The 29-year-old The Vampire Diaries actor and Torrey, who stars on ABC Family’s Pretty Little Liars, were on their way to see Venus In Fur on Broadway.
“Venus in Fur. Incredible play; incredible beyond words performances,” Torrey wrote on her Twitter account. “If you can, see it!!”
Also pictured: Paul waiting for a taxi outside his hotel earlier in the day.
FYI: Paul is wearing the AllSaints Tonic Scoop T-Shirt.