16 Things We Learned from Colton's Women Tell All for 'The Bachelor'

Caelynn felt secure in her relationship with Colton

Caelynn felt blindsided by Colton breaking up with her and many of the women considered her to be a frontrunner.

“He told me he was falling in love with me since Singapore. That’s a long time to be falling in love with someone. I was left standing there like, ‘What the hell happened?’ How can we have such an incredible relationship and then nothing?” she said.