Top Stories

'Fifty Shades of Grey' Movie Poll: Who Should be Christian Grey?

'Fifty Shades of Grey' Movie Poll: Who Should be Christian Grey?

We were all shocked by today’s news that Charlie Hunnam will no longer be playing the role of Christian Grey in the highly anticipated Fifty Shades of Grey movie.

Now the big question on everyone’s mind is… who will be playing the coveted role?! We want to get YOUR opinion on who should be cast alongside Dakota Johnson in the upcoming movie based on E.L. James‘ bestselling book.

The two most popular choices are without a doubt Ian Somerhalder and Matt Bomer, but some other opinions we have been hearing are Chris Hemsworth, Alexander Skarsgard, and others.

Vote below and let your voice be heard!

Comment below to explain your choice or leave a different option!

Like Just Jared on Facebook

JJ Links Around The Web

Larry Busacca/Getty

273 Responses to “'Fifty Shades of Grey' Movie Poll: Who Should be Christian Grey?”

  1. 1
    Brittany Says:

    Henry Cavill. Period.

  2. 2
    kate Says:

    noo god no .not ian somerhalder.please no! i alredy sick and tired of him in TVD.please pick somebody else

  3. 3
    vote for...!!!! Says:

    Jonathan Rhys Meyers!!!!

    I don’t understand why his name didn’t come up yet!

  4. 4
    KokeAckles Says:

    IAN SOMERHALDER!

  5. 5
    Ashley Says:

    No one. Just don’t make the movie.

  6. 6
    Nic Says:

    I chose “others”. Jensen Ackles.

  7. 7
    Candice Says:

    Not matt bomer.. I mean him being a gay is a huge turn off for me. Hope they dont take him. Plz take ryan gosling or garett hedlund

  8. 8
    HCfan Says:

    Matt Bomer is the perfect choice.

    Henry Cavill can do much better than making this cheap awful movie, that’s why Charlie drop out, he knew it was a mistake and a bad move for his career.
    I’ts going to be so embarrassing to any actor to make this sxxt, Henry is perfect as Superman and admired by kids, Warner is not going to allow him to do this mess.

  9. 9
    Agnieszka Says:

    MATT BOMER !!!!!

  10. 10
    Darth Shader Says:

    Hayden Christensen.

  11. 11
    Rose Says:

    Max Irons. I hated Fifty Shades when it was the Twilight fanfic Master of the Universe, but I’d watch it if Max Irons was in it. He’s too good of an actor to even probably consider this hot mess of a movie, though.

  12. 12
    jOYLINN Says:

    @Brittany:
    I agree, Brittany!!!

  13. 13
    mel Says:

    gabriel macht! was i the only one who pictured harvey specter while reading the book?

  14. 14
    Leenah Says:

    Ian or Jonathan Rhys Meyers..Matt Bomer doesn’t give me the “man” vibe, he’s too feminine for my taste.

  15. 15
    laly Says:

    Anyone really… interchangeable bunch of pretty boy for a crappy role. Im just happy that Charlie and Garret are out.

  16. 16
    Anne Says:

    Only Ian Somerhand can do the justice to this role

  17. 17
    jOYLINN Says:

    I wish the casting crew would go back and read the book, especially the description of Christian Grey. There are only 2 that fills it — Henry Cavill and Matt Bomer. He is supposed to be drop-dead gorgeous that women practically faint when they see him, and would do anything he wants.

  18. 18
    Bibi Says:

    I know only in my dreams but MICHAEL FASSBENDER! He’s got that alpha male vibe that Christian’s got in the book. I know people think he’s too good for this but maybe they can turn the book into a decent movie.

  19. 19
    misbah Says:

    well i have always been really fond of matt bomer and ian somerhalder..but i will be ok with chace crawford too..though matt bomer is whom i pictured as christian grey from the very first day till now and may be forever..

  20. 20
    Bibi Says:

    @vote for…!!!!: He is hot and has a troubled man look. awesome

  21. 21
    misbah Says:

    and please drop that dakota thing too..and bring someone more like anna..umm like alexis bledel or leighton meestor..

  22. 22
    Fassdong Says:

    The fassdong duh

  23. 23
    Bibi Says:

    Fassbender is that good that he would add some credibility to the movie. To others would be a risky movie but for him… he is that good

  24. 24
    Bibi Says:

    I know Michael looks old and Grey is what..? 27 /28? but c’mon it makes no sense… he is too young to be a billionaire. I would make him older in the movie and cast Michael Fassbender if only i could :D

  25. 25
    pumpkin Says:

    I want charlie hunnam to come back!

  26. 26
    Laura Says:

    James Scott from Days!

  27. 27
    Joana CR Says:

    Wentworth Miller

  28. 28
    KP Says:

    No one should be Christian Grey, the “book” should be left on a shelf not made into a movie.

  29. 29
    Roberta Says:

    Matt Bomer!!!

  30. 30
    noura Says:

    sure ian somerhalder <3

  31. 31
    one Greyssed Says:

    MATT BOMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! #TeamMattBomerForever

  32. 32
    Sayer Says:

    Clint Eastwood’s son. Maybe Stephen Amell.

  33. 33
    Mary Says:

    @vote for…!!!!: ohh now thats something I’d watch..

  34. 34
    Jessie Says:

    The question isn’t who will be best, but who would agree to do this. Charlie probably had someone whisper in his ear, “Man are you crazy?.”
    Fassenbender? He wouldn’t do this piece of ca ca.
    .
    Christian was an abuser. The author had no idea what it’s like in the REAL S & M world. Yeah, they do it because they were abused, then they give up the life, get married to the dull, stupid girl and have kids. It happens all the time. NOT! Basically women are saying it’s ok for a guy to do that because he was abused. Sounds romantic eh? None of those women would last 10 minutes with a real Dom. Dom’s do not do it just to inflict pain and they don’t take on naive school girls. Christian was anything but romantic. He should have lived on the psychiatric couch or spent a good many years in jail.

  35. 35
    pup Says:

    MATTHEW BOMER end of story!

  36. 36
    olebrum Says:

    Neil Patrick Harris, Chris Pine or the one of the Carver Twins :)

  37. 37
    niagirl Says:

    Theo James.

  38. 38
    Rose Says:

    Kellan Luntz…so he can get that Oscar he’s been craving. LOL

  39. 39
    niagirl Says:

    Mickey Rourke was a eighties version of Christian and he made it work.

  40. 40
    amanda Says:

    How bout some realistic choices….the majority wouldn’t be caught dead doing this. And Henry Cavill? Superman? He would laugh at them if they offered this.

  41. 41
    Alexandra Says:

    these are my choices
    1.- Matt Bomer (even tho he said he wouldn’t do it)
    2.- Jared Leto xd (obviously he also would not go for it)
    3.- Ryan Phillipe (I think putting the tattoos aside he’s kind of a perfect fit hair & eyes color wise.)

  42. 42
    SaadGKhan Says:

    Henry Cavill should had been in this list.

  43. 43
    Kresto Says:

    Betty White!

  44. 44
    Bibi Says:

    I know Michael woulnd’t do this ”crappy” movie but you know what happened? People started liking to hate on the story because everybody else was doing it. Its a ‘trend’. you see… I watched ‘SHAME’ and to me this movie is pretty lame! It’s a pretentious ****** film. everybody was like ‘wowwww thats wonderful what a piece of art’ just because it was cool to like it and it was artsy whatever… its a shame that people like to go by other people’s opinion… The book is not wonderful but the story is somewhat interesting, the characters are catchy and Christian is very appealing. The writing wasn’t very sophisticated one may say but I honestly think they could turn into a very sexy and amazing movie.
    ”Shame” isn’t that big of a deal and Michael agreed to it… FSOG might have stood a chance in his eyes if people weren’t so damn hateful towards it.

    pardon my english.

  45. 45
    Kirsty T Says:

    No actor of any real value would touch this piece of dog poo. Read the first book out of interest and it was new and okay but know that I am done and wouldn’t bother with the movie. Most of my friends are the same.

  46. 46
    HCfan Says:

    Lady Gaga

  47. 47
    Nancy Says:

    ALEX O’LOUGHLIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    This man has a body that’s made for sin……

  48. 48
    Juju Says:

    Taylor Kitsch.

  49. 49
    xyz Says:

    ENUFF OF THIS 50 SHADES OF CRAP BULLSHIT. NO ACTOR THAT RESPECTS HIMSELF WOULD TAKE THIS “ROLE”

  50. 50
    Gracinha Says:

    FOREVER :IAN SOMERHALDER!!
    HE IS PERFECT.

  51. 51
    JJ THE EXPAT Says:

    I hope Ian Somerhalder gets it. He’s really a fantastic and charismatic actor. On the other hand, his schedule on Vampire Diaries would make it difficult to commit. I’m sure the producers of the film don’t want to have another Charlie Hunnam bailing on them. So my second choice is Matt Bomer.

  52. 52
    maggie Says:

    Henry Cavill. Alexis Bledel.These two are the perfect actors.

  53. 53
    Julie Says:

    Fassbender !

  54. 54
    Hailey Says:

    Tom Welling

  55. 55
    Amber Says:

    I’m sorry, but who ever takes this role is a moron and is going to look like a fool because they were never the first option.

  56. 56
    Carol Says:

    MATT for sure!! Yeah, thanks GOD the other actor changed his mind!! huahauhaua

  57. 57
    Amber Says:

    @JJ THE EXPAT:

    I would rather he not do it. It was said that he was never in the running. If he were to accept the role now, I think he would look kinda foolish.

  58. 58
    Sam Says:

    Paul Bettany is the one for me.

  59. 59
    Erin Says:

    Nobody. That movie shouldn’t be made

  60. 60
    Bibi Says:

    Well… since M. Fassbender is now a farcry from the obscurity days in Hex and wouln’t do it and since I picture Christian Grey being 35+ I would go with Richard Armitage. He is so underated, such a talented actor… if you watch him as Guy of Gisborne in Robin Hood you would totally see what i’m talking about. he is very masculine, virile… all man and he is unknown so i don’t think he would be very picky :/ i think there is a possibility he would take it

  61. 61
    Ana Paula Says:

    Ian Somerhalder <3

  62. 62
    CJ Says:

    Totally agree, just can’t watch a proud gay guy “making love” to a woman – I know it’s called acting, but I have to be able to buy into the fantasy!!

  63. 63
    Pamela Says:

    HENRY CAVIL!!! (L)

  64. 64
    Bibi Says:

    @CJ: Second that! I just don’t get this girls… It would be totally lame and would not pass credibility. I’m sure the producers know that.

  65. 65
    Bibi Says:

    @Bibi: these girls

  66. 66
    Bibi Says:

    What about Rob-James Collier? I don’t think his name has been said yet. He is great looking and might be a good choice… idk it just came up. i still stick to Richard Armitage

  67. 67
    Samantha Patterson Says:

    Shouldn’t we just leave this one to the porn industry?

  68. 68
    becky Says:

    henry cavill!!!!

  69. 69
    Cathie Says:

    @vote for…!!!!:

    Because he’s too old and too short – cute though!

  70. 70
    House Says:

    Efron!!

  71. 71
    ava Says:

    I think Luke Mitchell would be a good choice, popular in Aus but just breaking out stateside

  72. 72
    karl Says:

    The should just pick this boomer guy and name it fity shades of gay…

  73. 73
    Liverwurst Says:

    Steven Strait, or Jason Momoa

  74. 74
    caro Says:

    Stephen Amell!!! Just perfect.

  75. 75
    Ashling Says:

    This movie gets worse by the day. Only a C list actor would want this role.

  76. 76
    julie Says:

    Why no Henry Cavill name there?
    They should recast Dakota Johnson with girl that looks 22 not 34.

  77. 77
    Jess Says:

    Karl Urban!

  78. 78
    SHINE Says:

    Shia labeouf

  79. 79
    Amy Says:

    Other… An unknown actor with dark hair and blue eyes who has similar features to Matt Bomer, Ian Somerhalder and Henry Cavill.

  80. 80
    rdh Says:

    @Ashley: I totally agree!!! Don’t bother making a movie of that trashy series of books.

  81. 81
    Danielle Says:

    @Jessie:

    Jesse if you read the last book and the point of view from Christian–he thought she was a sub because she tripped in his office. He had no idea she wasn’t until later. And by then from the book–they were both very attracted to one another and wanted to give the relationship, such as it was, a chance.

    This wasn’t literature you know. And the author had no intention of making it a real dom-sub relationship.

  82. 82
    Vee Says:

    Darn, I really would have seen this movie if Charlie Hunnam was in it, however, if not him Jonathan Rhys Meyers would be great.

  83. 83
    Dd Says:

    Cavill

  84. 84
    Sara Says:

    Dakota needs to be let go too! They need to completely re-do this thing. She was never right for Ana anyway! They need to recast both roles and let her go.

  85. 85
    Liz Says:

    @julie: Henry should be there because he was always one of the top 3 fan favorites! Yes Dakota looks very old for her age and looks nothing like Ana, I’m hoping she will drop too or be replaced.

  86. 86
    CEH Says:

    Matt Bomer is GAY!!! He would NOT be believable as CG!

  87. 87
    p a m Says:

    Jim Carey

  88. 88
    55vineyard Says:

    I have no plans to see this movie, the book was boring as heck and I gave it away (thankfully I did not buy the book but someone gave it to me) and after 5 pages I have it away. Personally I think the movie will bomb after 1-2 weeks.

  89. 89
    Willa Says:

    Someone new like Francois Arnaud!

  90. 90
    Jen Says:

    Charlie would have been perfect as Mr. Grey. But if not him, RYAN PHILLIPPE please!

  91. 91
    jimmy Says:

    No actor in their right mind will touch this misogynistic ode to domestic abuse. Get Robin Thicke to do it, he hates women.

  92. 92
    jennifer Says:

    i thought that charlie was the perfect grey!, i’m tired to hear that everyone wants matt bomer as christian grey but he is no darker enough for the role! he is just a good looking guy but he doesn’t fill the role, i want ian for grey but also i’m scared that the movie will be bad for his career

  93. 93
    jennifer Says:

    but also if they want someone new i will put scott eastwood

  94. 94
    LovePattz Says:

    Who should take the part? Anyone who wants their career flushed down the toilet. Can’t imagine how they can make such a horribly written
    book into a ‘good’ movie.

  95. 95
    Slightly Amused Says:

    I voted other. I say Bill Skarsgard- He has similar mannerisms to his brother but is alot younger. Also, Some of his early swedish stuff is excellent ;p

  96. 96
    Honest truth Says:

    Henry Cavill or max iron!!!!:)

  97. 97
    Bobbie Says:

    Really People?… Just because someone is gay it doesn’t mean he can’t play the role, that’s just being rude and unfair. Either way, they should just drop this whole project, I’m not sure but I don’t think this movie will be as everyone is expected to be, I mean They should just leave everyone’s imagination to flow with the book. This movie will just ruin it.

  98. 98
    Lyn Says:

    If it can’t be Charlie Hunnam- then Matt Bomer!!!!

  99. 99
    Chevelle Kealey Says:

    Henry Cavill!!!!!! TOM WELLING!!!!!

  100. 100
    Victoria R Says:

    Chris Pine! He’s exactly who I picture in my mind when I read the books!

  101. 101
    mausam Says:

    Matt Bomer <3

  102. 102
    Janet Marie Cooper Says:

    There is only *ONE* CHRISTIAN TREVELYAN-GREY and his name is MATTHEW STATION BOMER!!!!

    Look at this man’s beautiful face, thick ache-to-touch hair, sensual lips, eyes the blue-grey of a summer storm, cheekbones sculpted by the gods, chest & abs that make angels weep and a sinfully perfect ass…Add that sexy velvet whisper of a voice and the wayhe LOOKS at a woman (see “Chuck” Season 1/Ep 10 or “White Collar”; or even as far back as “Guiding Light”)…

    NO ONE brings the heat like MATT BOMER can!!!

  103. 103
    Bill Says:

    Gerard Butler

  104. 104
    sarah Says:

    Ian Somerholder for me. But they need to change the actress.

  105. 105
    Valeria Says:

    There should be the option “please don’t make that movie”

  106. 106
    matt Says:

    Garrett Hedlund, Ryan Gosling, Chris Hemsworth, Hayden Christensen, Colin Eggsfield, Sam Worthington.

  107. 107
    Shades of Gray Says:

    Matt Bomer, it doesn’t matter wether he is gay. He has the body and the looks.

  108. 108
    mel Says:

    I feel Henry Cavill would have been the one for it but that won’t be happening due to him being Superman. My second choice is definitely Ian somerhalder….I’ve not seen Matt Bomer at work in anything as yet but he’s pretty damn fine hey!

  109. 109
    DocP Says:

    My vote is for Matt Bomer

  110. 110
    Linley Says:

    Ditto to Henry Cavill!

  111. 111
    pclain Says:

    Jason Lewis or Paul Walker

  112. 112
    Traci Says:

    Matt Bomer declined this originally. Smart guy! Too good for this!

  113. 113
    El Says:

    @CEH: moron, so is Henry, Ian and most other actors. It’s called acting idiot!

  114. 114
    Juliana Says:

    Ian is way too good for the role, he deserves better roles. I hope he doesn’t do it.

  115. 115
    N Says:

    Matt Bomer, no doubt! I pictured him while reading the books :P

  116. 116
    hello_kitten Says:

    @Ashley: agreed!

  117. 117
    R Says:

    I say they should just not make the movie.

  118. 118
    Ursula Says:

    Ian could use the work but would never get it, he flopped in film years ago. Matt is too good and too busy. This is just a poll for web hits.

  119. 119
    Martina Says:

    Ryan Gossling without hesitation! I cant imagine nobody else. If they dont cast him I wont go to the cinema to see thaa HIGHLY participated movie.

  120. 120
    abby Says:

    We can all agree that Matt is the actor we all see playing CG but the truth is that Matt really isnt that great of an actor. if we want a quality film we should have quality actors.

  121. 121
    Julia Says:

    I think Henry Cavill is the best!!!

  122. 122
    mfb Says:

    NOT IAN NOR MATT BLAHHHHHHHHHHH !!!

  123. 123
    mfb Says:

    @pumpkin: ME TOOOO

  124. 124
    Christi Says:

    @abby: LOL, thanks for your comment Ian! You’ll never be able to compete with the Bomer on any level. He’s the best actor that has ever been mentioned for it and the most classically trained.

  125. 125
    hey you there Says:

    Supermodel, Garrett Neff please.

  126. 126
    jill Says:

    i prefer Matt Bomer…..

  127. 127
    jill Says:

    Matt Bomer will do…

  128. 128
    beverley deren Says:

    Bradley James for fifty shades check him out!

  129. 129
    beverley deren Says:

    bradley james check him out!

  130. 130
    diz Says:

    Rupert Friend

  131. 131
    mimi j. Says:

    jonathan rhys meyers !!!!!!!!!!!!he has just these eyes….

  132. 132
    Mari Says:

    Jonathan Rhys Meyers!! no no no Matt

  133. 133
    carome Says:

    In my opinion should be someone unknown…. These actors are very famous, it’s better if is unexpected ….because even if some of them match for the role, while watching I’ll be thinking in the real actor and not in the role of Christian Grey..

  134. 134
    mal20 Says:

    Stephen Amell should be Christian Grey

  135. 135
    Janire Says:

    What about Rob Pattinson? Since he was the first choice and the book is a fan fiction of Twillight…

  136. 136
    Lia Says:

    HENRY CAVILL

  137. 137
    m126876 Says:

    Ed Westwick

  138. 138
    Julskay Says:

    Nathan Fillion!!!!!!!!

  139. 139
    Bianca Says:

    CHANNING TATUM!!!

  140. 140
    dee Says:

    Max Irons

  141. 141
    nono Says:

    Only way I would watch this movie is if they could get one of these actors:
    1.FASSBENDER
    2.RHYS-MEYERS
    3.CAVILL
    4. FRANCO

    …I haven’t even read the book I just think they’re hot

  142. 142
    Eve Says:

    So much HYPE over such piece of c..p. NO actor with a bit of self-respect would accept a role in an adaptation of that moronic, boring, terribly-written, rubbish, childish joke of a book.
    If actually say that some good actor should play in this rubbish, you are not their real fans.

  143. 143
    Anya Says:

    Henry Cavill!

  144. 144
    luke Says:

    Sebastian Stan <3

  145. 145
    luke Says:

    Sebiastin Stan would be perfect <3

  146. 146
    Ksanthipi Says:

    Henry Cavill (the best choice)

  147. 147
    QTPIE Says:

    Ian Somerhalder NO ONE ELSE Period!

  148. 148
    Eve Says:

    A bunch of idiots here….

  149. 149
    Blue Says:

    HENRY CAVILL or Ian Somerhalder.

  150. 150
    Deea Says:

    IAN,I’m not saying this because I’m a fan or something,its just that he fits the role perfectly

  151. 151
    Dee Says:

    No one, this movie should go away, it will be another a Eyes Wide Shut…a bomb.

  152. 152
    Funny Says:

    Robert Pattinson – because it’s the same crap like the Twilight-Series… ;)

  153. 153
    Elena Says:

    It’s gotta be IAN SOMERHALDER!!!

  154. 154
    Christina Says:

    Alex Pettyfer ! Matt Bomer would fit perfectly by the way he looks, but he’s not masculine enough for this role. Ian Sommerhalder is kind of too serious and experienced to me.

  155. 155
    hysshdd Says:

    has to be IAN SOMERHALDER

  156. 156
    Bárbara Says:

    Henry Cavill. I think they should choose someone who’s not that known such as Ian or Matt or Ryan Gosling.
    He’s beautiful, sexy and at the same time mysterious. I think it’s the perfect choice for the role of ‘Christian Grey’.

  157. 157
    Pauline Says:

    hahaha back to square on ! I want a tall dark hair blue eyes kinda guy is it that HARD to find ?

  158. 158
    guamaru Says:

    Ian Somerhalder

  159. 159
    LiiL Says:

    MATT BOMER!!!!!
    or Kellan Lutz willbe also a good choice :]]

  160. 160
    Jan Says:

    I thought Charlie was perfect!!! How about Jonny Miller, Angelina’s first husband. Sultry with an amazing voice. Do not pick a lightweight, gay-looking pretty boy. This is a man’s role and he should look and behave like a confident man.

  161. 161
    Ann Says:

    don’t make the movie

  162. 162
    Old macdonald Says:

    Filming starts next month. Ian is too busy filming tvd.

  163. 163
    Jan Says:

    Heath Ledger would have been amazing!

  164. 164
    Sarah Says:

    Chace Crawford

  165. 165
    vintagetrouble2 Says:

    Aaron taylor Johnson is perfect for this part

  166. 166
    Gaia Di Lorenzo Says:

    Stephen Amell!

  167. 167
    joanne schuhmann Says:

    Matt bomer is gorgeous, sexy,elegant and so talented. He is the perfect christian grey.

  168. 168
    joanne schuhmann Says:

    Matt bomer is gorgeous, sexy, elegant and so talented. He is the perfect christian grey.

  169. 169
    Love The Shoes Says:

    @Candice: Ditto! I don’t know why his name or any openly gay actor’s name would even be tossed in the hat! This book has readers; many MANY readers, female readers who are living vicariously through it and bringing it to the big screen requires a “straight” face to go with it. Don’t nobody get their panties in a knot for saying what a whole lot are thinking and none of us are homophobes or anti gay actor.

  170. 170
    Nicky Says:

    Wow. I had never thought of Rob James-Collier before! He is very handsome. It a shame that his name was never mentioned, it was never in the running

  171. 171
    MJ Taylor Says:

    Jonathan Rhys Meyers has my vote. He is so hot and can carry the role of Christian Grey with little effort. Why in the world hasn’t he been asked to do this movie?

  172. 172
    Leticia Says:

    anyone except Ian, he’s too good for that movie, he deserves better.

  173. 173
    moon Says:

    matt bomer is the perfect choice for CG. though i love Ian..i want only Matt to play christian grey.

  174. 174
    Summer Says:

    IAN SOMERHALDER

  175. 175
    ncazzz Says:

    other Henry Cavill!

  176. 176
    Hazel Says:

    @pumpkin:

    Actually, me too.

  177. 177
    Mary Says:

    Matt Bommer!!!!

  178. 178
    Cruizin596 Says:

    While I like Matt Bomer, I do not want to see him in this role. Matt has been wonderfully open about his sexual orientation…and I applaud him for that and support him, however, I would personally have a problem with him portraying Christian because of that fact that the storyline is sooo sexual in nature. Whoever fills the role needs to have no inhibitions and be willing to lay it all out there…whatever is required.

  179. 179
    Valentina Says:

    MICHAEL FASSBENDER!!!

  180. 180
    Mars Says:

    @Ashley: hahaha right on!!!!

  181. 181
    joyce Says:

    MATT BOMER *******! <3 hahaha I was so devastated by this news. Seriously, I already loved Charlie! I read fifty shades again and I visualized Charlie as Christian Grey. IT SHOULD BE DAKOTA JOHNSON WHO SHOULD DROP OUT!

  182. 182
    Perpetual Says:

    @Cruizin596: you sound so simple

  183. 183
    Says:

    ONLY Ian Somerhalder

  184. 184
    yeah Says:

    TOM HARDY.
    MICHAEL FASSBENDER.

  185. 185
    carol Lee Says:

    NOT a gay guy please!!! Matt or Ian would really be a turn off. Henry Cavill, yes!!!!

  186. 186
    carol Lee Says:

    Not gay ugly Ian.
    Stopped watching TVD because of him. Yuk!!

  187. 187
    Dina Says:

    DEFINITELY Matt Bomer! As soon as I read the book and saw Matt Bomer, I knew he’d be the PERFECT match for Christian Grey!

  188. 188
    raissakkk Says:

    Jensen Ackles. what a lot of fans are forgetting is the fact that Christian is blonde, so half that is list should go

  189. 189
    Rose Says:

    Tom Welling. I know he’s too sweet, but that could be interesting to see in another role

  190. 190
    Nora Says:

    Jared Leto. Seriously! Look up the video for Hurricane by 30 Seconds To Mars!

  191. 191
    Deb Says:

    MICHAEL FASSBENDER!!!!!!!!!!!!

  192. 192
    Monique Says:

    @raissakkk: Honey… He is a ginger. In the book says he has copper hair… just like Fassbender’s :D

  193. 193
    ses Says:

    @Nic:

    I SECOND THAT.

  194. 194
    Monyka Says:

    Henry Cavil definitely!!!!

  195. 195
    Idun Says:

    Alexander Skarsgard!
    He is the best Christian Grey.
    But I don´t really want him in the film because of the bad reputation that follows this film.

  196. 196
    ALICE EVANS Says:

    @Brittany: SAM CLAFLIN IS THE ONLY CHOICE FOR CHRISTIAN GREY….BUT HE NEEDS TO LET THE HAIR GROW ON HIS CHEST….HE’S SO MUCH SEXIER (?? YEAH, I KNOW, HOW? ) WITH GRASS ON HIS PLAYGROUND…. <3

  197. 197
    Alejandra Says:

    MATT BOMER<3

  198. 198
    Barbara Says:

    gaspard ulliel is a great choice, he has that mysterious vibe

  199. 199
    Ga11ia Says:

    Jonathan Rhys Meyers! There’s no doubt about it!

  200. 200
    Tessa Says:

    @Candice: you sound stupid and BTW, Matt declined this before they asked Charlie, who would ever believe Charlie was their first choice other than a delusional fan girl?

  201. 201
    CC Says:

    @carol Lee: LOL – you think Henry likes girls?

  202. 202
    Dasha Says:

    I know he refused the role but i only see Garrett Hedlund play Christian Grey. He’s beyond gorgeous, charismatic and very talented.

  203. 203
    Yeah Says:

    No one. Can’t we just cancel the movie plans and let those horrible books be what they are..

  204. 204
    💗 GFW 💗 Says:

    @Candice:
    “garett hedlund”
    -
    Perfect. He’s got IT.
    -
    But time is running out. This throws a wrench in the wheel for certain. Funny, STILL on book own, don’t like the kiddy-20-something angle of it, so am reading it slowly… but now I see Charlie. LOL
    ~K

  205. 205
    susan Says:

    MATT BOMER *******

  206. 206
    Amy Says:

    I voted for Ian. I hope all of you realize that Matt Bomer is gay. I don’t really think he’d be okay playing a Dominant, straight role when he’s clearly into guys. That’s just my two cents.

  207. 207
    Amy Says:

    @kate: please, tell me you’re joking!

  208. 208
    💗 GFW 💗 Says:

    I haven’t read the whole thread but has Liam Hemsworth been mentioned or Chris? Liam is in Love & Honor a Nick Sparks film so maybe he’s not into all “this” which I can’t blame him. Doms have nefarious beginnings. This is a dark, dark film.
    -
    And frankly, they’re going to have to skip 85% of it to make it watchable, even provocative. And how do they get to the “happy” ending in 2 hours? I know the author doesn’t give a flip making $5M on the movie rights, and way too much for these girlie-girl novels exploiting people’s inner pains.
    ~K

  209. 209
    scotty Says:

    SCOTT EASTWOOD!!

  210. 210
    Gabriela Says:

    Gaspard Ulliel, definitely.

  211. 211
    M Says:

    Dear producers, get Ryan Gosling if you can, he’s undoubtly hot enough and, most importanly, is a great actor, so he’ll definitely pull this one off with all the girls (and boys) salivating all over

  212. 212
    MariaF Says:

    Henry Cavill is the only option.

  213. 213
    Neil Says:

    Good god, how is it this even came to be? In the age of the internet THIS is a story? It isn’t that sexy, it isn’t that shocking, it isn’t that GOOD. It isn’t even as good as a lot of free stuff found right here. It’s basically regurgitated store bought pizza.

  214. 214
    Marina Says:

    Henry Cavill !!!!!

  215. 215
    GiGi Says:

    if cours Michael Fassbender

  216. 216
    Katey Says:

    MATT BOMER!!!! It’s obvious!!!!

  217. 217
    karla Says:

    Henry Cavill! Just look at him, he’s the perfect combination of cute and sexy. Matt Bomer is way too “handsome” and not very masculine!!!

  218. 218
    Jessee Says:

    Ummm JENSEN ACKLES anyone????

  219. 219
    SOOKIEK Says:

    Ian Somehalder would be perfect and close to the character and he can act ! We can hope for decent script even soft porn.

  220. 220
    Breanna Greyson Says:

    Matt Bomer! I mean, he’s perfect for the role. Almost everyones is petitioning for him, including me!

  221. 221
    hey you there Says:

    I agree. Don’t even make the movie.

  222. 222
    Vixen Says:

    The problem is that most of the actors on the selection list are too established to risk their careers on doing this role. Yes, the books are popular, but it’s basically going to always come off a bit seedy and porny. Whoever does this risks being the next Elizabeth Berkeley in Showgirls. At best, they will be Mickey Rourke after 9 1/2 Weeks. You need someone who’s still a little hungry, and clearly not afraid to do cheesy movies. I suggest Cam Gigandet. He has the look. And he was even in the first Twilight movie, which they could use to play up the fanfic relationship element of the books.

  223. 223
    Jen Grant Says:

    @Brittany: @Brittany: absolutely!

  224. 224
    carriestachnik Says:

    Ryan McPartlin!!!!!!!!

  225. 225
    joy Says:

    Liam. Hemsworth. Can anybody else see that Liam is way cuter than Chris? Plus, I really think he needs to show Miley something about being “dirty”.

  226. 226
    J.P. Says:

    Stephen Amell

  227. 227
    hope Says:

    IAN JOSEPH SOMERHALDER!!!! PLEAASSSEEE!!!

  228. 228
    raerock Says:

    JAMIE DORNAN!!!!!!!!#

  229. 229
    raerock Says:

    JAMIE DORNAN!!!!

  230. 230
    carol Says:

    I would love to see Joe Manganiello. He is hot on True Blood.

  231. 231
    kiala Says:

    brandon stoughton ….he’s a very really Christian Grey!

  232. 232
    Elisa Says:

    I would LOVE to see either Chris Pine or Channing Tatum play “Christian Grey”!
    http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1517976/

  233. 233
    Elisa Says:

    @Elisa:

    http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1475594/

  234. 234
    nikky Says:

    Matt bomer would be perfect, but he filming White Collar season 5 so he’s out unfortunately…. but Henry Cavill…!!!! OMG! He looks like Mattt Bomer and I think he could play Christian G.

  235. 235
    Mely Says:

    Brandon Stoughton!

  236. 236
    LAREIGH Says:

    @Brittany: I AGREE 100%

  237. 237
    citmyway Says:

    SCOTT EASTWOOD!!!!

  238. 238
    Amy Says:

    What about Gerard Butler!?!?!?! I personally think he would be perfect with his dark hair and greyish blue eyes & of course he is SUPER sexy…. :)

  239. 239
    Sara Says:

    Colin Egglesfield is perfect! please! Matt Bomer is beautiful man , but he has a face like a good guy…. mmh nooo!!!!!!! :’(

  240. 240
    Kina Perez Says:

    Why do people think Matt Bomer?? People you do realize that he is a gay man. How is he suppose to be a strong dominant forceful man like Christian Grey?? Yes he has all the looks but he have a soft face that is just too sweet not take control.
    Look into Colin Egglesfield. He is tall dark blued eyed strong cutie. When he gets angry you can see it on his face. He looks to be able to take control when he wants too.
    Try to find an actor who is not in the big leagues and give that person a shot to show who Christian Grey can be.

  241. 241
    Peggy Says:

    SCOTT EASTWOOD…..SCOTT EASTWOOD….SCOTT EASTWOOD

  242. 242
    Ellen MacLean Says:

    Jamie Dornan

  243. 243
    molollllllll Says:

    Matt Bomer/ Henri Cavill/ Ian Somerhalder
    Ana: Alexis Bledel/ Emilie Clark

  244. 244
    Jen Says:

    Taylor Kinney

  245. 245
    Joni Says:

    Scott Eastwood

  246. 246
    Shaylei Says:

    Alexander Skarsgård all the way! He was born for this role and he’s PERFECT for it! :D <3

    I still think the chick needs to be replaced too. Just me, though.

  247. 247
    Tabitha Says:

    Don’t tell me you have forgotten James Ford AKA Sawyer from Lost!!! He looks sexy, and kinky all in one!
    I think he was born Christian Grey!

  248. 248
    Strutter Says:

    You want tall, dark, sexy, confident and intense? Throw some grey contacts on Jason Mamoa! Done

  249. 249
    bob Says:

    this is ridiculous.

    When it was just an online fanfiction of twilight the main characters were Edward and Bella. Why dont they put them as they were the original couple since the beggining?
    just saying.

  250. 250
    carla davis Says:

    The very talented actor Ian Somerhalder is the perfect choice for the role of Christian Grey. He is sexy, very good looking, and mysterious. I could easily picture him as I read the book. He is the kind of guy who makes a woman melt. He is IT!

  251. 251
    kat Says:

    what about Hell on Wheel’s hottie Anson Mount? Look at his eyes, he is so sexy! He would be perfect for this role. He’s a great actor!

  252. 252
    S Riley Says:

    Find an actor that looks like a young Robert Redford and you have your Christian.

  253. 253
    mrs. Ian Says:

    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder
    Ian Somerhalder

  254. 254
    picchia76 Says:

    ian e poi ian senza ombra di dubbioooooooo

  255. 255
    salso Says:

    @nono: James Franco would be perfect!!!!!!

  256. 256
    salso Says:

    James Franco would be perfect!!!!

  257. 257
    Elle Says:

    Henry Cavill yum!

  258. 258
    Viking Says:

    Travis Fimmel.

  259. 259
    Anwenn Says:

    I am totally in favor of Alexander Skarsgard! I think he would be great and he seems to be interested in the part.

    I like Matthew Bomer and I don’t care about his personal life, however, I doubt that this is a role he would be interested in career wise and fan pressure won’t change that.

  260. 260
    fifi Says:

    DANIEL RADCLIFFE!!! He fits the role perfectly!!!!!

  261. 261
    Nise59 Says:

    I think Matt Bomer is the only one for the movie and I believe that he is Christian Gray it is written all over him. But I believe that the best person to play Chris twenty year ago check this out Joe Black “aka” Brad Pitt was make for this triolgy to bad E.L. didn’t write her books back then. No disrespect to Dakota but she is not Ana. Alexis Bledel is Matt’s Ana no other actress pair perfect on the trailer they was born to play the role. It’ all about the acting.

  262. 262
    Ian Somerhalder lover Says:

    Please Please let it be Ian Somerhalder!!!!

  263. 263
    Jennifer Says:

    I think Mike Vogel from Under the Dome would be perfect as Grey!!! I hope people agree.

  264. 264
    Rebcca Says:

    OMG Jennifer…..YOU are so right!!!!!!

  265. 265
    Terrie Wallin Says:

    Without a doubt, it should be Ian Somerhalder ! If you’ve read the books then it is obvious that he is Christain Grey ! And he is one fine looking young man which Grey is suppose to be as well…Come on , get it right this time ! Ian is the man !!

  266. 266
    Victoria Dietrich Says:

    The only PERFECT choice after reading the entire book series is Jim Caviezel, he’s tall, moody looking….just has the perfect look for the part. I love Tom Hanks, but too old!

  267. 267
    char Says:

    JAY RYANNNNNNNN

  268. 268
    EVA Says:

    ARE PEOPLE FORGETTING THAT THE FIRST CONTACT OS SUDUCTION AND THE EYES!!! IAN AND THE PERFECT CHOICE FOR THIS ROLE . HE’S MYSTERIOS, PIERCING EYES AND SEDUCTIVE LOOK IS WHAT STARTS THE ATTRACTION..SEDUCTION STARTS IN EYES AND NO OTHER ACTOR HAS IAN EYES. HE IS PERFECT IN EVERY WAY.. BODY FACE AND EYES..

  269. 269
    WENDLE Says:

    I think that Jamie Dornan should play Christian Grey because he’s not well known like the other guys and he’s super hot without being too hot, if that makes any sense. He is a model/actor and recently played the Hunstman on the hit show Once Upon a Time.

  270. 270
    CHRIS Says:

    zac efron

  271. 271
    tomhardybiggestfan Says:

    i think tom hardy should be chrisian grey he can be tough guy and a sweetheart all in the same movie check out warrior

  272. 272
    tomhardybiggestfan Says:

    tom hardy should be christian he can be a love character and a bad ass also

  273. 273
    maya Says:

    None of those, I voted for other because I think none of those people would make a good person for this role. I personally think Ed Westwick could be a great addition to the role since he already played the rich kid in Gossip Girl he knows how to play a part like this. He’ll also bring a lot of Gossip Girl fans, which is a lot since gossip girl was very popular, and will get more viewers! Anyone else think so?

A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News | Advertise here