable discussing the relationship, why is he okay with her doing all of that? Gerry is the one the media is interested in. The only reason that they care whether Madalina Ghenea is dating Gerry Butler is because Gerry Butler is so famous. Yet she’s the one out there blabbing about it when he says that he’s not comfortable doing so?
And why is Gerry okay with all of that after he was so openly rude to Brandi Glanville for saying that she had been with him? He’s okay with it when Leo DiCaprio’s 23-24 year old ex-girlfriend let’s everyone know that she’s with Gerry but not when a 39 year old reality TV star does? Gerry chose to sleep with Brandi. Why is it okay for him to be a jerk when Brandi talks about him when Madalina has been doing the same thing and he seems okay with it?
Seems really sexist and elitist. It seems like the misogyny in Playing For Keeps that everyone is talking about – Gerry chasing his much younger ex to break up her marriage while rejecting gorgeous women in their 40s who desperately chase after him. Based on the reviews, that PFK plotline (intentional or not) isn’t making anyone look to good and it seems to be what Gerry does in real life.
I really used to like Gerry, but his films have just been so commercially packaged corn schlocky lame for SO long, and as a man, he seems really weak and disrespectful when it comes to women. He doesn’t seem to value women for anything other than shallow values and/or he’s just incredibly arrogant when it comes to the women he’s with and that blinds him. I DON’T THINK HE’S A BAD MAN. He seems like the type that would be a great friend. But beyond that, when it comes to women, he’s just ………. weak.
So being his fan is just impossible now because there’s not much to admire in his career and there’s not much to admire about him as a man. So I’m done. Thanks for Dear Frankie and 300 Gerry. Bye.

@Hahaha: You misunderstood me on two levels, haha. I meant Google HIM to find out who he’s currently dating; obviously not her (you’re right, old boyfriend info would probably be up). Secondly, I never said a celeb’s private life is of no interest. I know people like gossip. But with the vast majority of fans, the info is read in fun, and it’s not a big deal. I stand by what I said that only an obsessed few take the love life of a person they don’t even know, THAT seriously. And a few of them are right here on JJ.

@Totally Useless Information:

#409 – Totally hit the nail on the head, TUI. Anybody who’s been listening to what he says during any press junket over the years, should know by now that he tailors his spiel to fit with whatever role and film he’s talking about at the time. The spiel is even more obvious when he’s been promoting PSILY, TUT (the emergence publicly of the ‘manwho-re image’ which he actively promoted), TBH and now there’s another ‘romantic comedy/dramedy’ to promote, so here we go again… ‘girlfriend’, ‘relationships’ etc, etc.
I will also add that I highly suspect that the emergence of a ‘girlfriend’ this year, and the side-show that’s been played out for the benefit of bemused members of the public and an even more bemused Men’s Journal journalist, also has a lot to do with attempting to deflect away from questions about his near drowning last year, and particularly his rehab stint.
Advice and courses in “pain management” are available at every single doctor’s office or out-patient’s department/clinic at general hospitals. You don’t go to rehab, particularly a place like Betty Ford, for a “spring clean”.
Thus, it’s quite amazing how his ‘perfect woman’ just somehow materialised in front of him, isn’t it?

@Bex: it does appear that the tail is wagging the dog (though it is doing a clumsy job of it).

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/24/2012 at 3:27 pm

Hi Lolita. Beg to differ with you on the “attention span of a gnat. The man graduated with an honors degree and was hired by the most prestigious law firm in Edinburgh. He has a lot more going for him than we give him credit for. He is no buffoon and bet his house is in very good order as well. He acknowledged that he has everything he needs and appreciates where he came from is amazed at where he is.. living a charmed life. I understand what you are saying about wishing more for the talent you know he has. I do as well and merely along as an observer.
I think that he would make a very doting father and would love to see that one day. He realizes he isn’t getting any younger and as he said doesn’t want to have a child when he is in a wheel chair. He and Noah still keep in touch and think that was/is a special relationship. Looking forward to seeing the movie this time. Missed CM as well.

discussion re eve @ 11/24/2012 at 3:34 pm

@food 4 thought:

sounds like gfw….are you sure they aren’t the same person?

@Lord Love a Duck: Hi Ducky, Gerry is one intelligent man but he himself said he has a hard time focusing. I was just being a brat with that comment. I don’t really underestimate his intelligence. I never said anything about him not being a good father. If that is what he is heading for I hope it works out for him. Noah and Gerry have a nice relationship and it is good to see that he has mantained it. Many actors don’t keep in touch after a movie has ended but Gerry seems the opposite in that regard.
I do think he appreciates what he has achieved and I only wish that he gets more respect for his acting in the future. I just hope one of the real powers in HW give him a chance in a real dramatic role, take that chance with him. Maybe if OHF is a big hit then they will take notice.

@discussion re eve: No it’s not GFW aka “K”. She has a very distinctive voice, and although she changes her goofy monikers constantly, she always signs her posts.

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/24/2012 at 4:09 pm

@lolita: Oh I know you didn’t say that about the father thing. Someone else mentioned it and was just commenting in passing. Still lamenting MGP and Coriolanus and not getting proper credit for two good movies. But, MGP certainly helped in so many other ways and brought to light a situation out of control.
So are we going to see this new movie or what. And NO you aren’t a brat. Love reading your posts. Ducky

Totally Useless Information @ 11/24/2012 at 4:11 pm

Just because someone is book smart does not make them street smart.

Ok I guess I’ve been on here for a few days ghost writing. I haven’t been on because this relationship is too annoying. What is true and not true is woven together. Tom Cruise picked Katie Holmes out of head shots, why not GB? GB is not going to get a” Katie” because that type is too wholesome. A questionable foreign model is right up his alley. She spins lies as often as he does. She is supposedly well educated but her back story makes no sense. They probably marry and have kids and then divorce, then MG can spill what a bad person GB is. Just like all the other self absorbed couples in the “entertainment” industry.

Yes, google her, it raises her profile, how clever GB. Did you think of that all by yourself? What would a grown up GB look like? No one will ever know. If he slows down like he keeps saying, he’ll still be gone all the time. GB and MG and all his other current and future tail will need to be kept in the lifestyle they are accustom. Poor MG will have to show pictures of GB from JJ and say there’s your Da “working”. But in the end I think GB knows divorce is expensive especially if it’s MG. So I’ll be shocked if she gets him down the aisle. Now wee bairns are a different story.

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/24/2012 at 4:21 pm

@Totally Useless Information: I am sure that growing up in Glasgow was education enough to last a lifetime.

@Lord Love a Duck: I will make it to this movie if i have to camp out at the theater.
I enjoy your posts also. MGP was a passion project for him and Coriolanus brought him memories of when he first started acting. I know sometimes when we comment here it is not perceived the way we are writing them and they can come off so different than what we mean. I like Gerry or I would’nt follow him. I just wish he built his career on a more stable ground. I just don’t understand the down turn his career has gone to. I honestly think he tries to mix it up and do stories that will appeal to the public. It only seems like they attach him to the rom-coms.

How is he going to promote Olympus Has Fallen? Talk about how dear America is to him and consider becoming a citizen? Not that he would but it would just make a good story and that after all is the point..

MG is getting the better of this relationship. Well, at least one of them should be successful at what they do.

@Realist: her back story is utter crap.
she left school at 14/15 yrs old to go to Italy to become a model and according to her, modelled non-stop for 10years. but in the same breath, she says she’s well educated??! absolutely crazy. it is one or the other. If she left school at 14, as she says, she is undereducated.

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 5:13 pm

@Realist: He can’t become a U.S. Citizen marrying a foreigner,so, maybe he will stay a foreigner. Who knows what the butler will do. Yeah manny, you still believing I use a crystal ball, huh, you must be really jealous of me to make fun of me, again i don’t need a ball, I like being balled though, haha. Also manny didnt your mommy teach you manners, such as when you make fun of people, especially someone who claims they are a nurse,lol, to be nice and not a bully, because karma fairy, will correct you or be proud of you, I can see you’re fake, and your nursing is as well, because if you truly love from the heart, you would treat others with respect, damn glad I don’t have a nurse like you, you mean person. Dargabriel

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 5:16 pm

I do respect nice people on here, definitely not the miserable ones. Butler attracts alot of evil peeps, shows the true colors of his spiritual madness, we reap what we sow. Dargabriel


I didn’t say he would become one but I wouldn’t put it past him putting it out there during OHF was more of a joke as to how far this hollywood silliness goes

About half way down the link

totalroyalty 24th-Nov-2012 08:51 pm (UTC)
last year, when I worked for a company where I dressed up in various costumes to perform @ kids birthday parties, two dudes drove by in a golf cart multiple times asking me for my number, if I wanted to go out to dinner with them later, etc. the main aggressor, the one with some kind of accent, seemed a lot older than me, like over twice my age. I was skeeved out. plus I was wearing zebra face paint, who the hale is into that?

then they revealed to me that one of them was gerard butler. When I actually overlooked his obvious age difference to me/ the IRLness of it all I did recognize him… but I was still like, ehhhhh no bai. then I read a blind item about him banging very young chicks because they couldn’t tell he was bad in bed. the end// lol

@Lord Love a Duck: Ducky, are you from Glasgow? Is it a tough city to grow up in? Buffalo, NY was a big industrial area with steel mills and auto plants, and other industries, most are gone now. Ford and GM still have some plants in the area. I thought Glasgow was on the line as an industrial city also. I kinda compared Buffalo to Glasgow in a lot of ways, including weather.

@bex: ok, I’m just joking, so nobody freak out, but…
A zebra? Didn’t he (faux) bang a camel in a film? Maybe that’s the costar he’s been pining for all along…

i dont think his philandering ways are gona be an overnight thing…relationships can be boring after you have possibly done everything together he has a wandering eye

dargabriel @ 11/24/2012 at 5:41 pm

@Realist: @Realist: Shoot, I do totally agree with you. I know I’m very happy belonging to America, I can see why many would want to be from american or be a citizen, we’ve much to be thankful for. I’m not saying foreigners shouldn’t be proud of their home place, just that we have many great offerings for others and we except all kinds of people. I’ve been told alot of very intelligent people hail from Scotland, thats cool. Love and light. Dargabriel

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 6:06 pm

Hi Manny, sorry to hear about your dad. I hope he gets better soon. My thoughts and prayers are with you.

For those who delude themselves into thinking  GB would make a good father. Absolute rubbish. He would be an awful father. Can you imagine all those young silly women traipsing in and out of his bedroom. My Gawd. If he had a boy he’d turn him into a misogynist. If he had a girl  he’d turn her into a needy self loathing wreck. Let’s be honest, some people aren’t cut out to be good parents, and from his actions GB is most definitely one of them. Alas he is so arrogant and selfish he will probably have kids and make a right pig’s ear of bringing them up.

miami mama @ 11/24/2012 at 6:54 pm

Oh Manny

“PFK hasn’t had a decent review yet. Why when I glance into Dargabriel’s crystal ball do I see Lifetime movies in his future???”

I cringed and yet I know your crystal ball is looking clearerday by day, Who is watching Lilo Liz trainwreck this Sunday, BTW.

Not buying it @ 11/24/2012 at 7:10 pm

No doubt one of the old hags that regularly posts here is behind that comment there. All in an effort to justify her disharmony and malcontent at the Madalina situation. I’m not buying it at all. A similar comment with variation was posted here many times.

miami mama @ 11/24/2012 at 7:14 pm

@Not buying it: You don’t buy that Gerry tailors his answers in interviews to the movie he is promoting in a way where you might question his ability to distinguish fact from fiction, reality from fantasy, If you aren’t buying that, you got your head in the sand.

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 7:16 pm

The PFK film sounds horribly sexist. I wouldn’t give a dime to see  a film like that.  It’s just a c**p vanity piece for GB. As someone said before, essentially it’s  about a middle aged man turning down the advances of gorgeous middle aged  women – who are generally  younger than him – to get a woman who is substantially younger than him. Misogynistic rubbish. 

here it comes- @ 11/24/2012 at 7:19 pm

Looks like LOL the hagling and her minions or alter egos are online – you can always tell when the negative thumbing is more than the general traffic should warrant. So predictable – in 3, 2, 1……………………..

Another Opinion @ 11/24/2012 at 7:25 pm

This girl’s story raises a red flag. It’s another example of Butler praying on teenagers and twenty something girls. It reminds me of the teen girl whose photo he took in Glasgow and of the stories of his posse herding girls for him in LA. There’s definitely something off with him. At the very best he has poor judgment and no impulse control. I believe he has serious issues which will become even more apparent as time passes by.

Totally Useless Information @ 11/24/2012 at 7:30 pm

So GB and his golf cart buddy were looking to take this young woman out, buy her dinner and than what? I am not liking the image I’m getting from the threesome part. Please, not two guys and a girl–unsettling to say the least.

Man do I feel the LUUUUV on this site! Let’s do something for Gerry for Christmas and wipe his slate clean. The man is in need of a visit from the Ghosts of Past present and future! And if we could put all our problems in a pile and trade with him, I’d bet we’d take ours back. Until we have walked a mile in his shoes, maybe we should crawl into his brain housing group to find out why before we condemn, lest we have done some of the same sins. Anyone game to forgive?

worse and worse @ 11/24/2012 at 7:42 pm

I am really anticipating a day when this guy is busted good and proper for the misogynist teen-chaser that he is. I’m ignoring this upcoming film. Time for him to go away.

dear gawd @ 11/24/2012 at 7:46 pm

@Another Opinion: I bellieve you have serious issues that lead you to believe any madeup smutty story someone posts on the internet. How naive. You remind me of the commercial where the girl obviously believes all on the internet and introduces her “French model” boyfriend she met on the net. Obviously an oaf and no French model.

Not buying it @ 11/24/2012 at 7:50 pm

@miami mama:
Don’t try to change what I said. I said there is no doubt that one of the old hags that regularly posts here is behind that comment there. All in an effort to justify her disharmony and malcontent at the Madalina situation. I’m not buying she is a young girl that got hit on by GB. A similar comment with variation was posted here many times. Now, don’t get me wrong. I do believe he hits on young girls, as most men who can get away with it do, just not on the owner of that comment. I think that’s totally fabricated.
To your issue, of course he says what he thinks people want to hear, but that’s called tailoring your comment to your audience. You have to make an interview sound pertinent to the situation or it sounds weird. It’s the first thing they teach you in law school if you’re going to be a litigator. He wasn’t going to be a litigator, but Gerry knows his stuff, let’s just say.

@Another Opinion:
“This girl’s story raises a red flag. It’s another example of Butler praying on teenagers and twenty something girls.”
That comment is fabricated. Get a life already. You sound 70.

I do not understand why so many of you keep harping that Gerry is a misogynist and treats women so badly.If he was so horrible with all the women he’s supposedly slept with, I would think we would have heard a lot about that in the past few years. Most people have reported that he’s a really nice, charming guy. So what if he sleeps with a lot of women? They could have said no, couldn’t they? Most men’s dreams are that a lot of women would sleep with them. It’s a male thing, ya know? Doesn’t say much about the women, does it?

He’s single, isn’t he? One thing I’ve learned in my several years on this earth is that all men who have a good and healthy relationship with their mothers and respect them, as Gerry does, is in NO WAY a misogynist. Gerry has indicated many, many times how important his mother is in his life. These kind of men DO NOT hate women! He loves women and is a flirt but so what? That doesn’t make him evil. If he has treated anyone so badly, how do you know they didn’t deserve it. Think “Fatal Attraction”. That’s the gamble you take when sleeping with strangers. I’m a terrible flirt and like men but I am not easy by any means. None of us knows him well enough, if at all, to know who he really is and you all know that.

@GEEZ!: A voice of reason. You and others who show a spark of intelligence will probably get thumbs down from the nuts.

livejournal @ 11/24/2012 at 8:16 pm

You do understand this story was told by someone who has a livejournal website. Which means you can read her other posts. She doesn’t sound 70 to me. Click on her link and you can read her rofile.Don’t know why someone whould make up a story like this one. If I’m gonna make up a story I at least want it to be a good one. Of ourse your probably one of his undying fannies that think he can do no wrong.

@Ducky, sorry if I was prying into where you live. I forgot for a moment where I was. I see by the thumbs down that posters let me know it was not appropriate to ask that. So Sorry.

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 8:35 pm


You are missing the obvious, look at  virtually all the women he has been known  to date.  No man who has any respect for the opposite sex  would continually date women who are so quick to strip down  to their knickers for the titillation of men to earn a crust. 

I’ve never seen him openly date a decent, educated age appropriate woman. Never.

I think he likes to think he has a lot of respect for his mother.  If he really did, he wouldn’t even dream of  bringing a woman like MG anywhere near  her or his family.  The man only cares about himself, all this charming Mr Nice Guy stuff is just a means to an end, which is getting what he wants – loads  of money, sex and attention.

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 8:54 pm

One day GB is going to slip up, and slip up badly with one of those young women he has such a strong predilection for,  and all these silly  phannies who still hang on to the belief that  he has a ” beautiful soul” are going to  have a nasty shock. It’s only a matter of time before they finally throw away their Mereck dolls. 

angelsrock @ 11/24/2012 at 8:56 pm


I’m sure his mother treated Maddie as one of the family while she was there, because Margaret has class. Now I’m also sure that when she gets the chance, she will let Gerry know exactly what she thinks of Maddie.

Another Opinion @ 11/24/2012 at 9:04 pm

@samy: Relax; I was just expressing my opinion. Everyone has the right to believe what they want to believe. You can turn the argument around -just because someone seems charming and funny in a couple of videos online it doesn’t mean that they can do no wrong. Actions speak louder than words. As Butler himself had said in the past, where there’s smoke there’s fire. I’ll leave it at that.

“Another opinion” is not the person with the blog; that’s who I said sounds 70.

As far as the blog writer, she is not behind the comment about Gerry propositioning her, is she now? That’s another party altogether.
So let me make it clear to some of you who like to intermingle and mix everything up in order to deliberately make your fraudulent argument plausible:
1) Another Opinion is outraged Butler is “praying on teenagers and twenty something girls….. There’s definitely something off with him.” Another Opinion is implying he’s a child molester. That makes her sound like a disgruntled old hag because Gerry has no interest in women her age.
2) Then there is the person who made the comment at some blog called, She is calming Butler tried to pick her up knowing full well how young she is. Someone said that sounds fabricated, I agreed.
3) Then there is the Blog owner ,who never said anything about Butler, just repeated the PC story
4) Then there is you, who is deliberately trying to cloud everything because you too are one of the crazies who are mad they can’t have free reigns here to make Butler look evil, user, molester trash, and why? Maybe because you’re upset he has a young hot looking GF and it’s killing you?

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 9:09 pm


I totally agree with you on that one.


I actually just think he’s pretty odd. He seems to not sleep and wanders around all night every night. All those instagrams are not faked. He’s an oddball. The commenter’s age has nothing to do with his strangeness. He’s weird, IMO his GF is also weird.

I think most of these fame hos have way more money than sense.

livejournal @ 11/24/2012 at 9:15 pm

The poster who told the story has a webpage on livejournal. Thast the only way you can post a comment is to make a page. That the one who I am talking about. Don’t know who your talking about. It doesn’t look like the poster “makes up” stories from her actual blogs. Once again don’t confuse the actual blog website with the posters website. Thats the one that you said was a 70 year old making up the story. Maybe this is just to complicated to understand for your small brain. Just pass it by.

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 9:18 pm

@ samy

There’s way much smoke around GB’s behaviour towards women for there not to be a nasty little fire.

@Another Opinion:
“You can turn the argument around “.
Funny, I am not changing the argument around. it’s some of you here that keep trying to twist it all up and change everything with common sense. Nice try!
“-just because someone seems charming and funny in a couple of videos online it doesn’t mean that they can do no wrong. ”
Here is where a simple-minded person like you would think we’re falling for some video. It’s called proof. We’re waiting for it. Until we have proof, it’s all hearsay, gossip, or lies. You are very selective in what you want to believe and what not. You’ll believe anything some person claims on the Internet without proof, so long s it shows him in a bad light, yet you wont accept he has a GF. Is it any surprise you get called delusional?

“The poster who told the story has a webpage on livejournal. ”
Please, the webpage owner is a blogger who has a post on the latest news on GB.

The person who spoke about him trying to proposition her, made a comment on that webpage. She is a commentator like we are commentators on JJ. She is not the blog owner. She is called TotalRoyalty. What don’t you understand here?

Why is it that every time someone calls Gerry out on being attracted to near jail bait they get called an old hag? Maybe young and middle aged posters ALSO think he’s a creep.

Hey guys notice any similarities between the way Samy posts compared to LOL. I guess she was tired of all her comments being thumbed off the board. Shes the only poster here that calls the rest of us “old hags”. Read her comments. Poor LOL , she must be lonely for someone to converse with. Whats with that older hubby?Doesn’t he want to talk to you??

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/24/2012 at 9:28 pm

@lolita: No, don’t be silly. That does not offend. No I am not from Glasgow, but had an elderly friend who left when the employment was a disaster, probably in the mid 50′s. Learned a lot. Independence should be interesting.
I don’t know about Buffalo, but have certainly heard of the extremely harsh winters. We will have to check in with each other when we see the movie. Camping out are we? ha Have a good evening Lolita. Going to finish decorating the tree.

Nice try.
Everyone that throws back your bs in your face is lol.

Grow up. Make a decent argument and then you won’t have to call people lol.

Wake up... @ 11/24/2012 at 9:31 pm

Samy has now used the words “hags” “delusional” “trash”, the usual bs. You guys are falling asleep at the wheel. It’s the troll and it’s time for thumbs, geez.

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 9:33 pm


I know you like the guy, but just look at the so called friends he hangs around with. If you had one iota of street smarts and you saw GB and his cronies walking towards you, I guarantee you they would make your skin crawl and you’d be sorely tempted to cross the road to avoid them. They look super sleezy.  

whatshedonenow @ 11/24/2012 at 9:35 pm

Gerard Butler does not give off a trustworthy vibe.

go away eve

@Wake up…:
Some of these words are the only ones that seem to have been successful in shaming you.

Some of us don’t agree with you, and we have borrowed them from the one and only lol. Can’t say lol wasn’t right at the end of the day. No one can talk to you rationally without you stooping so low to either change and twist the argument, or to call people lol. I was waiting for it. If I was lol, and I was trying to hide, I most certainly wouldn’t use her jargon. What would be the point?

Now can anyone on jj have a conversation that makes sense?

go away eve

CerealKiller @ 11/24/2012 at 9:42 pm

@whatshedonenow: So true. When I saw those pics of them all dressed up and roaming the streets in NY it gave me the creeps big time. They do have a very dark vibe around them. I don’t even want to know what they get up to.

@Lord Love a Duck: Thanks Ducky, have fun decorating the tree. I’ll let you know how I like the movie. Have a good night.

@Realist: I think a lot of you are overlooking the fact that Gerry can’t GET a decent and respectable woman. He’s simply not good enough. A decent woman would not put up with the baggage that he carries, his attitude, his disrespectful nature. Oh, they’d brag about having coffee or a meal with him or a kiss maybe.

But no one in their right mind who values their self-esteem would want to be his gf or wife. He’d be like Sonny Corleone on your wedding night to him. Ban.ging someone else when he should be with his wife.

I’ve thought long and hard about this and the only thing that makes sense is that his defenders (some live here and the rest at the fan sites) are complete enablers. They are the type of woman who would put up with verbal and physical abuse and stay in relationships because they are so lonely and desperate they “can’t live without him”.

HIs fan girls are scary. Always coming to his defense and raving about his shi.tty movies. There’s nothing nice or honest about him. He’s a user of women and all he cares about is his own pleasure. It’s really sad that he can’t even admit to an interviewer, “Yes, I have a gf, she’s sweet and nice and I’m very happy” and just leave it at that. Instead he has to come up with a stupid and arrogant retort.

I truly feel sorry for Maddie but she’ll figure him out in time. I don’t blame HER for his bad films and his arrogant disrespectful nature. He’s always been a jerk, IMO. It’s just that everyone is finally seeing how he really is…it can’t be covered up any longer.

Samy=lol=troll @ 11/24/2012 at 10:48 pm

Give it up LOL, are that desperate for come on to talk to?? Apparently you are. Your not fooling anyone, your the only poster who calls others who trash MG and don’t agree with you old hags, you seem to have a phobia about getting old. Cut the cr.ap and come clean or stop posting. We’re onto you and we will just keep thumbing you. You did this to yourself by insulting others instead of carrying on a civilized conversation.

Like I said, when you have no argument you resort to calling people lol.
I Laid out the facts about that comment on that blog, why no one here has anything of value to say about it? All you do is twist the argument and change the issue.

Then you have the nerve to call anyone with a point to make, lol. That makes you an old hag just as lol says you are. Not only that, but you are also a big coward. All you can do is call anyone who disagrees with you lol. How about making a coherent argument, or maybe you’re too drunk with grief over GB having a GF?


My point is that that the people like you are passing judgement on someone you don’t know based ONLY on what’s been in the media. Intelligent people know how much the media spins stories to get the most attention. You don’t even know 5 percent of his life yet you feel qualified to make disparaging statements about him. I know that any of you who were the subject of such judgement and gossip would be SCREAMING that people don’t know you and that most of the stories were lies and a spin on the real truth. Try walking in someone elses
shoes before you hang them out to dry. Let he who is without guilt cast the first stone. How about we investigate some of you and put it out there for others to judge how great a person you are?

None of them has a coherent argument to make.
They use some hearsay on some obscure website and turn it into the gospel truth. yet when they see direct proof – pictures – or hear a confirmation from Butler himself, they refuse to believe that stuff is true. How demented can they be?

God Bless yoou all! @ 11/25/2012 at 12:15 am

Colossians 1:13-14
New International Version
For he has rescued us from the dominion of darkness and brought us into the kingdom of the Son he loves, in whom we have redemption, the forgiveness of sins.

At least at imdb they are not so delusional about his girlfriend. Check this out:
“It’s great to read that he is finally acknowledging his girlfriend. I’ve always thought it was so strange to hide the women he dates. It seems like this relationship is serious. Especially talking about having children….

I have a bucket of popcorn and am waiting for GFW’s meltdown. Butler has finally replaced her.”

For a man who is”spiritual” I fInd it off that titles mean so much to him. But again he’s”spiritual” when it serves him to be.

@PsychoB: He uses the word “spiritual ” like bollywood actresses use “independent” to define they are able to do everything like western women. Yet they have very cheap hired help for all the things westerns can’t take for granted.

It is glamorous to both because neither really truly experienced all the ramifications those words bring.

Keep saying the word Gerry. Where there is no deep love or true service, that word does not apply.

Gerard Butler sighting wandering alone and a little disheveled around the Santa Barbara pier (him not me–I was disheveled but no alone).

Spoke to Gerard butler tonight though,legend.

@SeattlePulp One time I sat about three feet from Gerard Butler while he cried in public for like 20 minutes straight. It was awesome.

@SeattlePulp I don’t think so, but like six months later he checked into rehab. Abella Wyss is the little girl in the official trailer for PFK.
Gerry is also involved with Mary’s Meals and was the presenter to Magnus MacFarlane-Barrow CNN Heroes.

Maybe the haters of the truth about Gerry (the enabling fangirls) can face this post again.

I think a lot of you are overlooking the fact that Gerry can’t GET a decent and respectable woman. He’s simply not good enough. A decent woman would not put up with the baggage that he carries, his attitude, his disrespectful nature. Oh, they’d brag about having coffee or a meal with him or a kiss maybe.

But no one in their right mind who values their self-esteem would want to be his gf or wife. He’d be like Sonny Corleone on your wedding night to him. Ban.ging someone else when he should be with his wife.

I’ve thought long and hard about this and the only thing that makes sense is that his defenders (some live here and the rest at the fan sites) are complete enablers. They are the type of woman who would put up with verbal and physical abuse and stay in relationships because they are so lonely and desperate they “can’t live without him”.

HIs fan girls are scary. Always coming to his defense and raving about his shi.tty movies. There’s nothing nice or honest about him. He’s a user of women and all he cares about is his own pleasure. It’s really sad that he can’t even admit to an interviewer, “Yes, I have a gf, she’s sweet and nice and I’m very happy” and just leave it at that. Instead he has to come up with a stupid and arrogant retort.

I truly feel sorry for Maddie but she’ll figure him out in time. I don’t blame HER for his bad films and his arrogant disrespectful nature. He’s always been a jerk, IMO. It’s just that everyone is finally seeing how he really is…it can’t be covered up any longer.

@TeaCakes: How many times do you think your thumbed down message should be posted? Once should do it.

@Hello: You must be one of his enabler-defenders. Protecting him at all costs even though he’s done nothing to earn anyone’s respect.

He has my outmost respect as an actor. I am sorry for you that your contempt for another human being, such as you have will be your downfall and undoing. To slander another for no reason other than spite is not a good thing to do to yourself. Hope you find some peace in your life.
Matthew 12:36
I tell you, on the day of judgment people will give account for every careless word they speak,

Gotta say @ 11/25/2012 at 4:56 am


Why take this attitude just because someone disagrees with what you post? It seems to be standard practice at JJ to insult anyone with a differing point of view.

What gives you the right to say what you do? Do you know any of these things for a fact? Do you base your assumptions on second or third hand gossip posted by those who seek to undermine someone who has in some way offended their sensibilities?

Please don’t refer to all the unsubstantiated gossip of the past and the tired old “no smoke without fire”. That just isn’t good enough.

Perhaps it might be worth remembering that no one here actually knows this man, for all that there are those who seek to imply that they do. And no, I am not an enabler-defender. I’m merely someone who tries to see things from both sides and does not automatically soak up all the rubbish that seems to delight so many.

By all means thumb me down. It matters not.

angelrock @ 11/25/2012 at 7:55 am


Teacakes, we are not enablers; we don’t even know the man, just as you don’t. And why would you say that he has done NOTHING to be proud of. When you make a statement like that, you appear to have absolutely no credibility. There are many people who look for the good in people and there is a lot of good in Gerry. You read the gossip and embrace it and twist it and WANT it to be true. I read most of that stuff and just shrug because most of it is B.S. I noticed that not many people responded to the relationship he has with that little girl with cancer and her family. There are some here who despise him so much they refuse to find any good in him. In this day and age, being he’s a big star and all, why don’t these young girls and their families go big time with this? If it were my daughter, I’d be right there, in his face. And I would make life miserable for him. (20 somethings don’t count). And just so you know that I’m a fan, but not an enabler; I wholeheartedly disagree with his association with girls young enough to be his daughter. I don’t think this Maddie thing is a good relationship for him at all. I would love for him to find a nice wholesome woman his age. BUT he probably never will so we all have to get over that. The man has committment-phobia. Stop throwing mud. Life is too short to exude so much hate. Especially when there’s a heck of a lot of things to hate in this world besides Gerard Butler. I’m not scary. I am accepting and realize that just because others don’t have the same ideals and values as I do, doesn’t meant their evil and losers. When there is more than a tweet or tabloid newsflash about Gerry having S..E..X.. with a below 20 something or, or, or bashing someone’s head in out of rage, I will jump on your bandwagon. Although I will leave it behind me. You just won’t see me here anymore because I will not waste my time to bash him over and over and over and over and over. I will find much better things to do with my time. I have one question for you and those who feel the same as you: Why do you so badly want to see this man fail not only in his career, but in his life?

What’s with all the phannies showing up all of a sudden? Did the mother ship sites crash or something? Thumb all you want phannies, but you aren’t shutting down reality here. We’re not a bunch of koolaid-drinking enablers.

@Hello: Nice to see some good things said about him. So he has kept up his friendship with her and Noah. Kids see people for who they are. If Gerry was such a bad person these kids would not have taken to him. I hope little Abella gets well, she has the smile of an Angel.

exfantiredbyallthebs @ 11/25/2012 at 8:08 am

@bex: curious why no-one has picked this up to comment on. It really shows what state he was in last year, perhaps over a woman? I do hope his latest romance is not a rebound To get tied to a rebound relationship without realising is tragic for all parties.

@angelrock: Angel, I have wondered too how Teacakes hates Gerry so much. If he did something to her personally, maybe that is why she feels this way, but if not, where does this come from.
If this is how she feels about someone she doesn’t really know, what kind of life is she living that she needs to empty her hate onto him.
I am his fan and I LIKE HIM, just like you Angel i don’t always approve of his choses, but hate is never a good thing to live with, it only eats away at you.
Some of the things he has done in his life has given the haters a place to discredit him every chance they get because he lives in the public eye.
You can call me the board mommy or say I wear rose colored glasses when it comes to him, but you are wrong. He is not perfect and he makes mistakes as I have in my life choses but i don’t believe he is horrible person. He could have shown total disregard for Abella, but he hasn’t and not only her but her family see the real warm side of Gerry that we don’t always get to see.
The saddest thing is letting a gossip site make judgements on a person most or all have never met or never will meet.
I expect to be thumbed down but you know that’s ok, because I don’t hate him and until he would do something directly to me, I never will.

Can'tGetEnough @ 11/25/2012 at 8:36 am

Good Morning JJer’s. Hope you all had a nice holiday. Here are the Playing for Keeps Press Conference Portraits, courtesy of the Russian GB site. I don’t think they have been posted yet, but sorry if they are repeats:
Have a great day!

@Can’tGetEnough: Thanks CGE, nice pics, hope things are going well for you.

@exfantiredbyallthebs: Maybe this person saw him during his promotion for MGP when he cried a lot supposedly openly about the children of Sudan/Uganda. At that time, some of the posters here had a field day with him crying about that movie.

Can'tGetEnough @ 11/25/2012 at 8:50 am

@lolita: You’re welcome Lolita. Things are getting back to normal finally. How are you doing??

@Can’tGetEnough: I am doing well, thanks for asking. Missed you here, you always make it a better place to visit.

Gotta say @ 11/25/2012 at 9:05 am


No one wants to shut anything down. It’s about having another point of view that doesn’t call for insults at every turn.

It’s most telling that anyone who seeks to give a balanced view is routinely thumbed down. A balanced view simply isn’t wanted at JJ.
Too bad.

@Can’tGetEnough: We saw a full size billboard for PFK last night. Almost ran off the road, lol!

@Gotta say: You are hilarious. It was Teacakes, with her “other point of view” that was getting thumbed into oblivion and getting lectured by fawning phannies last night. She was getting ganged up on by your ilk ffrom the motherships for saying anything negative about him. “Balanced view” my as.s.

@Gotta say: I think more people that come here dislike Gerry more than they like him that is why there is so much negative about him. I like him and don’t believe everything I hear about him. So because of this I will get thumbs down, but that is ok because it is how they feel about my comments. I don’t have a problem with that because their negativity will not change my opinion of him. Like I said he will have to do something directly to me to change that. i wish I could say everyone that I have read here that I like but I can’t, I just have to deal with it in my own way.

On a brighter note, Our first snow fall of the season is happening now. A soft covering of white touching the ground, so pretty.
Have a good day JJr’s.

@WTH?: Ah, Teacakes stated (and you’re right, EVERYONE has a right to express themselves, this isn’t a fan site) basically, that Butler is a bad person who’s done NOTHING to earn anyone’s respect. So, a few people defended him without swearing, insulting or yelling (using all caps). So, if you disagree with someone who dislikes/hates Butler, you’re a “fawning phannie”? Is there no middle ground? (like me! I like a few of his older films, but I’m not really a HUGE fan). But you’re almost as bad as the troll, who calls everyone an “old hag” if they should disagree with her…..just chill out.

What is frustrating to me about Butler now is that he has achieved such success in a very difficult business to do that but acts oblivious. There are thousands and thousands of actors who have enormous talent & skill but for one reason or another haven’t even come close to his level of recognition and financial security. It is painful to see that he somehow manages to get work but each new offering seems to falter, hugely. I don’t understand why he hasn’t been choosing roles or making a full commitment to the serious ones(besides Coriolanus) that will challenge him to go deep. I believe that he has it in him BUT he is completely distracted and absorbed in his vices. You can argue that the vices are either women or substances or both, whatever…Those have taken an enormous toll on his career focus in the last few years. He has had opportunity in roles to go deep but I think he avoids that because that requires vulnerability, honest commitment and trust. I don’t think he can do that…yet. For example, if he wants to play American, he should be working on the accents/regionalisms and speech every effing day! Day in and Day out, he should be drilling words(regardless if he is working on a project or not) and I bet he isn’t. Looking at the criticisms he has been receiving in his films, critics have trouble getting passed the accent and it may seem a small point to a lot of people here but that one thing is very, very important. I think he can do it, it takes work and dedication and focus but until he dispenses with the vices and distractions, IMO people should expect more of the same behavior for a long time to come.

Cosmopolitan, another no-name magazine with MG on the cover.

angelsrock @ 11/25/2012 at 10:41 am


Enjoyed the pics! Thanks, CGE! Have a great Sunday!! Ravens Vs Chargers at 4:00!

angelsrock @ 11/25/2012 at 10:44 am


Hey, thanks, lolita!! The thumbs say it all around here lately!
I’m wishing the best for Gerry especially with these next 2 movies. If they bomb, I believe he has some tough choices to make about his career. Enjoy your Sunday!!

@angelsrock: Angel, don’t let the negative ever get you down. You are a kind person who sees Gerry for what he is, a human who has faults along with many good characteristics. We know he cannot be the monster some like to portray him as. I don’t think PFK’s will be huge but it will fair better than CM. OHF is the one that will make or break him if that fails. Then he will have a real eye opener on where his career is. Not many rom-coms of late have been setting the box office on fire that has all gone to the super heros or the 007 types. OHF will have a broader audience because more men will want to see it than sit through a chick flick. You have a wonderful day also.

Hi girls hope your all doing fine on this sunday.

Can'tGetEnough @ 11/25/2012 at 11:08 am

@angelsrock: You’re welcome Angel! Always good to see you, Loli, Lyla and all the regulars. So many moniker changes lately, I don’t know who is who anymore.
You have a great Sunday too.

@@Cosmo: Exactly. It’s the ROMANIAN version, which means nothing to anyone other than people in Romania. Wake us up when she does something of consequence. What are you, anyway, her agent? Why don’t you go over and hang at her fb page?

Wow, you just managed to insult all of Romania. Why is Cosmo there any less important to it’s readership than Cosmo here? It’s of great consequence to have the cover. Madi is well-known in her own country as well as Italy. Razza Bastarda is giving her more positive exposure as will Dom Hemingway which will be seen internationally. It’ll be wonderful to figuratively see you with your foot in your mouth in the next year. For now, we’ll contend with seeing it up your heinie.

@@Nice try: Keep dreamin’. I’d get used to the taste of your own foot if I were you.

Not gonna happen. You can post yourself into a tizzy attempting to malign Madi based on unsubstantiated gossip poorly translated. Doesn’t change the fact the girl is on her way up and with Gerard along to share.

fashionista @ 11/25/2012 at 11:45 am

@Cosmo: Only a certain kind of Italian woman would wear that dress, tacky – not blaming MG, she would have no choice in this.

@fashionista @ 11/25/2012 at 11:47 am

IMHO most couture is unwearable.

fashionista @ 11/25/2012 at 11:48 am

@@Nice try: She is on her way up as he is on his way down, we know how that works too

oh was that Romanian Cosmo they have a Romanian version ? well that explains the dress even more

fashionista @ 11/25/2012 at 11:49 am

@@fashionista: Hardly looks couture. Romania makes hot models, clothes not so much.

sunday musings @ 11/25/2012 at 12:01 pm

@Just wanna: Odd that would appear in a Fashion Magazine but then he was in Dubai for launching of Roger Dubuis boutique, watch makers, so there would have been lots of fashion press around.

Has anyone seen any actual reviews of MG’s performance however in her new movie? That award was not for acting and really should have gone to the director if you believe what the award is actually for, bringing social issues forward. Gassman as director, producer, screenwriter and lead actor is the one who was bringing social issues awareness. He must be another one of her conquests which is why she was o the podium and not the other actresses who had LARGER ROLES and at least one has garnered critical praise but yes MG is on her way up on the easy track. Show me some reviews from non Italian or non Romanian critics ie independent reviews that scream about her acting talent and not her T &A and I will reassess. Brooklyn Decker was in a movie too clearly as obligatory eye candy for the male movie audience.

angelsrock @ 11/25/2012 at 12:03 pm

@Just wanna:

That story seems to be floating around. Now you know he would never throw his precious cell phone across a room!!

@sunday musings @ 11/25/2012 at 12:08 pm

Actually the award was for acting also. Gassman is married with a child and his wife was alongside of him in most of the group pictures.

“Attorno a lui un ottimo cast in parte recuperato dallo spettacolo teatrale, in parte arricchito di nuove presenze come l’incantevole Madalina Ghenea, o di cammei come quelli di Michele Placido e di una ritrovata Nadia Rinaldi.”


“Around him a great cast partly recovered from the stage, partly enriched with new appearances like the charming Madalina Ghenea, or cameos like those of Michele Placido and a renewed Nadia Rinaldi.”

Morning Lolly and CGE. Unfortunately if Gerry lays any more box office eggs I’m not sure he is going to get many more opportunities to lose money for the studios.
I wish he would spend his time off in acting classes fine tuning his craft. Whomever posted the dialect comment I totally agree. He should be working with a dialect coach ALL the time. If he wants to play Americans he should sound like them.
I wish totally and completely that he would embrace Pinkerton and play the lead. It would be a no brainier in my mind.
Until then Gerard Butler the side show marches on.

Once again the same story …

I just found interesting the sentence where they mention his gf.

It seems that not everybody agree with her “supermodel” status and here they just refer to her as “a Romanian lingerie model called Madalina Ghenea”

According to that articles it was HER cell phone he pitched.
I tend to think it could be true since monogamy has been something he hasn’t mastered. I think getting outted as on the hunt may have spurred his reaction. He is supposed to be in a “relationship” after all…

@@sunday musings:

That award was not considering acting skills, is just a social award … Francesco Castellani was also a candidate and he is a director not an actor.

Thank you for the link!

sunday musings @ 11/25/2012 at 12:41 pm

@@sunday musings: You are not too naive how many directors/actors show up with their wives to events having slept with their co-stars or even still having an affair????@Mmmmmmm:
Thank you for the backup!

Puttanesca @ 11/25/2012 at 12:43 pm

@Mmmmmmm: What do they mean by “social”?

@sunday musings @ 11/25/2012 at 12:44 pm

I’m not naive in the least. It is the same with all people. Some have affairs; some remain faithful to their partner. Your point?

@Not buying it:

Sean Bean doesn’t tailor his awnsers to interviews and is still more well known and well liked by audiences than GB

Puttanesca @ 11/25/2012 at 12:54 pm

@Manny: First thing I thought of when I read this a couple of days ago was that it was one of his old tricks of getting the press to do his dirty work. Everyone knows he’s p-a when it comes to breakups.

@Manny: Hi Manny, i was checking some other sites and I think it was gNet. It said that Gerry and Alan still have Pinkerton and September Shariz (sp) as possible projects for them to produce. I don’t know how far that has gone but at least it is still listed as potential.
I think he would be great in Pinkerton. I guess to support these projects he needs to also do movies.
I heard him in earlier interviews where is accent was so thick it was hard to understand what he was saying. He has come a long way but improvement is always a good thing.


The award is a recognition given to social issues addressed at the festival (and it is the third time that takes place at the RFF).

@Realist: Ok don’t get angry but according to some news about Sean, he is a drunk who gets into many fights and was recently stabbed in one of them. He also has been married four times so his track record with woman is not so good also. He does have a good career going for him.

@well well well: Wow, I didn’t realize how Sean looks now. That was not a very kind article about him. I have seen him in the LOTR and Game of thrones, I also thought he was good in the movie where he played an Irish terrorist with Harrison Ford.

Done that @ 11/25/2012 at 1:27 pm

@well well well: We’ve seen plenty of “disheveled” and “smoking” pics of GB.

@well well well: What do you mean? Crabbing over his looks or actions or both? Gerard never gets a free pass here, never. Sean looks just fine to me here, btw. Don’t know much about him. He’s a very talented actor, imo.

@Done that: Yes we have and it goes to show we all have our strengths and weaknesses that we deal with on a daily basis.

@Lyla J.:
Butler gets talked about here and “doesnt get a pass” is your opinion only. Ive read here for years and he gets offered passes here all the time. There are those who consistently make excuses for Him all the time. Does he deserve a break? yeah sometime. but after all this is a gossip site not a celebrity ego boosting site. I’m sure Sean Bean followers might say similar things on his threads.

well well well @ 11/25/2012 at 1:49 pm

@Lyla J.: Butler has not been fool enough to get married four times and create three kids to be buffeted among a variety of homes with wives and girlfriends.

Done that @ 11/25/2012 at 1:53 pm

Seriously, if it wasn’t for people giving him passes, he’d be a distant memory by now. Not too many get the breaks he has in life, and all because his “cute and charming.”

Boy that struck a chord. Sorry long time JJers. My attempt at sarcasm failed. I have a love-hate relationship with Gerard. Sorry to ruffle some feathers. Enjoy the day.

I for one am not buying the phone launching story. It seems pretty far fetched. It would seem a little more plausible if they said he yelled at the person (without grabbing and throwing the phone) or if the person took a picture without asking first, but I’m not buying this one. I don’t get that Chris Brown/Naomi Cambell/Mel Gibson vibe from GB.

Untamable Shrew @ 11/25/2012 at 2:23 pm

He had punch a paps in their face before.

@Untamable Shrew:
And a dog in NYC…

God Bless yoou all! @ 11/25/2012 at 3:45 pm

Psa 62:7-8
New International Version
My salvation and my honor depend on God; he is my mighty rock, my refuge. Trust in him at all times, O people; pour out your hearts to him, for God is our refuge.

Hair trigger @ 11/25/2012 at 4:08 pm

Believe what you will, but I think there’s been plenty of reports over the years of him showing flashes of anger, or worse, if you catch him at the wrong time. Judging by what I’ve read about him and his antics, I think he’s more than capable of throwing a phone if caught off guard.

Totally Useless Information @ 11/25/2012 at 4:30 pm

@Hair Trigger
I agree. The one time I didn’t agree with his throwing a punch was the dog incident where he was the person at fault. Then he and Alan made up a bad story about the other couple and their dogs which made me ashamed of GB. He should have just admitted to not having his dog on a leash and let it go at that.

The other time he threw a punch, I understood why he did it. I’d like to throw a punch at paps once in a while myself, but I’d rather not pay the price. GB evidently decided it was worth it. He shouldn’t have, but sometimes those guys need to be put in their place.

I would say if he threw someone’s phone, it’s because she took his picture when he thought he was in a no photograph area of the club and was caught off guard…or caught cheating, however you want to see it.

I see there were mommies on board last night–rather amusing to read their posts.

I am sad to read he was crying in public. If that little incident is true, I am sure he had good reason. Just because GB is rich and famous, handsome and charming, does not mean he doesn’t have feelings and worries like everyone. I do not like anyone being sad enough to cry tears in public.

Hope everyone has a good Sunday. I ‘m hoping I’ll see the last of the turkey today.

dargabriel @ 11/25/2012 at 4:30 pm

Good afternoon…. Dear manny even though you have written things to make me feel bad, I wish your father the best. I know you peeps on here like to thumb me down, but just know, I’m very important in regaurds to butler. I will say he’s very much incognito for a valid reason, has nothing to do with any woman, and hes hiding something, when you see him againhe will be healed, I know things very deep, there is someone projecting madness/ugliness. These emotions run very deep in the spiritual. Butler to all of you tosses the word spiritual loosely, however he is most certainly a deeply spiritual person and knows how to use this power. He will become an a lister, when the war stops, not what you think.Lord knows karma is very real, for every action, reaction. Come out,come out, where ever you are butler. Love,dargabriel

@Hair trigger: Other than punching a stalking paparazzi in 2008 wish you would name me another time “showing flashes of anger, or worse”. Especially the “worse” part.

Punching a dog is a lot worse IMO especially when the altercation was his fault. Sheeeeesh…
@dar, thank. You for the kindness. I’m still not a believer but cheers.

wiphoenix @ 11/25/2012 at 4:55 pm

@@Nice try:

The point is she is on her way up because of she screws. Natalie Port man was a famous kid discovered eating ice cream. She never screwed anyone for a job. She has beauty talent and ethics.

Clicks like Mass are a dime a dozen in Europe. She’s pretty and generic. GB likes a very superficial type of beauty, one that is very cookie cutter.

wiphoenix @ 11/25/2012 at 4:59 pm


I watched How To Train Your Dragon last night. He can act he can show a lot of emotion, but I want to see it too. I think he actually is afraid of his own power. He needs to stop throwing it away on women and conquer the world men instead, that he shied away from in law school. It keeps getting laid on his table and he walking away from it.

wiphoenix @ 11/25/2012 at 5:01 pm

@wiphoenix: That is success,a nd opportunity. I,m he’s sure gotten laid on tables too, but, beside the point… :-)

Hair trigger @ 11/25/2012 at 5:21 pm

@Hello: Manny beat me to it, but yes, hitting an animal for any reason is revolting. And the bogus stories made up afterwards to cover his behavior were equally revolting. Paps can be annoying, but violence is never tolerable unless the pap hit him or something. It shows what he’s capable of, imo. As for other accounts of his behavior, Google is your friend, and many tweets have been posted here of him behaving in a hostile manner towards fans.

With Scorpio as a dominant sign, you are a strong and astute person, complicated and passionate, sometimes destructive and intolerant, but strong-willed, tough and daring, sometimes bordering on aggressive. So many qualities and dangers combined in one person! Obviously, this often results in a natural selection of people around you: those who stand up to you or admire you and those who can’t bear you anymore! But that is precisely what you want. You are what you are and you are not going to transform yourself just to please. You are too proud and you never dread confrontations, although your way of fighting is secret, like your nature that, mysteriously enough, you are so reluctant to reveal even to your close friends who will never understand you. That said… what a hellish charm you have!

With Libra as a dominant sign in your natal chart, you love to please, to charm, and to be likeable. Moreover, you are naturally inclined towards tolerance and moderation, as well as elegance and tact, as if you were meant to please! Of course, you always find malcontents who criticize your lack of authenticity or of courage and your half-heartedness, but your aim is to be liked, and in this field, you are an unrivalled champion!

Capricorn is one of your dominant signs and endows you with a grave and serious style that seems to stick to you constantly. But if you have that reserved and cold side – as some extrovert people may think – on the other hand, you possess sturdy qualities: you are strong-willed and tough. Your long-term vision, your sense of duty, and your ambition are not affected by the derisory and erratic motions that seem to upset most mortals less steady than you. Besides, you are like a good wine, you age well and your natural solemnity or serious side paradoxically turns into an almost cheerful appearance, as you grow older. You are actually very sensitive when it comes to love. Faithful, caring, sweet, and sensitive, your behaviour is very different in your everyday, sentimental life. A golden heart beats under your tough and austere appearance…

dargabriel @ 11/25/2012 at 5:45 pm

@Manny: We all have our own beliefs and ideals, I know manny. You are welcome, please papa get better, to manny godspeed recovery to pops, have a great day, thanks for responding. Now I wish butler would be good and loving towards women always, he could really make a difference. Love, dargabriel

dargabriel @ 11/25/2012 at 5:54 pm

@wiphoenix: I agree with you, sometimes I wonder is this ignorance or just defiance on his agenda. He needs to project power in a God light and trust, things will balance, if this change is made. I hope there is a positive change. Have a great day. Love,dargabriel

What’s up with this “just google it” response when asked about his relationship?? I’m still laughing!
Why doesn’t Mr. Butler say her name? If he cares about her, respects her and wants people to respect his ability to be in a committed relationship, don’t you think he should fully disclose who the person is and confirm it? Is he embarrassed? Come on! LMAO!
It’s already out there so it’s not a secret anymore so what’s the problem? Why isn’t he “comfortable” saying her name? I don’t think I’ve ever heard him say it yet. Is he having trouble pronouncing it? If he says it then it must be for real? What gives? Enquiring minds want to know!
And totally believe the cell phone throwing tantrum. Sorry, but it seems when he’s caught doing something he knows he shouldn’t, like with his hands in the cookie jar, he gets upset, especially when it’s someone else’s “cookies”.
Thoughts, anyone?

80sGeorgeMichael @ 11/25/2012 at 6:27 pm

@Cupajo: ITAWY. I was trying to remember if I’d actually ever heard him say her name, and someone here mentioned that he did once in the MJ article. What I find bizarre is that when he was here doing promos for CM, there was no mention of her whatsoever. The only disclosure of the relationship seems to be offshore, and there’s very little of it. These two haven’t behaved normally since the beginning.

Amen. Cupajo, I agree with what you said.Its a good sign that he admitted he has a girlfriend but why be ashamed not to say her name.

He’s what I call a “one foot in, one foot out” kind of guy in a relationship. He rides the fence, so to speak. He wants to be able to make a fast getaway if necessary. That’s what a person does when they don’t have confidence in their own judgement. To be honest, I think he’s a bit afraid of the back lash he’ll get because of her age perhaps or he reads here, LMAO! Whatever it is, I was a bit taken aback by his cavalier response about his relationship. Not very nice really. If I was her, next time he called me for a “hook up” I’d tell him to “google it”!

Really, I think part of what Dar says is true about him. He’s very much “in tuned” with a spiritual side of himself but is afraid of that power, to afraid to let go and follow it. He has to completely let his guard down if wants to find true love and quit looking for it from the outside inward. He sabotages himself, chews off his own leg to get out of traps he gets in to. Right, Dar?

Amen twice to that Cupajo.

I’ve been a around for a while and just my impression of him and nothing more. I guess it’s easy to draw judgement on someone from a far sometimes when really you don’t know what’s going on. But a pattern of behavior speaks volumns for me. He’s got almost a split personality or persona. The good Butler vs. the badl one. Which one will win? Who knows!

Then we struck up a conversation with another guy we ran into about how cool it was to see him, trying to remember which movies he’s been in

Only after that guy we were talking to walked away did we realize he was Gerard Butler. Meta-Hollywood moment.

dargabriel @ 11/25/2012 at 7:10 pm

@Cupajo: very much true, but to me it seems like its a cruel game on his end, trust me in the spiritual, butler is alot more aggressive and is very controlling, but the weird thing, he has your best interest at heart, but even still, how can he keep dragging his feet about the real? I hope he finds true love, not even really just to be with her, but she can really bring light to all his life and many around him. Again, butler isnt in a real relationship, I know this. Take care, love dar

@80sGeorgeMichael: Yes, he was interviewed while driving in Shreveport. Then took the guy up in a helicopter, called her up to come outside on the dock and wave up to them and he called her “Madi” per the story. The interviewer called her very “modelistic” or something like that. See, he was showing her off to another man and that seems important to him. Merely saying her name was not enough. Too, it’s a Men’s mag so he may have hoped the interviewer would comment about her in the article without getting too close. But see that way, he could show off the house and the girl without exposing too much. Again, if I was her, I would have asked why the interview wasn’t conducted at the house and why he felt the need to “distance” her yet mention her. Butler’s a strange guy.


To start with I think that he didn’t want to go public, but he didn’t have any other option.
If you check the timeline everything is clear …
1) After Cannes and before the release of Supermax commercial everything was speculation (no pictures of them together, only MG posts in fb).
2) Then, when the Supermax commercial was released everybody confirmed that MG was in it and that she got the role after starting dating GB (they were together in May and the casting took place at the end of June) …
3) The comments of GB fans in the Supermax video was not good publicity … they were deleted immediately!!!
4) Then, damage control … Supermax and/or GB team decided to make up the story that they met while filming the commercial … thus, they had to admit they were together.
5) Surprise surprise … that was exactly when the MJ interview took place (which was not released immediately but in October).
6) Knowing that the story would be public soon they decided to make a public appearance in Natchitoches.
7) Once the MJ interview was released in October we have pictures of both of them in the South of France.
Perhaps he really doesn’t feel comfortable discussing his gf. He had never admitted before to be in a relationship, and he probably wouldn’t have admitted this relationship if MG wouldn’t have messed up everything by posting too much info in her fb.

@dargabriel: Hey, D, glad to see you around! I think he drags his feet out of fear of the unknown. He has an ideal in his mind he can’t let go of and it is in constant conflict with “the real”. He has to make up his mind if he wants to be happy or not and then let down his self conceived notions and go with the flow! I think he holds back, keeps things hidden, because that deep down voice is telling him to do that, that pull. Can’t articulate it as well as you do but you know what I mean. Have a nice night!

@Mmmmmmm: He may be uncomfortable about discussing a gf but it’s out there now. But my thing is why on Earth isn’t he with her now? Sure he’s doing some PR for the film but wouldn’t he be filming Motor City right now if it hadn’t been dumped? He’s got plenty of free time to spend with her between appearances and interviews and if she’s not doing anything, vice versa. People in love find a way, otherwise, it’s not going to work. You work around your schedules don’t you? It all seems very strange to me and almost contrived.

Nice convo tonight, guys! Much appreciated. It’s lovely when the board isn’t flooded with immature name calling.

dargabriel @ 11/25/2012 at 7:44 pm

@Cupajo: Hello again, cup, well the funny thing is, I can relate to spiritual realms, but yet I fail promises to my God, I know thats wrong and there is no excuses, funnily when I make a promise to someone in the physical I keep it. I feel butler suffers from blockages because of his other halfs ways, more than his. This is just my gut feeling. If you believe in spiritual wars, well there is indeed one happening for the butler. He is so pissed off, because his other half has given up on him, pardon me for saying but, butlers true love sees someone, it drives him mad, he knows this, also hi other half has a liking for one thing, margret would not approve, marajuana, so with this being said, there has been much karma from butler to the other, to butler, love is not free with his other half towards another, he’s smothering, ouch, puts up blocks,causing some pain in the physical and material, you can say somewhat of a nightmare. So thats my very complex description of the butler. We’ll see if victoria is right about his meeting with the other. Love,dargabriel

80sGeorgeMichael @ 11/25/2012 at 7:53 pm

@Cupajo: She managed to be with him while he was filming, so if she’s still filming he could do the same. Also, did I miss something? Do we know where he is right now? I just assumed he left around Thursday to be with her. If not, then I’m stumped since he has a large block of time right now. It’s interesting that she was so into leaving all the pics and clues, and now that they’ve supposedly gone public, she isn’t leaving trails of breadcrumbs on her fb, or any mention of him at all.

80sGeorgeMichael @ 11/25/2012 at 8:11 pm

@7′ Tall Evergreen Tree: Love the Russians! They are sooo good at sussing out info, maybe they can get on the case and figure out what’s up? The blond in the second pic down looks very familiar. She’s either a celeb or a celeb’s wife, but I’ve seen her a few times before (I think). L.A. people start to look alike, lol.

80sGeorgeMichael @ 11/25/2012 at 8:16 pm

Uh oh. Down thumb. The evening mommies are about to descend. Or the troll.

angelsrock @ 11/25/2012 at 8:20 pm


Do we know where he is right now? L.A.? I agree about him visiting Maddie; he should be with her, unless he is scrambling to find a project to work on. He really needs to form up some jobs just in case PFK and OHF flop.

And I agree about the maturity of the board over the last few pages. Good reading. Good opinions. And no immature name-calling. Very refreshing.

Have a good last week of November everyone!!!

SouthernBelle @ 11/25/2012 at 8:24 pm


New thread with pic of GB at LAX to catch a flight.

Lord Love a Duck @ 11/25/2012 at 8:29 pm

@7′ Tall Evergreen Tree: Thanks for the post. Gerry leaving LAX.
He has an interview for PFK’s tomorrow in Miami
Rosy ‏@asexiness
Did I mention I’m talking to Gerard Butler tomorrow about his new movie? #dying

Englisch subs interview

MG is telling a dubious story about how close she was to something that easily could have ended in a tragic experience… But what did really happen??? We will never know… it ´s therefore important, to be well educated, she explains, because all the other models who were involved when this happened must have been not so well educated… And how she wants her future children to be proud of her one day.
And that she won´t end up being a sl*t, so children and the young will look up to her, bla bla bla. Good job, Madalina! LOL, too funny.

MG is a good role model in this regard, hahahaha!

@what?: Too bad it’s too late. She is a ****, that sleeps with connected men to get ahead. She’s such h a hypocrite, being self righteous. Whatever. They all do it, she must have no self esteem. She keeps saying how educated she is. Where did she get her BA?

@Lord Love a Duck: not necessarily Rosy said it was a phone interview

Comment and Share!

You have of 5,000 characters left.

A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News | Advertise here