Phoebe Tonkin Searches For Potatoes & Ketchup In NYC; Finds Shelley Hennig Instead

Paul Wesley holds hands with girlfriend Phoebe Tonkin as they cross the street during their stroll in New York City on Saturday (March 26).

The Originals and The Vampire Diaries couple was seen out just a few days before, checking out the city while on break from filming the shows.

PHOTOS: Check out the latest pics of Phoebe Tonkin

While there, Phoebe ran into Teen Wolf‘s Shelley Hennig — whom she starred with on The Secret Circle!

“True love on the LES looking for potatoes and ketchup,” Phoebe captioned with their fun selfie on Instagram.

10+ pictures inside of Phoebe Tonkin and Paul Wesley…