This 'Bachelor' Finale Theory Involves a Contestant Sent Home Weeks Ago!

A Bachelor finale fan theory is floating around that some people think is too wild to be true…but there’s some intriguing evidence!

Fans are wondering if somehow, Kelley Flanagan, who was sent home weeks ago, might make a comeback!

First off, she was in Los Angeles, according to her Instagram account, at the time the Women Tell All was filmed. However, Kelley did not attend the Women Tell All, and the winner of the season never does.

But there’s more!

Fans have noticed that Peter Weber‘s mom, dad, and brother all follow Kelley on Instagram. They do not follow the final two, Madison Prewett or Hannah Ann Sluss.

While this is obviously just a theory, it would be interesting if it was true!

You can see the evidence in the gallery!